Subject: [dnssd] Requirement #9: Proposed Edit

From: RJ Atkinson <[email-masked]>
Date: Thu, 24 Jul 2014 16:08:47 -0400

Existing text from today's slides:

         SSD should operate efficiently in all networks, 
         with particular consideration for potentially lossy 
         or multicast-challenged wireless networks.

Proposed revised text from today's microphone:

         SSD should operate efficiently in all networks.

Rationale:
	(1) The text to be deleted is superfluous given
            the phrase "all networks" that precedes it.

	(2) We ought NOT be trying to optimise IP services
            for particular link layers (see previous discussion
            about how the IETF handled IP multicasting when
            Ethernet switches first appeared).  

        (3) The current text appears to discourage use of
            widely-deployed, well-accepted IETF technology
            (i.e., IP multicasting).

Yours,

Ran Atkinson