Subject: Re: [AAA-WG]: Conflict between NASREQ & EAP AVP values

From: David Mitton <[email-masked]>
Date: Sat, 04 Oct 2003 16:44:56 -0400

On 9/29/2003 01:55 PM +0300, [email-masked] wrote:
>Hi all,
>
>It seems that NASREQ & EAP have allocated the same AVP codes:
>
>NASREQ:
>    Tunneling                    401
>    CHAP-Auth                    402
>
>
>EAP:
>    Accounting-EAP-Auth-Method AVP       AVP Code 401
>    EAP-Payload AVP                      AVP Code 402
>
>My suggestion is that NASREQ keeps those values, and EAP marks its AVPs
>as TBD.
>
>John

Umm... yes, NASREQ draft 11 renumbered the remaining NASREQ unique AVPs 
into a contiguous range overlapping the original EAP space, when it shed 
all of the EAP and Key Distribution AVPs, leaving it's original assignments 
looking like swiss cheese.

I think this is what was implemented:

NAS-Filter-Rule 400 = same
Tunnelling 403 => 401
CHAP-Auth, -Ident, -Response, -Algorithm 409-412 => 402-405

The EAP authors were notified at the time (2/19/03), as a new version was 
pending.
And there was discussion on the AAA-Editors list prior. (circa 2/5/03)

Dave.