
From nobody Wed Nov  1 02:32:52 2017
Return-Path: <asaeda@ieee.org>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 89D8D13F66D for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  1 Nov 2017 02:32:50 -0700 (PDT)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -1.9
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-1.9 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE=-0.0001, SPF_PASS=-0.001, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=ieee-org.20150623.gappssmtp.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 8-tuL3lcK8XJ for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  1 Nov 2017 02:32:48 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from mail-pf0-x22a.google.com (mail-pf0-x22a.google.com [IPv6:2607:f8b0:400e:c00::22a]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 (128/128 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 0A84C13F666 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  1 Nov 2017 02:32:47 -0700 (PDT)
Received: by mail-pf0-x22a.google.com with SMTP id a8so1532017pfc.0 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed, 01 Nov 2017 02:32:47 -0700 (PDT)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=ieee-org.20150623.gappssmtp.com; s=20150623; h=mime-version:subject:from:in-reply-to:date:cc :content-transfer-encoding:message-id:references:to; bh=OnmIfiRnnRxAqrKYJjD/hzf0Cm2BYmDLmVyaHBoZSIs=; b=CSmJQkkv6aW1ybZlW+4ChEUjAEtWmN21lXUWrdlS7Gav+dEGTnIONtoqao1F+SNFn6 QsbZ81NvPXvVuYgOp/T7/mPmM+QVk6fwd8IRvN5OI+KjSuFahroC0DIgyu90w9B75p80 j+K0SjyxGDl9XGf6XmHQySOT8JijZ7kumVkSu42hoax642mNgB5KCa7YKC4dvjyRyd81 Mypb5c2HJnXiqkXOyMc4axnR6PRdD8JikwNC4vrT26DPuBCAIRzbZPgBNSHRefy6SkcZ zggPyJCV6SORC3xUl2MzbdbsgLJGkZodc0tmt6GD37Mtwb0jqHM0N6O95aph3ULEXEhA N/AA==
X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:mime-version:subject:from:in-reply-to:date:cc :content-transfer-encoding:message-id:references:to; bh=OnmIfiRnnRxAqrKYJjD/hzf0Cm2BYmDLmVyaHBoZSIs=; b=mA8S+FUtrP7koolYyfmDfH9dEp9Bqni2JJF8LDVoDOrDLkcTNkJesu11wBmPCVC4fS qKdqZr3GJ2G7U/h3HdnfMQnFS2l45hU8jf530MOiLqeQJuYZbvQLw6jtDQRSAjA76+ck Aq3XB5CWcv9jEIrjS4kjahM9ucTBQT6Sm1tr5O9SPyk1mfx+jB1cK28quTO94ZJNDaOF yMQgAhEDWAH8uvOkpKXxzhZfhzfb896XTVhEBsI7O9X9pFgBgOysm7dC3sLeH9thmXb+ XhXO++52QPY0QvepDcYVRddXgAMJDU7JKsX0zTkEiafng57FXAnNTjmvVOd6OW+1pnFz 53nw==
X-Gm-Message-State: AMCzsaWtKVCXMqosVsJGE46+UCRruE2jpJV+yAtS2FN6w7bM0igubii/ JukmauIIOi/A+tIVWlshPg53Nw==
X-Google-Smtp-Source: ABhQp+Q2zWSmWL3Ot29l08TNEKkbzfyBCIqhPekU1RI2GLTcjxEqjxb366uCXXiTHHYbfmE7kA3BXQ==
X-Received: by 10.101.64.70 with SMTP id h6mr5302089pgp.144.1509528767287; Wed, 01 Nov 2017 02:32:47 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from [133.69.36.76] ([133.69.36.76]) by smtp.gmail.com with ESMTPSA id v14sm337061pgc.78.2017.11.01.02.32.45 (version=TLS1 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES128-SHA bits=128/128); Wed, 01 Nov 2017 02:32:46 -0700 (PDT)
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Mime-Version: 1.0 (Mac OS X Mail 9.3 \(3124\))
From: Hitoshi Asaeda <asaeda@ieee.org>
In-Reply-To: <CAHw9_iKFqz87Hd=8XPjtgcMcwax6Scba50aoSh=Z69tsd2dD8w@mail.gmail.com>
Date: Wed, 1 Nov 2017 18:32:41 +0900
Cc: MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>, mboned-chairs@ietf.org
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Message-Id: <B35AA6A8-5790-4101-949C-C919B240340F@ieee.org>
References: <CAHw9_iLt3XMdgEw6ZoMviG+zAEPLDH6jxJojvS_f+GP8GYODmQ@mail.gmail.com> <CF4E377C-A58A-45AE-85B9-EAD29A2EAB48@ieee.org> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1710302333340.9511@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <CAHw9_iKFqz87Hd=8XPjtgcMcwax6Scba50aoSh=Z69tsd2dD8w@mail.gmail.com>
To: Warren Kumari <warren@kumari.net>
X-Mailer: Apple Mail (2.3124)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/lEhaAZvnyt_JfthXJcVScsPDf2M>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] AD review of draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 01 Nov 2017 09:32:50 -0000

Hi Warren,

Thanks for your comments and reply.

>> Hitoshi- Warren will be taking the draft to IETF LC, and as he =
mentions,
>> it's best to address these items now to avoid issues later in the =
process.
>>=20
>> I think it's OK to wait until the cutoff is over to resubmit.
>=20
> Yup -- otherwise, because this is my fault (and the changes are all
> editorial) I'll approve submission if you want to submit before the
> cuffoff opens again.
> If so, please make sure to let me know.

Kerry and I discussed the revision and we believe we've addressed your =
comments.
Can I submit the revised draft before the submission site opens?
If I can do it, please tell me the way to do it.
(If not, I=E2=80=99ll submit the draft after the site opens.)

BTW, one point we=E2=80=99d like to inform is that we found ambiguity in =
section 7.3. (thanks to your pointing out:)

You mentioned;

> 7.3.  Packet Loss
> ...
>  Since the packet counts may be
>  changing as the Mtrace2 Request is propagating, there may be small
>  errors (off by 1 or 2 or more) in these statistics.  However, these
>=20
> [O] (off by 1 or 2 or more)
> [R] limit the =E2=80=9Cor more=E2=80=9D; otherwise, what=E2=80=99s the =
point of saying this at
> all? Perhaps "on the order of 1 or 2=E2=80=9D?


Instead of the following original statements:

By taking two traces, it is possible to find packet loss information
  by comparing the difference in input packet counts to the difference
  in output packet counts for the specified source-group address pair
  at the previous hop.  On a point-to-point link, any difference in
  these numbers implies packet loss.  Since the packet counts may be
  changing as the Mtrace2 Request is propagating, there may be small
  errors (off by 1 or 2 or more) in these statistics.  However, these
  errors will not accumulate if multiple traces are taken to expand the
  measurement period. =20

in the revised draft we mention:

By taking multiple traces, it is possible to find packet loss =
information
  by tracking the difference between the output packet count for the =
specified
  source-group address pair at a given upstream router and the=20
  input packet count on the next hop downstream router.
  On a point-to-point link, any steadily increasing=20
  difference in these counts implies packet loss.  Although the packet =
counts
  will differ due to Mtrace2 Request propagation delay, the difference =
should
  remain essentially constant (except for jitter caused by differences =
in
  propagation time among the trace iterations). However, this difference
  will display a steady increase if packet loss is occurring.

We hope this editorial change gives better understanding.

Regards,

Hitoshi


>=20
> W
>=20
>>=20
>>=20
>> Lenny Giuliano
>> Juniper Networks
>> Herndon, VA
>> 703-786-3398
>>=20
>> On Tue, 31 Oct 2017, Hitoshi Asaeda wrote:
>>=20
>> | Hello Warren,
>> |
>> | Thank you very much for your review.
>> |
>> | We will address your comments ASAP.
>> | BTW, since this C/O date was past, we cannot submit the revised =
document now. Whenever the draft submission site is opened again, we =
will do it.
>> | Can you chairs just wait for the IESG review process until the =
revision?
>> |
>> | Regards,
>> |
>> | Hitoshi
>> |
>> |
>> | > 2017/10/31 6:22, Warren Kumari <warren@kumari.net> wrote:
>> | >
>> | > Hello,
>> | >
>> | > Firstly, I'd like to apologize for how long it took me to review =
this
>> | > - I came down with a bad case of pneumonia, and was broken for a
>> | > while...
>> | >
>> | >
>> | > Thank you for your work on this document, it's a well written and =
easy
>> | > to understand
>> | > draft.  I do have a few comments that I=E2=80=99d like addressed =
before I
>> | > start IETF LC =E2=80=94 addressing these now will avoid issues =
later in the
>> | > process.
>> | >
>> | >
>> | > Section 1.  Introduction
>> | >   Given a multicast distribution tree, tracing from a multicast =
source
>> | >   to a receiver is difficult, since we do not know which branch =
of the
>> | > [O] know which branch
>> | > [P] know on which branch
>> | > [R] readability/grammar
>> | >   multicast tree the receiver lies.
>> | >
>> | > When not receiving an Mtrace2 Reply message due to
>> | >   network congestion, a broken router (see Section 5.6), or a =
non-
>> | >   responding router (see Section 5.7), the Mtrace2 client may =
resend
>> | >   another Mtrace2 Query with a lower hop count (see Section =
3.2.1), and
>> | >   repeat the process until it receives an Mtrace2 Reply message.  =
The
>> | >   details are Mtrace2 client specific, and it is outside the =
scope of
>> | >
>> | > [O] specific, and it is outside
>> | > [P] specific and outside
>> | > [R] readability; otherwise we would need to say =E2=80=9Cthey,=E2=80=
=9D and not =E2=80=9Cit,=E2=80=9D
>> | > because we are referencing =E2=80=9Cdetails=E2=80=9D (plural). =
That seems awkward.
>> | >   this document.
>> | >
>> | >   Note that when a router's control plane and forwarding plane =
are out
>> | >   of sync, the Mtrace2 Requests might be forwarded based on the =
control
>> | >   states instead.  In which case, the traced path might not =
represent
>> | >
>> | > [O] In which case,
>> | > [P] In this case,
>> | > [R] grammar
>> | >   the real path the data packets would follow.
>> | >
>> | > Section 3.2.3.  Mtrace2 Reply
>> | > ...
>> | >  The Reply message would then
>> | >   be unicasted to the Mtrace2 client specified in the Mtrace2 =
Client
>> | >   Address field.
>> | >   There are a number of cases an intermediate router might return =
a
>> | >
>> | > [O]  cases an intermediate router might return
>> | > [P] cases in which an intermediate router might return
>> | > [R] I think this is what was meant.
>> | >
>> | > Section 3.2.6.  Mtrace2 Augmented Response Block
>> | > ...
>> | >      When the NO_SPACE error occurs on a router, the router =
should send
>> | >      the original Mtrace2 Request received from the downstream =
router
>> | >      as a Reply back to the Mtrace2 client, and continue with a =
new
>> | >
>> | > [O] client, and
>> | > [P] client and
>> | > [R] grammar
>> | >      Mtrace2 Request.
>> | >
>> | > Section 4.3.3.  Appending Standard Response Block
>> | >   ...
>> | >   The router then turns the Request
>> | >   into a Reply, and sends the Reply as described in Section 4.4.
>> | > [O] Reply, and
>> | > [P] Reply and
>> | > [R] grammar
>> | >
>> | > 5.8.3.  No Upstream Router
>> | >   A trace can not continue if the last Upstream Router in the =
trace is
>> | > [O] can not
>> | > [P] cannot
>> | > [R] grammar =E2=80=94 unless you that optionally, it can elect =
not to continue=E2=80=A6 :-P
>> | >   set to 0.
>> | >
>> | > 5.9.  Continuing after an Error
>> | >  ...
>> | >   However, if all paths but one flow back towards the non-
>> | >   responding router, it is possible to be sure that this is the =
correct
>> | > [O] it is possible to be sure
>> | > [R] I don=E2=80=99t know what this means - perhaps "this" ?
>> | >   path.
>> | >
>> | >
>> | > 7.3.  Packet Loss
>> | >  ...
>> | >   Since the packet counts may be
>> | >   changing as the Mtrace2 Request is propagating, there may be =
small
>> | >   errors (off by 1 or 2 or more) in these statistics.  However, =
these
>> | >
>> | > [O] (off by 1 or 2 or more)
>> | > [R] limit the =E2=80=9Cor more=E2=80=9D; otherwise, what=E2=80=99s =
the point of saying this at
>> | > all? Perhaps "on the order of 1 or 2"?
>> | > ---
>> | > Again, apolgies for the delay,
>> | > W
>> | > --
>> | > I don't think the execution is relevant when it was obviously a =
bad
>> | > idea in the first place.
>> | > This is like putting rabid weasels in your pants, and later =
expressing
>> | > regret at having chosen those particular rabid weasels and that =
pair
>> | > of pants.
>> | >   ---maf
>> | >
>> | > _______________________________________________
>> | > MBONED mailing list
>> | > MBONED@ietf.org
>> | > =
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=3Dhttps-3A__www.ietf.org_mailma=
n_listinfo_mboned&d=3DDwIGaQ&c=3DHAkYuh63rsuhr6Scbfh0UjBXeMK-ndb3voDTXcWzo=
CI&r=3Diw2TU3OZ0CDpCbqeV23zdah2FoG9Do-zEmGgWTaavDg&m=3D3edLGzdsQxcFpVJH9_z=
NcVA5vyzKmcwscKD72Nw3laY&s=3Di5OB_xGccMzEPkQ6JqRclxJpQiUKQKYB14TvVuDwsxA&e=
=3D
>> |
>> | _______________________________________________
>> | MBONED mailing list
>> | MBONED@ietf.org
>> | =
https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=3Dhttps-3A__www.ietf.org_mailma=
n_listinfo_mboned&d=3DDwIGaQ&c=3DHAkYuh63rsuhr6Scbfh0UjBXeMK-ndb3voDTXcWzo=
CI&r=3Diw2TU3OZ0CDpCbqeV23zdah2FoG9Do-zEmGgWTaavDg&m=3D3edLGzdsQxcFpVJH9_z=
NcVA5vyzKmcwscKD72Nw3laY&s=3Di5OB_xGccMzEPkQ6JqRclxJpQiUKQKYB14TvVuDwsxA&e=
=3D
>> |
>=20
>=20
>=20
> --=20
> I don't think the execution is relevant when it was obviously a bad
> idea in the first place.
> This is like putting rabid weasels in your pants, and later expressing
> regret at having chosen those particular rabid weasels and that pair
> of pants.
>   ---maf


From nobody Thu Nov  2 06:44:22 2017
Return-Path: <internet-drafts@ietf.org>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietf.org
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from ietfa.amsl.com (localhost [IPv6:::1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 3C23613F4FA; Thu,  2 Nov 2017 06:44:14 -0700 (PDT)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
From: internet-drafts@ietf.org
To: <i-d-announce@ietf.org>
Cc: mboned@ietf.org
X-Test-IDTracker: no
X-IETF-IDTracker: 6.64.0
Auto-Submitted: auto-generated
Precedence: bulk
Message-ID: <150963025410.24406.4811987093800464019@ietfa.amsl.com>
Date: Thu, 02 Nov 2017 06:44:14 -0700
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/isD7vkEUWkXc1b7mpVNQLoWetb0>
Subject: [MBONED] I-D Action: draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2-21.txt
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 02 Nov 2017 13:44:14 -0000

A New Internet-Draft is available from the on-line Internet-Drafts directories.
This draft is a work item of the MBONE Deployment WG of the IETF.

        Title           : Mtrace Version 2: Traceroute Facility for IP Multicast
        Authors         : Hitoshi Asaeda
                          Kerry Meyer
                          WeeSan Lee
	Filename        : draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2-21.txt
	Pages           : 36
	Date            : 2017-11-02

Abstract:
   This document describes the IP multicast traceroute facility, named
   Mtrace version 2 (Mtrace2).  Unlike unicast traceroute, Mtrace2
   requires special implementations on the part of routers.  This
   specification describes the required functionality in multicast
   routers, as well as how an Mtrace2 client invokes a query and
   receives a reply.


The IETF datatracker status page for this draft is:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2/

There are also htmlized versions available at:
https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2-21
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2-21

A diff from the previous version is available at:
https://www.ietf.org/rfcdiff?url2=draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2-21


Please note that it may take a couple of minutes from the time of submission
until the htmlized version and diff are available at tools.ietf.org.

Internet-Drafts are also available by anonymous FTP at:
ftp://ftp.ietf.org/internet-drafts/


From nobody Fri Nov  3 07:41:03 2017
Return-Path: <ben@nostrum.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietf.org
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from ietfa.amsl.com (localhost [IPv6:::1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 8F74A13FB55; Fri,  3 Nov 2017 07:41:00 -0700 (PDT)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
From: Ben Campbell <ben@nostrum.com>
To: "The IESG" <iesg@ietf.org>
Cc: draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp@ietf.org, mboned-chairs@ietf.org, tim.chown@jisc.ac.uk, mboned@ietf.org
X-Test-IDTracker: no
X-IETF-IDTracker: 6.64.0
Auto-Submitted: auto-generated
Precedence: bulk
Message-ID: <150972006054.28969.9619532220112698830.idtracker@ietfa.amsl.com>
Date: Fri, 03 Nov 2017 07:41:00 -0700
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/izEdWEG47N60ZSlomoTMgenJfBY>
Subject: [MBONED] Ben Campbell's No Objection on draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14: (with COMMENT)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 03 Nov 2017 14:41:00 -0000

Ben Campbell has entered the following ballot position for
draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14: No Objection

When responding, please keep the subject line intact and reply to all
email addresses included in the To and CC lines. (Feel free to cut this
introductory paragraph, however.)


Please refer to https://www.ietf.org/iesg/statement/discuss-criteria.html
for more information about IESG DISCUSS and COMMENT positions.


The document, along with other ballot positions, can be found here:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp/



----------------------------------------------------------------------
COMMENT:
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Thanks for addressing my DISCUSS point.

As a new editorial comment, I note that there are a few other mentions of
"location" in the draft. It might be helpful to qualify those as "network
location". But this is not a show stopper, since you did qualify it in the
authoritative mention.



From nobody Fri Nov  3 10:34:45 2017
Return-Path: <Kathleen.Moriarty.ietf@gmail.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietf.org
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from ietfa.amsl.com (localhost [IPv6:::1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 6830C13FF04; Fri,  3 Nov 2017 10:34:38 -0700 (PDT)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
From: Kathleen Moriarty <Kathleen.Moriarty.ietf@gmail.com>
To: "The IESG" <iesg@ietf.org>
Cc: draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp@ietf.org, mboned-chairs@ietf.org, tim.chown@jisc.ac.uk, mboned@ietf.org
X-Test-IDTracker: no
X-IETF-IDTracker: 6.64.0
Auto-Submitted: auto-generated
Precedence: bulk
Message-ID: <150973047838.16503.13279296612177476065.idtracker@ietfa.amsl.com>
Date: Fri, 03 Nov 2017 10:34:38 -0700
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/aDtKi7LVBueUuJvhbLY0KTEhadw>
Subject: [MBONED] Kathleen Moriarty's No Objection on draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14: (with COMMENT)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 03 Nov 2017 17:34:38 -0000

Kathleen Moriarty has entered the following ballot position for
draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14: No Objection

When responding, please keep the subject line intact and reply to all
email addresses included in the To and CC lines. (Feel free to cut this
introductory paragraph, however.)


Please refer to https://www.ietf.org/iesg/statement/discuss-criteria.html
for more information about IESG DISCUSS and COMMENT positions.


The document, along with other ballot positions, can be found here:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp/



----------------------------------------------------------------------
COMMENT:
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Thanks for addressing my prior discuss and comments.



From nobody Tue Nov  7 15:13:48 2017
Return-Path: <stig@venaas.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id B3B34129ACD for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 15:13:38 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.599
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.599 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_LOW=-0.7, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=venaas-com.20150623.gappssmtp.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id v_Bi0kr-5NDG for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 15:13:30 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mail-qk0-x22a.google.com (mail-qk0-x22a.google.com [IPv6:2607:f8b0:400d:c09::22a]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 (128/128 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 8BC53129B06 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 15:13:28 -0800 (PST)
Received: by mail-qk0-x22a.google.com with SMTP id n66so1173120qki.8 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue, 07 Nov 2017 15:13:28 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=venaas-com.20150623.gappssmtp.com; s=20150623; h=mime-version:in-reply-to:references:from:date:message-id:subject:to :cc; bh=+cqM0OfJX//fQF7xP/tKrWclmc0bNMQqlkPk/hIqXo8=; b=tWOu0V8C+F01KNupu6IYOCiYn8aO/tN3S5ZIbiBiWZjo5il+LNQ06Uufm2tm+ZNIcX eKQwK7ULJVFwL5zSL5BQ1/l75p2COW+BeKs+L/Wkvl39YoB/oC8aSc7ruGfzWXDp+ELY r/mYdq759nCwaSi7YSz5bE/wQJ6WQHxP19Wo16Bi9Am8DgJTevO+OJQz+Ds/nRYq+8YB YHT0oZEn6Z8c03E16EnlRMDbxEByc76p6w/tZI7GJVLYX1y7UeK0FuQahuspe40LrMa6 4mcatkhdUbLcIJVvnDDJDutyJSQjWXr1duTE/U65GIHqlEn1MfuPejX4GSHCE1uykS3E PZwg==
X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:mime-version:in-reply-to:references:from:date :message-id:subject:to:cc; bh=+cqM0OfJX//fQF7xP/tKrWclmc0bNMQqlkPk/hIqXo8=; b=TbkRPs7SKPlupgU/U3bC3Z2QeZL8Ewhclq2zv0tJEbRI41rwDZkyV0OIvUQyCbXmeC gLb8HnvxsdulD/CcKGbfrxSh3sU+s3SR71GVWSE2cFBK/n4imLx3k0uyXQ5zGWFSzUOu 8MFrVU71Ks5NZ5mXJU/WQcAaGDG2bm5kw1HqVaCTJ/Wo9py/ghvtd9+8brFOJFqZr7V4 O72Y4oRMd/DHTWJJRAeOrL8BulzI8DqjiuoyBQZLIvvPnbfa0XVKGIJLVa+GAMnJ7Jmo moHSfrAGcwGPsFGlv/PRolnMrXNFWkRim4gjMVhSxELS+F8f3HXqi2OMBT+WSGOVqEhv 4Bcg==
X-Gm-Message-State: AJaThX6fvCCDmunv92/EuBMXOyRl0tWLPCBDGB/3UIngbQCSkPjDuXRk Cnat84myWvu1QvEPm6AHIwKpj5wrIWUj9FMoXnZCJw==
X-Google-Smtp-Source: AGs4zMa1ZPS+pNAZalBB3XpIoD6nr6sHdGa+230mHN79Ax5r+yZqEtVnvuZLLVzgake9achvjklc1wffLY+++v1zgv4=
X-Received: by 10.55.170.74 with SMTP id t71mr655462qke.84.1510096407650; Tue, 07 Nov 2017 15:13:27 -0800 (PST)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Received: by 10.140.28.9 with HTTP; Tue, 7 Nov 2017 15:13:27 -0800 (PST)
In-Reply-To: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se>
References: <20170725221330.GA4821@cs-it-6805697.local> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1707260908550.29724@svl-jtac-lnx02> <20170904141235.GC3194@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709051358300.14937@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se>
From: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>
Date: Tue, 7 Nov 2017 15:13:27 -0800
Message-ID: <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com>
To: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
Cc: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8"
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/y4vNFgibTe4pTS3W1e91UFa1s5g>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Tue, 07 Nov 2017 23:13:39 -0000

Hi

I don't think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular multicast. If
you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by using AMT to the device, the
packets will be unicast packets, so the regular Wi-Fi handling of
unicast packets (including retransmissions) should be sufficient. Do
you need additional retransmissions?

Stig


On Thu, Sep 7, 2017 at 8:16 PM, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se> wrote:
> On Thu, 7 Sep 2017, Manfredi, Albert E wrote:
>
>> users is via unicast, and the stream protocol depends on the user's
>
>
> Here is another thing. Most of the traffic to user devices traverse at least
> one wifi hop. The unfortunate truth is that multicast doesn't work well on
> todays wifi environment (I raised this issue within the IETF close to two
> years ago, and we're still nowhere near anything I would say even remotely
> looks like a widespread solution).
>
> So yes, AMT tunnels to unicast everything from the ISP to the devices might
> work. They would have to be initiated by the device/app itself (to aid
> initial deployment).
>
> 6to4 was decided to be a really bad way of doing IPv6 (public relays nobody
> knew how well they worked, they were badly maintained etc).
>
> AMT looks like it was designed the same way. Now, with AMT you don't have
> the problem with return path uncertainty that 6to4 had, so that is less of a
> problem.
>
> What I see lacking here is reliable transport. If we're going to do this,
> the client is going to have to be able to request retransmits to work around
> unreliable delivery of packets.
>
> How do we do that? 5 second buffer in the AMT relay (or a device sitting
> next to the relay) that the client can request re-transmits from? It would
> need to be stateful somehow. We'd also need some kind of identifier/sequence
> number in each AMT packet so the end device can tell that a packet was
> missing, and can request a retransmit of this.
>
> Thoughts?
>
> --
> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
>
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned


From nobody Tue Nov  7 15:23:43 2017
Return-Path: <stig@venaas.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 9B1E9129A90 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 15:23:41 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.599
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.599 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_LOW=-0.7, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=venaas-com.20150623.gappssmtp.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id hRmdGtgd9MVO for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 15:23:40 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mail-qk0-x236.google.com (mail-qk0-x236.google.com [IPv6:2607:f8b0:400d:c09::236]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 (128/128 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id ECC83129687 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 15:23:39 -0800 (PST)
Received: by mail-qk0-x236.google.com with SMTP id 2so388953qkg.13 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue, 07 Nov 2017 15:23:39 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=venaas-com.20150623.gappssmtp.com; s=20150623; h=mime-version:in-reply-to:references:from:date:message-id:subject:to :cc; bh=o2RnK4PD7rPDYLC3EOYFCy/5yOh6NWn6IibmoeVoBRY=; b=Ij9PUadMo8q5J0UCL3ZaL6pGdZgjzy1QN+eTO8CXdo8tx7KsL9ufpLLuvfKf1hxvvl JZieWT9Rki6JDRM9IH5moV9n16Bkyafy735PMoUhNw6LVd7LYVaN42UpcW9mJ+2matE7 b5+9O/8DdFt3S9vAS2uKcdHRSO7qNTeUIF1uFqDpqJLiSHnj7l6yBKbiWtzlhs9DfQpa IaaSTD7Owm9+lSKLEVJM6lfjLjMPv3F9JGJ/yZK/qPRJ7fA20paT7FSjuBdi8Qsy3ud5 UhlUgQs8CVhxdkb5Zdu2YyfJ0NJpEYf4OITG7B/rCs7gK+sxQrjw5XCjQTtlkb/TtI2b z/Sw==
X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:mime-version:in-reply-to:references:from:date :message-id:subject:to:cc; bh=o2RnK4PD7rPDYLC3EOYFCy/5yOh6NWn6IibmoeVoBRY=; b=bUPwlqTQ4WZkRLO4dN2Xol85dQc27JmYHsVURPbqTcV5YlT7loBsWLxbjuvAN2S9KX qyPGo5SLNb7Luflcsu+wjpPfOZaJxMIllGPCuAwBdsOg4UV42AUEf8XrR9z2JLZfHmpC tl5StbUCn+qEMyB3/c3qHZkcQ/9t3aWGWg4Drhai6iWjyiqh2/RHH9RdAmOcll9gdzZB hv4Wxio1OO/ytPx33YzEtTp6uFGnPC+rSZBUCeYQFR24nPpgV8vwciVirPTybPJM6wAv fHgv2DvZ+zlZ/kx1Afj+0YOIIelWTJkThjBJ0EkyCeM6tp6j9ryYPb4oGAEBJj32bNo9 l4Vg==
X-Gm-Message-State: AJaThX7F4C7W0UfJToE1li5lOiWDSGnA8KIoVPC5bFIsl3LRC2G2acni eOJis0ZrGmWOHgdcErxdpT40vWHmVysxv7R90kSN9Q==
X-Google-Smtp-Source: AGs4zMal0YngkGGaonCnaJ9BJDjDBlVBJZk0YoTs9uNnINd6FVB9roxLaa58DjPD1He6c2tK012rmj2zi6kENZAQ/kI=
X-Received: by 10.55.153.67 with SMTP id b64mr624325qke.313.1510097019072; Tue, 07 Nov 2017 15:23:39 -0800 (PST)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Received: by 10.140.28.9 with HTTP; Tue, 7 Nov 2017 15:23:38 -0800 (PST)
In-Reply-To: <20170911165410.GD3600@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170911115306.GA3600@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709111454170.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170911135240.GB3600@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709111633360.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170911161453.GC3600@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709111834260.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709111835340.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170911165410.GD3600@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
From: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>
Date: Tue, 7 Nov 2017 15:23:38 -0800
Message-ID: <CAHANBt+dc=y1oMmApZi=ebAaYAqjez3-Jyj8Zjwu2_qef_y5kw@mail.gmail.com>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
Cc: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8"
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/TZEfsUBNFKR5IbWnX7tqHv3VcY0>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deprecating MSDP
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Tue, 07 Nov 2017 23:23:42 -0000

Hi

There may be some room for improvement for 4610, but I think it's a
bad idea to encapsulate data packets in TCP. I don't get why you would
need that reliability. Does it need to be more reliable than regular
multicast? However, it might be a good idea to use TCP to avoid
periodic signaling and send just a single SA message without data.
Basically doing a single NULL-register by FHR to RP when the source
becomes active, and relaying this to other RPs. And of course,
withdrawing the SA when source is no longer active. Alternatively
doing this just between the Anycast-RPs, not involving FHR to RP.

Stig


On Mon, Sep 11, 2017 at 9:54 AM, Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de> wrote:
> Right. So it would not enable new content owners to come in and get
> an easier market entry to reach customers for live streaming... sitting
> in front of STBs.
>
> On Mon, Sep 11, 2017 at 06:36:38PM +0200, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
>> On Mon, 11 Sep 2017, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
>>
>> >There is URL I know of.
>>
>> There is *no* URL that I know of.
>>
>> This isn't volume business afaik. I don't remember which one it was,
>> but it was basically in cooperation with one of the larger typical
>> "channel package providers" you might get on coax TV. One of Canal
>> Digital, VIASAT or someone like that.
>>
>> --
>> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
>
> --
> ---
> tte@cs.fau.de
>
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned


From nobody Tue Nov  7 17:29:13 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 1057C12E053 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 17:29:11 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.199
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.199 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 7sVRx68rcEzt for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 17:29:08 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 5B731129C4B for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 17:29:08 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 932B758C504; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 02:29:03 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 7E093B0D0DF; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 02:29:03 +0100 (CET)
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 02:29:03 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
Cc: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171108012903.GA19448@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <20170904141235.GC3194@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709051358300.14937@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/Mzbalv8IBIlLvpt68pWGYgFe6bE>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 01:29:11 -0000

Thanks Mikael.  Would be great to see if we can close any gaps
to get towards more deployments!

When you say 6to4 failed and AMT is similar, i assume that there is more
to it than the reliability aspect you discuss afterwards. Would be good
to get more insight into any other aspects you think killed 6to4 and that
we may want to reconsider for AMT.

As Stig mentioned, there is fairly good retransmission across WiFi
for unicast packets, so merely by relying on AMT you get that benefit.
I have not seen good analysis whether or not this can be deemded to
be sufficient. I wold guess that it is buffering far less traffic than
a few seconds, so i am not discounting your approach, but it would be
great to have explicit testing data to make the case for what you
propose.

Lets assume get the data to show WiFi unicast retransmission itself
is insufficient and unicast is only reliable enough because of the
combination of TCP and WiFi unicast retransmission:

I hesitate to invent new retransmit mechanisms. Should we not rather
use an existing reliable transport such as TCP or SCTP ? Admittedly,
RTP also implemented its own retransmit schemes for the same reasons,
i wonder how good that experience was. 

The main issue IMHO is that i would like for clients to be able to
connect to arbitrary remote AMT relays because different relays can
support different content. We can do this with todays AMT approach.
And its left up to the client library to determine which relay to connect
to for which content. So no network config needed if we do a direct AMT
tunnel from client to relay.

If we want WiFi-reliability from home gateway to client then we can
easily loose this flexibility. Either the tunnel is reliable from the
remote relay to the client, so that you retransmit across the whole path
when the wifi blurbs. Thats IMHO terrible. Or you put the relay into the
home gateway, and then you need some scheme for how the home gateway
builds another AMT tunnel to the remote relay. And a scheme how the
client can indciate for each content the remote relay address.

SO, if you ask me, i would just try to tunnel the original AMT tunnel
between client and remote AMT relay into a TCP tunnel between client
and home gateway. Not sure what the easiest reused tunnel method is.
I would love SOCKS, but it does not define tunneling of UDP over TCP
(just over UDP). One could use just that "whatever" VPN tunnel that
can use TCP. OpenConnect for example falls back to TCP.

I have always missed a simple, non-encrypted/strong-authenticated
TCP tunnel option in network products *sigh*.

Cheers
    Toerless

On Fri, Sep 08, 2017 at 05:16:00AM +0200, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
> On Thu, 7 Sep 2017, Manfredi, Albert E wrote:
> 
> >users is via unicast, and the stream protocol depends on the user's
> 
> Here is another thing. Most of the traffic to user devices traverse
> at least one wifi hop. The unfortunate truth is that multicast
> doesn't work well on todays wifi environment (I raised this issue
> within the IETF close to two years ago, and we're still nowhere near
> anything I would say even remotely looks like a widespread
> solution).
> 
> So yes, AMT tunnels to unicast everything from the ISP to the
> devices might work. They would have to be initiated by the
> device/app itself (to aid initial deployment).
> 
> 6to4 was decided to be a really bad way of doing IPv6 (public relays
> nobody knew how well they worked, they were badly maintained etc).
> 
> AMT looks like it was designed the same way. Now, with AMT you don't
> have the problem with return path uncertainty that 6to4 had, so that
> is less of a problem.
> 
> What I see lacking here is reliable transport. If we're going to do
> this, the client is going to have to be able to request retransmits
> to work around unreliable delivery of packets.
> 
> How do we do that? 5 second buffer in the AMT relay (or a device
> sitting next to the relay) that the client can request re-transmits
> from? It would need to be stateful somehow. We'd also need some kind
> of identifier/sequence number in each AMT packet so the end device
> can tell that a packet was missing, and can request a retransmit of
> this.
> 
> Thoughts?
> 
> -- 
> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
> 
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Tue Nov  7 17:45:56 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 45BBF12EAC4 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 17:45:53 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.199
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.199 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id FsHJg1wVmM-9 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 17:45:51 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 71F9812EAB7 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 17:45:51 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 6DE2F58C504; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 02:45:47 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 56597B0D0DF; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 02:45:47 +0100 (CET)
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 02:45:47 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>
Cc: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171108014547.GB19448@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170911115306.GA3600@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709111454170.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170911135240.GB3600@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709111633360.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170911161453.GC3600@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709111834260.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709111835340.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170911165410.GD3600@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <CAHANBt+dc=y1oMmApZi=ebAaYAqjez3-Jyj8Zjwu2_qef_y5kw@mail.gmail.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <CAHANBt+dc=y1oMmApZi=ebAaYAqjez3-Jyj8Zjwu2_qef_y5kw@mail.gmail.com>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/2xW7ZLO3lgtL0KXz60vf_B9CmgI>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deprecating MSDP
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 01:45:53 -0000

Improving on 4610 is a bit like proposing fixes for 

Be happy that you didn't have to sit through the years of IETF discussing
the MSDP encasulated packets. Which is the dicsussion that ultimately
made MSDP fall froms tandard to experimental. Its really like discussing how
to best deal with horse manure. You really need to accept that there are no
good solutions other than changing your motor. Aka: the problem is
the data triggered PIM-SM (S,G) state building, not MSDP. MSDP just
tries to carry the horse manure over longer trips ;-).

I would just want to engineer multicast state building on top of reliable transport,
so i do not have to deal with all the complexities of even predicting the
behavior under loss. Let alone optimizing/perfecting.

Just make all RP and LHR BGP speakers (RPs = RR) and use a BGP address family
to carry (S,G) SA state. Probably only small changes over how MVPN is done
with BGP. Just need to decide on how to do (*,G). 

Cheers
    Toerless

On Tue, Nov 07, 2017 at 03:23:38PM -0800, Stig Venaas wrote:
> Hi
> 
> There may be some room for improvement for 4610, but I think it's a
> bad idea to encapsulate data packets in TCP. I don't get why you would
> need that reliability. Does it need to be more reliable than regular
> multicast? However, it might be a good idea to use TCP to avoid
> periodic signaling and send just a single SA message without data.
> Basically doing a single NULL-register by FHR to RP when the source
> becomes active, and relaying this to other RPs. And of course,
> withdrawing the SA when source is no longer active. Alternatively
> doing this just between the Anycast-RPs, not involving FHR to RP.
> 
> Stig
> 
> 
> On Mon, Sep 11, 2017 at 9:54 AM, Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de> wrote:
> > Right. So it would not enable new content owners to come in and get
> > an easier market entry to reach customers for live streaming... sitting
> > in front of STBs.
> >
> > On Mon, Sep 11, 2017 at 06:36:38PM +0200, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
> >> On Mon, 11 Sep 2017, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
> >>
> >> >There is URL I know of.
> >>
> >> There is *no* URL that I know of.
> >>
> >> This isn't volume business afaik. I don't remember which one it was,
> >> but it was basically in cooperation with one of the larger typical
> >> "channel package providers" you might get on coax TV. One of Canal
> >> Digital, VIASAT or someone like that.
> >>
> >> --
> >> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
> >
> > --
> > ---
> > tte@cs.fau.de
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > MBONED mailing list
> > MBONED@ietf.org
> > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Tue Nov  7 18:05:36 2017
Return-Path: <zhang.zheng@zte.com.cn>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id DD64512EB10 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 18:05:35 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.2
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.2 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, SPF_PASS=-0.001, UNPARSEABLE_RELAY=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id gF-RX-n6emMK for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 18:05:33 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mxhk.zte.com.cn (mxhk.zte.com.cn [63.217.80.70]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 3465F12EAF3 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 18:05:31 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mse01.zte.com.cn (unknown [10.30.3.20]) by Forcepoint Email with ESMTPS id 426E1D06BF25AED4E41B; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:05:29 +0800 (CST)
Received: from njxapp01.zte.com.cn ([10.41.132.200]) by mse01.zte.com.cn with SMTP id vA824jBO056755; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 10:04:45 +0800 (GMT-8) (envelope-from zhang.zheng@zte.com.cn)
Received: from mapi (njxapp05[null]) by mapi (Zmail) with MAPI id mid203; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 10:04:46 +0800 (CST)
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 10:04:46 +0800 (CST)
X-Zmail-TransId: 2afd5a02663e139-34a56
X-Mailer: Zmail v1.0
Message-ID: <201711081004463220174@zte.com.cn>
In-Reply-To: <20171108014547.GB19448@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se, 20171108014547.GB19448@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de
Mime-Version: 1.0
From: <zhang.zheng@zte.com.cn>
To: <tte@cs.fau.de>
Cc: <stig@venaas.com>, <mboned@ietf.org>
Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="=====_001_next====="
X-MAIL: mse01.zte.com.cn vA824jBO056755
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/V2mt_Yp8KRgx2RxGqPLhjCTATpc>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] =?utf-8?q?deprecating_MSDP?=
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 02:05:36 -0000

--=====_001_next=====
Content-Type: multipart/related;
	boundary="=====_002_next====="


--=====_002_next=====
Content-Type: multipart/alternative;
	boundary="=====_003_next====="


--=====_003_next=====
Content-Type: text/plain;
	charset="UTF-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 
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--=====_003_next=====--

--=====_002_next=====--

--=====_001_next=====--


From nobody Tue Nov  7 18:17:44 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 7B46A12EB25 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 18:17:43 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.199
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.199 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id IoKlavT36FZn for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 18:17:42 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 173C312EB1A for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue,  7 Nov 2017 18:17:42 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id BC50C58C504; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 03:17:37 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id A5A33B0D0EE; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 03:17:37 +0100 (CET)
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 03:17:37 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: zhang.zheng@zte.com.cn
Cc: stig@venaas.com, mboned@ietf.org
Message-ID: <20171108021737.GC19448@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <20171108014547.GB19448@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <201711081004463220174@zte.com.cn>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <201711081004463220174@zte.com.cn>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/2qxWRtIW1X24PDW7K0WiTZfVUas>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deprecating MSDP
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 02:17:43 -0000

Or at least a good starting point, yes. In doubt an SP solution for PEs is
likely designed to require a lot of configuration, so something more easily
self-configuring may be required for enterprises or other environments.
But thats just my prejudice speaking. Have to read through it in more detail.

Thanks!
    Toerles

On Wed, Nov 08, 2017 at 10:04:46AM +0800, zhang.zheng@zte.com.cn wrote:
> Hi Toerless,
> 
> >Just make all RP and LHR BGP speakers (RPs = RR) and use a BGP address family
> to carry (S,G) SA state. Probably only small changes over how MVPN is done
> with BGP. Just need to decide on how to do (*,G).
> 
> It may has been solved in RFC7716. :)
> 
> Best Regards,
> Sandy
> 
> ------------------????????????------------------
> ???????????? <tte@cs.fau.de>;
> ???????????? <stig@venaas.com>;
> ???????????? <mboned@ietf.org>;
> ??? ??? ???2017???11???08??? 09:46
> ??? ??? ???Re: [MBONED] deprecating MSDP
> Improving on 4610 is a bit like proposing fixes for
> 
> Be happy that you didn't have to sit through the years of IETF discussing
> the MSDP encasulated packets. Which is the dicsussion that ultimately
> made MSDP fall froms tandard to experimental. Its really like discussing how
> to best deal with horse manure. You really need to accept that there are no
> good solutions other than changing your motor. Aka: the problem is
> the data triggered PIM-SM (S,G) state building, not MSDP. MSDP just
> tries to carry the horse manure over longer trips ;-).
> 
> I would just want to engineer multicast state building on top of reliable transport,
> so i do not have to deal with all the complexities of even predicting the
> behavior under loss. Let alone optimizing/perfecting.
> 
> Just make all RP and LHR BGP speakers (RPs = RR) and use a BGP address family
> to carry (S,G) SA state. Probably only small changes over how MVPN is done
> with BGP. Just need to decide on how to do (*,G).
> 
> Cheers
> Toerless
> 
> On Tue, Nov 07, 2017 at 03:23:38PM -0800, Stig Venaas wrote:
> > Hi
> >
> > There may be some room for improvement for 4610, but I think it's a
> > bad idea to encapsulate data packets in TCP. I don't get why you would
> > need that reliability. Does it need to be more reliable than regular
> > multicast? However, it might be a good idea to use TCP to avoid
> > periodic signaling and send just a single SA message without data.
> > Basically doing a single NULL-register by FHR to RP when the source
> > becomes active, and relaying this to other RPs. And of course,
> > withdrawing the SA when source is no longer active. Alternatively
> > doing this just between the Anycast-RPs, not involving FHR to RP.
> >
> > Stig
> >
> >
> > On Mon, Sep 11, 2017 at 9:54 AM, Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de> wrote:
> > > Right. So it would not enable new content owners to come in and get
> > > an easier market entry to reach customers for live streaming... sitting
> > > in front of STBs.
> > >
> > > On Mon, Sep 11, 2017 at 06:36:38PM +0200, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
> > >> On Mon, 11 Sep 2017, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
> > >>
> > >> >There is URL I know of.
> > >>
> > >> There is *no* URL that I know of.
> > >>
> > >> This isn't volume business afaik. I don't remember which one it was,
> > >> but it was basically in cooperation with one of the larger typical
> > >> "channel package providers" you might get on coax TV. One of Canal
> > >> Digital, VIASAT or someone like that.
> > >>
> > >> --
> > >> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
> > >
> > > --
> > > ---
> > > tte@cs.fau.de
> > >
> > > _______________________________________________
> > > MBONED mailing list
> > > MBONED@ietf.org
> > > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
> 
> --
> ---
> tte@cs.fau.de
> 
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned



-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Wed Nov  8 01:50:40 2017
Return-Path: <swmike@swm.pp.se>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 9815D1318E5 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 01:50:39 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.301
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.301 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=swm.pp.se
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 7Mn9NdqFMImC for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 01:50:37 -0800 (PST)
Received: from uplift.swm.pp.se (swm.pp.se [212.247.200.143]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 4AF9F1318CC for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 01:50:37 -0800 (PST)
Received: by uplift.swm.pp.se (Postfix, from userid 501) id C9425B3; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:50:34 +0100 (CET)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/simple; d=swm.pp.se; s=mail; t=1510134634; bh=vmcQUGAUU0rmr4LnKzI/+WKV/JsM5WyNuVtY6RD5hTo=; h=Date:From:To:cc:Subject:In-Reply-To:References:From; b=aGYG621fkRNSBrNe01wl3JWrEGeDgUmGKWm7c6Prw1tG3WFxWRJZedgclIiRYV9yu IoyouRg3G8NF9os41HmO/NJkbHbFLJNFLdFzUNqr+zftHMXqyyOw1rt+ZRY6/7d4HS 2pTRozgZQJ5cy/UfdSco61JOmy6GYITK5EZ0AOfU=
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by uplift.swm.pp.se (Postfix) with ESMTP id C613DB1; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:50:34 +0100 (CET)
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 10:50:34 +0100 (CET)
From: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
To: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>
cc: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>,  "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
In-Reply-To: <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com>
Message-ID: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se>
References: <20170725221330.GA4821@cs-it-6805697.local> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1707260908550.29724@svl-jtac-lnx02> <20170904141235.GC3194@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709051358300.14937@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com>
User-Agent: Alpine 2.20 (DEB 67 2015-01-07)
Organization: People's Front Against WWW
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII; format=flowed
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/UDr4TLcwvS_Nf0HYhGQrq8GSTLI>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 09:50:39 -0000

On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:

> Hi
>
> I don't think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular multicast. If

Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC is an operational nightmare 
that never stops. You need to constantly measure customer experience 
(preferrably in the STBs, all of this with proprietary solutions afaik) or 
try to measure it in your network (using expensive equipement).

I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at large scale.

> you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by using AMT to the device, the 
> packets will be unicast packets, so the regular Wi-Fi handling of 
> unicast packets (including retransmissions) should be sufficient. Do you 
> need additional retransmissions?

Unicast will be far superior to multicast over wifi, but it's probably 
still not enough to give a good enough customer experience without FEC.

FEC in this aspect means the application deteriorates gracefully under 
packet loss, by smearing out infomation across packets and degrading 
quality without for instance magenta squares gliding along the screen 
until the next full screen update (that might be a second into the 
future (or more)).

This "FEC" can also be (as some have done), by the devices receiving 
multicast packets and then requesting (via unicast) from a server of some 
kind, to get the packets it lost. The few solutions available when I was 
involved in this before, were all proprietary. They were also used to 
speed up channel changes by providing full screen update immediately, 
before same information came via the multicast stream.

In packet networks, packets are lost. It's a fact. They're designed to 
behave this way. From what I can see, there are two ways to handle this. 
Either we come up with a standards based retransmission mechanism for 
multicast streams that anyone can use, or we punt the problem to the 
application layer, and let them figure it out. We need to be perfectly 
clear to everybody what our choice is.

-- 
Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se


From nobody Wed Nov  8 06:37:35 2017
Return-Path: <lenny@juniper.net>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 07421126D45 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 06:37:34 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.021
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.021 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE=-0.0001, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H3=-0.01, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=-0.01, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=juniper.net
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 06LBZkuaCidH for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 06:37:31 -0800 (PST)
Received: from NAM02-BL2-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-bl2nam02on0119.outbound.protection.outlook.com [104.47.38.119]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 8A8FE127369 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 06:37:26 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=juniper.net; s=selector1; h=From:Date:Subject:Message-ID:Content-Type:MIME-Version; bh=70woBp6zLsU/0Q6/E6qcr4h3pZntbc8w2vLMGQJ6Mao=; b=kZANpmaZ9m3xvy3xZR8Q65ju22erwm7kV2AtlRku2CTeNMFB9UW8ykVuZfMEWEndp6nQp+D5Gw+FFNVo2qPakFTT1xwO/GiyUpb95ZJ4lFKWZ9XSz4T+jG80Z5JuoWqGm26wy/Ta1QFhlt2JhuTMV9Y+YegeytktA1U/7ql2q/M=
Received: from DM5PR05CA0022.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.173.226.32) by DM5PR05MB3610.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.174.242.167) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384_P256) id 15.20.218.6; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 14:37:24 +0000
Received: from DM3NAM05FT053.eop-nam05.prod.protection.outlook.com (2a01:111:f400:7e51::209) by DM5PR05CA0022.outlook.office365.com (2603:10b6:3:d4::32) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384) id 15.20.197.4 via Frontend Transport; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 14:37:24 +0000
Authentication-Results: spf=softfail (sender IP is 66.129.239.15) smtp.mailfrom=juniper.net; zte.com.cn; dkim=none (message not signed) header.d=none;zte.com.cn; dmarc=fail action=none header.from=juniper.net;
Received-SPF: SoftFail (protection.outlook.com: domain of transitioning juniper.net discourages use of 66.129.239.15 as permitted sender)
Received: from P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (66.129.239.15) by DM3NAM05FT053.mail.protection.outlook.com (10.152.98.167) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_0, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA_P256) id 15.20.218.12 via Frontend Transport; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 14:37:23 +0000
Received: from svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (172.17.28.215) by P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (172.24.192.21) with Microsoft SMTP Server id 14.3.123.3; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 06:37:23 -0800
Received: by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix, from userid 1709)	id E14189F934; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 06:37:22 -0800 (PST)
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1])	by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix) with ESMTP id DE00E9F931; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 06:37:22 -0800 (PST)
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 06:37:22 -0800
From: Leonard Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
CC: <zhang.zheng@zte.com.cn>, <mboned@ietf.org>
In-Reply-To: <20171108021737.GC19448@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
Message-ID: <alpine.DEB.2.02.1711080635380.18330@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net>
References: <20171108014547.GB19448@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <201711081004463220174@zte.com.cn> <20171108021737.GC19448@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
User-Agent: Alpine 2.02 (DEB 1266 2009-07-14)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="US-ASCII"
X-EOPAttributedMessage: 0
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-HT: Tenant
X-Forefront-Antispam-Report: CIP:66.129.239.15; IPV:NLI; CTRY:US; EFV:NLI; SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10019020)(6009001)(346002)(376002)(39860400002)(2980300002)(189002)(24454002)(199003)(252514010)(2810700001)(5005980100005)(53936002)(105596002)(2906002)(106466001)(81156014)(356003)(69596002)(47776003)(478600001)(81166006)(57986006)(76506005)(45336002)(6306002)(90966002)(77096006)(305945005)(68736007)(6916009)(46386002)(8936002)(4326008)(50466002)(3240700002)(7126002)(2950100002)(97736004)(50986999)(58126008)(5660300001)(46406003)(6246003)(6266002)(23726003)(8676002)(53546010)(316002)(86362001)(54906003)(575784001)(189998001)(229853002)(83506002)(76176999)(966005)(16586007)(54356999)(510974002)(42262002); DIR:OUT; SFP:1102; SCL:1; SRVR:DM5PR05MB3610; H:P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net; FPR:;  SPF:SoftFail; PTR:InfoDomainNonexistent; MX:1; A:1; LANG:en; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; DM3NAM05FT053; 1:ILw4GARvy/8uwV7fNEMBt2z6jIY0THWFyh1snwGGKglVq/6/UKbkjNQAYQL5F3CMWF9owyJDQuBsF9og50LPalegDem87VN7p9eAHtPCS3n6dyCpCSme4fQ5v1c8YuWT
X-MS-PublicTrafficType: Email
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-Correlation-Id: affdc870-a685-4f58-a5c6-08d526b63a05
X-Microsoft-Antispam: UriScan:; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(22001)(4534020)(4602075)(4627115)(201703031133081)(201702281549075)(2017052603199); SRVR:DM5PR05MB3610; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; DM5PR05MB3610; 3:EDUQo8CK4ykIG1Gn5Dq8N+5JE41J45TNu4QGlRCbaSUF1HA4aJOS+oShHWcpRoZtVz9xhSDsSeeFETFKr8XM5Xtgvlumnb1I9hxUMURkELDePPoT8PGySWwu5PZyqXdiEtY5hWpWFv+W3vZjExExaqLbA134f3y0x0ZuvmilIBs003pxT3I2jkbxYv2RZcyv/kKN6rXtqIg+WWQmbAgfK4Ydhn+QAL7olZH808BronUM3d92rtdeNebtqC7xNiwV3eTjGT/fQiKGjh6EbFSp25VaTxHlGBg7ZmD4cvZYNKCR0dxET5sTMcgEVutxxVMWIjjktUPryCcGBdLQjibgR+3dC/wqgy6odeX32G+AQzw=; 25:+ABjtpBri2UUMkm2xGCe00ChC6lrl7/kD6zUFIsCKVom8w5SytJM2AOAF+EfDIrlM3XoYljo5qsB4jHL2Qghap5P1Nv+Mo0CJC0s3Menp7RHOCTuOb2hD5/7uwKKbnReftCclCYltnHekCYu1AaOuelWMmyRYRhHTT6BJb7PLA7akY9Nw4M+HX7KW1z6nWUndA6+Y2yEE+ki6TQ248g5eZ6AzM6xKzu9cHRJt/z3uatM0eLz/CHZbfdthJtGa8IOmOegvhhmlxuG/CnvwaWoZTeU0OhMArWo7zbEqdFZSuQh0Be4nsRezc6+iT7XEvDjT+PrS/HvMWxqdJvZpJDM2A==
X-MS-TrafficTypeDiagnostic: DM5PR05MB3610:
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; DM5PR05MB3610; 31:ySoWxn8ECvvEwTbCcnWhrJY5LZldMj2r49ZwCXSoySp276l6BRrCuktj0mAROUQej498r1sXyE9N83ml1uOXJLu7mMzAFpoPXyPhKDOyEnJajiPjfawBq0rnAG3S6k3iiDI2A/AHYPiaCMgaizAwXZArAptNEg00U8V/lKsxIp1S/ytIb613zgLdvjotj52YQS5lqTdTfnT0kwTod05qacJKF9wGUJRBIk1GqI/zM28=; 20: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
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-Test: UriScan:(10436049006162)(788757137089);
X-Microsoft-Antispam-PRVS: <DM5PR05MB361059AB78767400B52D9A4FA4560@DM5PR05MB3610.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-CFA-Test: BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000700101)(100105000095)(100000701101)(100105300095)(100000702101)(100105100095)(6040450)(2401047)(5005006)(8121501046)(3231021)(10201501046)(100000703101)(100105400095)(93006095)(93001095)(3002001)(6055026)(2017110403001)(6041248)(20161123564025)(20161123560025)(20161123562025)(20161123558100)(201703131423075)(201702281528075)(201703061421075)(201703061406153)(20161123555025)(6072148)(201708071742011)(100000704101)(100105200095)(100000705101)(100105500095); SRVR:DM5PR05MB3610; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000800101)(100110000095)(100000801101)(100110300095)(100000802101)(100110100095)(100000803101)(100110400095)(100000804101)(100110200095)(100000805101)(100110500095); SRVR:DM5PR05MB3610; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; DM5PR05MB3610; 4:S8FbTMVuHsvvdz2Q9ypFpy93h+i7B2Zye8lSO6S0mUkQLotKjNDe5uDe5MCUSIMjaTSCFYtePv67rZADZaHRa5LUdpJuy7Z5XJsskAQmk953R3p1UDzqobSLLyQ2wMmS1L6yQs2jmprYv0EScdOXSWT7pyQyQ2n9i5rFQ8UMFNdBLxf37Q1ozk9BH2+Yn/jNLbAKgHF+fM31v6shJ+up+1T02dvbtg7QDPwqZdCORWUOhPCb5PfGkAqSoWZ4yJWl8ZMUYEl2QVHEWO5inW0W8imVufDGTWzBLDu97avEATDToScApOnKHU6pbWaE0keCOmFOVFX6K5bKw5xNf5wS/A==
X-Forefront-PRVS: 0485417665
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: =?us-ascii?Q?1; DM5PR05MB3610; 23:bMfhX7h5Xehzi752SxB3RJWPiIHG6OAXErObDI0L4?= =?us-ascii?Q?xdSaoy/X05LZxEAXmqjX1+ic0GJBfsgfKtM9ldJjGE/XR7QD48YX5rboh+Pn?= =?us-ascii?Q?uL/8d3GzqhxgwnJcMNAUx5wOsvfmEZQZrKTYcmDiEuDQ8Ct9L+Fp7jrdGfYo?= =?us-ascii?Q?x/g6pd8ANxiXH+2MzAaBiPtffTLnCW2R91zF93uWX2x7pMRD8P0LkVdD8tqa?= =?us-ascii?Q?NdzD8KxX8JoRxk4YXr/bdF8mXf25CyM19VeYxgBS0/PS2gejV3FqJMdiOCtW?= =?us-ascii?Q?TR1eqDDRtTrUvMCds1fm7Cya9x+5pi6glLmts71KX1xV3EfMx8g2O31C+k1x?= =?us-ascii?Q?bRFCtRXcA9BD/R/UXLQj3FhoM/TdGAunIHBTK2mArrmodwaE+WmEgKofvXnD?= =?us-ascii?Q?UN4Xvd1Wxah7HoYD6Rt0WoMe/VS+qlFSKEkOrilovd/aaYF4kmdB1Q2Wjiy/?= =?us-ascii?Q?wUK+RIl9pfj3eCdGMjHjoAUjASD0YkC9E4CxR4NLnE5sKO/dCQFPz+FHf3SK?= =?us-ascii?Q?dIktRPRRV/FDRzsBOPtc7grH8PeF2yosa9hwSKYAUoMr43YhXbnSuMZWtdEW?= =?us-ascii?Q?GaS215igxrxgnjwfGbipV00DtZm8mYTptiIfjT3bLNmxqAEBs5z9+rWP+5EY?= =?us-ascii?Q?M1SmJoLyxUU+kit5TFb7zNr3qhG8XQdRaZdijlJTEsoMzhQuWOKPa1S3FwsU?= =?us-ascii?Q?zqFlTWYCC8MIMzlje0oPemJvMentigZddkulYDctFZ42iAF7IzkRgkhRlY+H?= =?us-ascii?Q?CtTtBW+/QkIVNcSxvAEy9OHNe1eRv0Wx+EMJeQOHRQcab51hrrE6EzeCbiOA?= =?us-ascii?Q?nxNUpPKhllJkHluBtfipD5lWIv0U66r6GGutAzW8azInmWoR675VsSHrapAw?= =?us-ascii?Q?Yf06CWaVzdSAAfxe1HM0TiwClHT3O1YPuTKqkJfhq68wNcM0b6/B3YbwBOlw?= =?us-ascii?Q?3GOXCmMELcFvAk9zjsyk24YTONSCC3HtiZWCFMmj07TpAtssuMFXtVjj2L7Q?= =?us-ascii?Q?rlZiiE3CzUs6EsaEU0AGPGooSET4nGCEVg3CkozPPZrBvSfzZyiuc9AY6JSZ?= =?us-ascii?Q?v7svm6r3YVD6toSPo2nRt++C7XdXG7i1t01M6ZcoU4JUgdw09BOm1biE6P8E?= =?us-ascii?Q?U1KvTWXeKiQNWj0zd+zFHKkoaVrDSPIUkLkQyBLhJQYGY2DBqVSFRTY8zjsG?= =?us-ascii?Q?Gy2oy/rIEE7twXWtfi1SQWlv+Dn1AyzRqblXj5AvddoFrr9E6o45yUwEpEX+?= =?us-ascii?Q?L/nvbtndBwrpD6IsQnWeJ6THwxah4ejG/g1+FLb/Ik9BQKgV6JPgtQgmZ0ZF?= =?us-ascii?Q?GHOnpWXPCkRC7FVs0tt3m06mHjpFNO4GPSYpzBLAwpzNknlmDXnjdb+i4rQS?= =?us-ascii?Q?fxklGMfaEWDElMW5zjDf0QJh8LWACcOOSzSVPHauP1nXS/l?=
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; DM5PR05MB3610; 6:Qm+uGLhRBpLukqxX6eBiwLUY2o3XJLJlQAdQ0LMddxTh6Yejpzw6VYPiDT5D1SbKYcbLBf3Jn4V1Ua8FJgusV1CSWWiYv88Wuf6n0XcW0a9GSfm6JWkoSgqZAjOEQHe6DADx5I84CguoZJFqpV6RAgkEAslW6khPqViU7w91gnM3TdZe8jFuD9rkBMGpIj92oPUcAXboykUVm18Fmcm9BrMFjYbCxvgRCPSAedzPnIRgRZTjC1JwLABwhv6O3tXDSOO0YaAD1e7vm9PfpxZ6nQupYMHh22jVuVmomUYe/fUtCL+d2jwyusNQAkKEJgLuhKpPSjixEVinClbFBCn4RoI8nAicIULFcgtHVTCXN5U=; 5:zuCBQeZ6RBL939tJbT3gwtJDyOoLIED2GPfDRkGSkUBMz2MdPc8Xf0aFcBNZgc3SdKQa38qVhiYcDPdGc+54jjb2r/gkXkHZlBsA3WilQ95akwU1rvWpAgkrWko/IjV/c1O80DbDpJCq5KrMzCpfpyo1AW7BoUo+TTb0hRfQhV0=; 24:2WSClq2ItoprxSs9Ho4SHNwLftspIJlk6NuGgyFB9kZIxctLW+95KezR7Iiqn+njZujSD2ahyYv86zuKB3DBzrHbSQjfQUzUz8tpDzGuj+U=; 7:AdWyWr7+BFhf1jgLItr7KUXnIOqAKc/ZglJKHkUAqEcv3cqZRrWSqozbyLv/rq+qrTNbGv4VzKtfsDNfNz0+34dftiT5aQZXAp0p7owzk7p9T/0Q+VHdSWCUfX0dMmqlSq5hfn3xXXvgKd+3V/RQoVizJWOu1d2Mf0zgGFKv+0G+K04vmL7fS31XZcLY3Mxk4ADM4ub9zgZ8bkbJyCCFZJ/KPXj1uY8DMtGQyrVsLzpdXR1IO7IrjeraP3jZb7Vy
SpamDiagnosticOutput: 1:99
SpamDiagnosticMetadata: NSPM
X-OriginatorOrg: juniper.net
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalArrivalTime: 08 Nov 2017 14:37:23.8395 (UTC)
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: affdc870-a685-4f58-a5c6-08d526b63a05
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Id: bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalAttributedTenantConnectingIp: TenantId=bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4; Ip=[66.129.239.15];  Helo=[P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net]
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-FromEntityHeader: HybridOnPrem
X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: DM5PR05MB3610
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/aRSOf89umUW9Jr4P8WhdvH9N-VQ>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deprecating MSDP
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 14:37:34 -0000

Indeed, RFC7716 is a good start.  And 
draft-zzhang-bess-bgp-multicast-01.txt goes even further to completely 
replace PIM with BGP as a multicast routing protocol.



On Wed, 8 Nov 2017, Toerless Eckert wrote:

| Or at least a good starting point, yes. In doubt an SP solution for PEs is
| likely designed to require a lot of configuration, so something more easily
| self-configuring may be required for enterprises or other environments.
| But thats just my prejudice speaking. Have to read through it in more detail.
| 
| Thanks!
|     Toerles
| 
| On Wed, Nov 08, 2017 at 10:04:46AM +0800, zhang.zheng@zte.com.cn wrote:
| > Hi Toerless,
| > 
| > >Just make all RP and LHR BGP speakers (RPs = RR) and use a BGP address family
| > to carry (S,G) SA state. Probably only small changes over how MVPN is done
| > with BGP. Just need to decide on how to do (*,G).
| > 
| > It may has been solved in RFC7716. :)
| > 
| > Best Regards,
| > Sandy
| > 
| > ------------------????????????------------------
| > ???????????? <tte@cs.fau.de>;
| > ???????????? <stig@venaas.com>;
| > ???????????? <mboned@ietf.org>;
| > ??? ??? ???2017???11???08??? 09:46
| > ??? ??? ???Re: [MBONED] deprecating MSDP
| > Improving on 4610 is a bit like proposing fixes for
| > 
| > Be happy that you didn't have to sit through the years of IETF discussing
| > the MSDP encasulated packets. Which is the dicsussion that ultimately
| > made MSDP fall froms tandard to experimental. Its really like discussing how
| > to best deal with horse manure. You really need to accept that there are no
| > good solutions other than changing your motor. Aka: the problem is
| > the data triggered PIM-SM (S,G) state building, not MSDP. MSDP just
| > tries to carry the horse manure over longer trips ;-).
| > 
| > I would just want to engineer multicast state building on top of reliable transport,
| > so i do not have to deal with all the complexities of even predicting the
| > behavior under loss. Let alone optimizing/perfecting.
| > 
| > Just make all RP and LHR BGP speakers (RPs = RR) and use a BGP address family
| > to carry (S,G) SA state. Probably only small changes over how MVPN is done
| > with BGP. Just need to decide on how to do (*,G).
| > 
| > Cheers
| > Toerless
| > 
| > On Tue, Nov 07, 2017 at 03:23:38PM -0800, Stig Venaas wrote:
| > > Hi
| > >
| > > There may be some room for improvement for 4610, but I think it's a
| > > bad idea to encapsulate data packets in TCP. I don't get why you would
| > > need that reliability. Does it need to be more reliable than regular
| > > multicast? However, it might be a good idea to use TCP to avoid
| > > periodic signaling and send just a single SA message without data.
| > > Basically doing a single NULL-register by FHR to RP when the source
| > > becomes active, and relaying this to other RPs. And of course,
| > > withdrawing the SA when source is no longer active. Alternatively
| > > doing this just between the Anycast-RPs, not involving FHR to RP.
| > >
| > > Stig
| > >
| > >
| > > On Mon, Sep 11, 2017 at 9:54 AM, Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de> wrote:
| > > > Right. So it would not enable new content owners to come in and get
| > > > an easier market entry to reach customers for live streaming... sitting
| > > > in front of STBs.
| > > >
| > > > On Mon, Sep 11, 2017 at 06:36:38PM +0200, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
| > > >> On Mon, 11 Sep 2017, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
| > > >>
| > > >> >There is URL I know of.
| > > >>
| > > >> There is *no* URL that I know of.
| > > >>
| > > >> This isn't volume business afaik. I don't remember which one it was,
| > > >> but it was basically in cooperation with one of the larger typical
| > > >> "channel package providers" you might get on coax TV. One of Canal
| > > >> Digital, VIASAT or someone like that.
| > > >>
| > > >> --
| > > >> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
| > > >
| > > > --
| > > > ---
| > > > tte@cs.fau.de
| > > >
| > > > _______________________________________________
| > > > MBONED mailing list
| > > > MBONED@ietf.org
| > > > https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__www.ietf.org_mailman_listinfo_mboned&d=DwICAg&c=HAkYuh63rsuhr6Scbfh0UjBXeMK-ndb3voDTXcWzoCI&r=iw2TU3OZ0CDpCbqeV23zdah2FoG9Do-zEmGgWTaavDg&m=rQDiyMm1c_DRTBSb1SUMotzGXWVNBJzio6Mq8C1Bfos&s=fkvyOdq3F14iAD1iYb5R_OgEXUNZetf_0PA3BmeiEoU&e=
| > 
| > --
| > ---
| > tte@cs.fau.de
| > 
| > _______________________________________________
| > MBONED mailing list
| > MBONED@ietf.org
| > https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__www.ietf.org_mailman_listinfo_mboned&d=DwICAg&c=HAkYuh63rsuhr6Scbfh0UjBXeMK-ndb3voDTXcWzoCI&r=iw2TU3OZ0CDpCbqeV23zdah2FoG9Do-zEmGgWTaavDg&m=rQDiyMm1c_DRTBSb1SUMotzGXWVNBJzio6Mq8C1Bfos&s=fkvyOdq3F14iAD1iYb5R_OgEXUNZetf_0PA3BmeiEoU&e=
| 
| 
| 
| -- 
| ---
| tte@cs.fau.de
| 
| _______________________________________________
| MBONED mailing list
| MBONED@ietf.org
| https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__www.ietf.org_mailman_listinfo_mboned&d=DwICAg&c=HAkYuh63rsuhr6Scbfh0UjBXeMK-ndb3voDTXcWzoCI&r=iw2TU3OZ0CDpCbqeV23zdah2FoG9Do-zEmGgWTaavDg&m=rQDiyMm1c_DRTBSb1SUMotzGXWVNBJzio6Mq8C1Bfos&s=fkvyOdq3F14iAD1iYb5R_OgEXUNZetf_0PA3BmeiEoU&e=
| 


From nobody Wed Nov  8 07:51:24 2017
Return-Path: <stig@venaas.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 6AEAE127A91 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 07:51:21 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -1.9
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-1.9 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE=-0.0001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=venaas-com.20150623.gappssmtp.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id U8knXbRnrhic for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 07:51:18 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mail-qt0-x233.google.com (mail-qt0-x233.google.com [IPv6:2607:f8b0:400d:c0d::233]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 (128/128 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id AB8FC127978 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 07:51:18 -0800 (PST)
Received: by mail-qt0-x233.google.com with SMTP id 1so3873250qtn.3 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed, 08 Nov 2017 07:51:18 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=venaas-com.20150623.gappssmtp.com; s=20150623; h=mime-version:in-reply-to:references:from:date:message-id:subject:to :cc; bh=VOm92tO9BNnuM0G283hgtvxrjkBC9yKXjQQ3L98lopc=; b=xlTLwbK5MJDKwf8Lhs7yK9aNBUQX7gMnQIiR+dPtRofAtVyMp17SXRQYrrysWSCcoJ wC0CcVjvff56YGf8ZsfN8fpMD5f0qzFm/O6LE9YSqbKc7f7P4bkiwGCMZFgmlfhPWNrl IJo0kK79YuOSZehdO0yTvraZUOHy7rfrTiW/NXWc9i8M0EqYCT7kn2b7tE4g5hJEoq5e E/y5mBf0x7Mh2lAvjs4yb/PPAGQYNmmXVQDm7vNwpyfI3nEgp+oGZANtcFQxjn1WixT0 Xt7+wQI7C7LroAb7qPwssmCpVyXmMYNMt8yMBOHftvNiW7SlxJMiu9XyYyg89H5RpMmZ 3HEA==
X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:mime-version:in-reply-to:references:from:date :message-id:subject:to:cc; bh=VOm92tO9BNnuM0G283hgtvxrjkBC9yKXjQQ3L98lopc=; b=uPmMqXnZO1WJHa/LFMoWVNvNBTdsPbjLsj2f0S8pMU0aAhuLCyGIa7mRVFxp73Uzqy UbE1FjQFMShfUE8+qIKDJM/3p4SskfNFC/U5Y02Y/+FI/XeVYb6VcbdkecjJrjP7KSrr 3NZc1cIqM9Q26jwBhrY+hXDSX/MVCrIIlZT75WdQmdLorFZxjXP5QXRGKUPldTlppThu tNHVTFSS1A8j3SNG9spH76XZO9Ug9F6b9tpXDEa3CRDu3FAd06zARmOOK/+OvDk6o29X PpiQpJ38iCBuVGkceSmag3ePK8aPPOiD1dzMZAKjdgsAhUBl4loptWW6RlupOofnk7Gl sCpw==
X-Gm-Message-State: AJaThX4Mo4nQeNjGpzeUc6ChLVYrO2CijoEBCrb21VWV54W6lA1GWZ46 pup8VqXSeRB1k3Taj+Vuinu8epFwIf4+4ONlpD2tQQ==
X-Google-Smtp-Source: ABhQp+RmG80mqcQcTvyr5YMoyPoawSY9euUDB/rJjkclgKo2UAcUkQhPve6dcmRmxN+9rxWYsb2+m8AgRuxaf6Ue6R0=
X-Received: by 10.200.45.28 with SMTP id n28mr1576576qta.100.1510156277548; Wed, 08 Nov 2017 07:51:17 -0800 (PST)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Received: by 10.140.28.9 with HTTP; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 07:51:17 -0800 (PST)
In-Reply-To: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se>
References: <20170725221330.GA4821@cs-it-6805697.local> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1707260908550.29724@svl-jtac-lnx02> <20170904141235.GC3194@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709051358300.14937@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se>
From: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 07:51:17 -0800
Message-ID: <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com>
To: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
Cc: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8"
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/bVXdMp-nCi_aqOI7bL6-gc5RS8M>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 15:51:21 -0000

Hi

I only meant that with AMT and Wi-Fi, the experience should hopefully
be equivalent to regular native multicast. I agree you often need FEC
to protect against loss, and also in some cases some kind of
retransmission or unicast assistance. Assuming there is no loss in the
core until an AMT relay is reached, then I suppose an AMT specific
solution could work, but I would like a generic solution that can work
for native multicast. I don't remember exactly what was done for
reliable multicast in the IETF now. Anyone remember better than me? I
remember proposals including how to do retransmissions.

Stig


On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 1:50 AM, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se> wrote:
> On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:
>
>> Hi
>>
>> I don't think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular multicast. If
>
>
> Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC is an operational nightmare
> that never stops. You need to constantly measure customer experience
> (preferrably in the STBs, all of this with proprietary solutions afaik) or
> try to measure it in your network (using expensive equipement).
>
> I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at large scale.
>
>> you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by using AMT to the device, the
>> packets will be unicast packets, so the regular Wi-Fi handling of unicast
>> packets (including retransmissions) should be sufficient. Do you need
>> additional retransmissions?
>
>
> Unicast will be far superior to multicast over wifi, but it's probably still
> not enough to give a good enough customer experience without FEC.
>
> FEC in this aspect means the application deteriorates gracefully under
> packet loss, by smearing out infomation across packets and degrading quality
> without for instance magenta squares gliding along the screen until the next
> full screen update (that might be a second into the future (or more)).
>
> This "FEC" can also be (as some have done), by the devices receiving
> multicast packets and then requesting (via unicast) from a server of some
> kind, to get the packets it lost. The few solutions available when I was
> involved in this before, were all proprietary. They were also used to speed
> up channel changes by providing full screen update immediately, before same
> information came via the multicast stream.
>
> In packet networks, packets are lost. It's a fact. They're designed to
> behave this way. From what I can see, there are two ways to handle this.
> Either we come up with a standards based retransmission mechanism for
> multicast streams that anyone can use, or we punt the problem to the
> application layer, and let them figure it out. We need to be perfectly clear
> to everybody what our choice is.
>
>
> --
> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se


From nobody Wed Nov  8 10:22:31 2017
Return-Path: <jholland@akamai.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 601301294F7 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:22:30 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.701
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.701 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_LOW=-0.7, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=akamai.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id nyL4mBBKWZwE for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:22:28 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mx0a-00190b01.pphosted.com (mx0a-00190b01.pphosted.com [IPv6:2620:100:9001:583::1]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 2A490129576 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:22:28 -0800 (PST)
Received: from pps.filterd (m0122333.ppops.net [127.0.0.1]) by mx0a-00190b01.pphosted.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vA8IMI6r004327; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 18:22:26 GMT
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=akamai.com; h=from : to : cc : subject : date : message-id : references : in-reply-to : content-type : content-id : content-transfer-encoding : mime-version; s=jan2016.eng; bh=4foqAEwW7qPDQsJKXkCR9Gh5pCMjM7JDYeOkHG8XuOQ=; b=A2cwRlW+VI8/C1U6b5fQEvs6T6WRZWy1HKbii+QWWQHCmu65vG2sX46Kn+KW0iKfIDAT prcqNJwCfW+dWYayS0xYXC7v6ZR0N9RU86CmY2GO/t3E360E0+vxwz1wFLOmTEBVzZLl nhf5ih49hbOVld0BcXm4BM0A0OAcgjnQKz3nhRDz2hHynSqIJZFN+Dz2MU9k1e+03kq9 07Vi0vUU+oXUZqm/v70qSInh1P9KQs9WN0JEv3TgVTDGEqShjiKpnU0494C+vP7uv/h4 JzQtcABUbmxGU+RE5Y0keRyI7hmq8XWJeC+sKAHEhib1cTDqGmru5drIgLvclt7z8RnN Fg== 
Received: from prod-mail-ppoint1 (prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com [184.51.33.18]) by mx0a-00190b01.pphosted.com with ESMTP id 2e3nkn3qgs-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Wed, 08 Nov 2017 18:22:26 +0000
Received: from pps.filterd (prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com [127.0.0.1]) by prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vA8IIvNu014329; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 13:22:25 -0500
Received: from email.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.32]) by prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com with ESMTP id 2e18vue18j-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Wed, 08 Nov 2017 13:22:24 -0500
Received: from usma1ex-dag1mb6.msg.corp.akamai.com (172.27.123.65) by usma1ex-dag1mb3.msg.corp.akamai.com (172.27.123.103) with Microsoft SMTP Server (TLS) id 15.0.1263.5; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 13:22:23 -0500
Received: from usma1ex-dag1mb6.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.65]) by usma1ex-dag1mb6.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.65]) with mapi id 15.00.1263.000; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 13:22:23 -0500
From: "Holland, Jake" <jholland@akamai.com>
To: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
CC: "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
Thread-Index: AQHTKFDU/aqwdbbq5kmpwFCfY4/mJKMKPziAgACyAgCAAGTJgP//pBoA
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 18:22:23 +0000
Message-ID: <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com>
References: <20170725221330.GA4821@cs-it-6805697.local> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1707260908550.29724@svl-jtac-lnx02> <20170904141235.GC3194@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709051358300.14937@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com>
In-Reply-To: <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com>
Accept-Language: en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
user-agent: Microsoft-MacOutlook/f.24.1.170721
x-ms-exchange-messagesentrepresentingtype: 1
x-ms-exchange-transport-fromentityheader: Hosted
x-originating-ip: [172.19.112.167]
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-ID: <FA5B5E7005F9DD468FC6BBA6906BA285@akamai.com>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-08_03:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 spamscore=0 suspectscore=0 malwarescore=0 phishscore=0 adultscore=0 bulkscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1707230000 definitions=main-1711080242
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-08_03:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 priorityscore=1501 malwarescore=0 suspectscore=0 phishscore=0 bulkscore=0 spamscore=0 clxscore=1011 lowpriorityscore=0 impostorscore=0 adultscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1707230000 definitions=main-1711080244
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/sd0r01wKWba_PkTazjcvIPhsaOU>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 18:22:30 -0000
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From nobody Wed Nov  8 10:32:10 2017
Return-Path: <farinacci@gmail.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 1F1911296CD for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:32:09 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9,  DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, FREEMAIL_FROM=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE=-0.0001, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmail.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id p71615MWAsCZ for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:32:06 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mail-pg0-x22a.google.com (mail-pg0-x22a.google.com [IPv6:2607:f8b0:400e:c05::22a]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 (128/128 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 9C8F01294D3 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:32:06 -0800 (PST)
Received: by mail-pg0-x22a.google.com with SMTP id j3so2560677pga.1 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed, 08 Nov 2017 10:32:06 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20161025;  h=mime-version:subject:from:in-reply-to:date:cc :content-transfer-encoding:message-id:references:to; bh=OnqIjqQaXdthLYySBqxtJsbjNG2MG6ClIK2N5J0I49s=; b=COuQrj3CPJupnFvEL87cxqyn63RAoNBaVr2NqSs9qiOlb5z4bHMveHzwarSc9uNmVp KZ+kGB6g2o0k69i/1JuIWH76z8a7mCHsnx2NZKbjTUNl1dG9KsRT8rr6HDmed3YBGBuJ z/R99EnDXAj/13jaGBBisUg1lCjQj4+TCXu8RNmrBAt41uaNM0T9mBp8R7R3TAOSTvsW bqoGhdSSE8MAeBSXoJOttgJUFSprXeMDiVyMquF0aOxFhzUHhqG371y434nfJ6GlESxs 4FCAdjV7zOrrWUt/unZ+auzGHwG19BCcyAx3CQCN0zp8X3p+PReoRPkif1+iocwjMTb/ mH4A==
X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:mime-version:subject:from:in-reply-to:date:cc :content-transfer-encoding:message-id:references:to; bh=OnqIjqQaXdthLYySBqxtJsbjNG2MG6ClIK2N5J0I49s=; b=iy8LEOh0z5hIlCNJYZSfO9PdNQK61C1GObxXSUu80Mfx9GEfaQPysDRY4jNzAx9GUt jfDChtWyvO3IIVGmMPO704QzOK4hlfg4PamWRaVkqVmdrwsg9sQHy8txmhI24UbtRSOd pFk0lSjUP23nMxJrAMY1sAyNua7lj9dis2FW6uKBntrSjLjj2z6Ir0pYr8LLZIIPGcxc DEu/v+cpySDQvTe9PlCCGgz1kdWMpbHlA6Y3cLOBTuRcnkcy6QjBbtI+DGZZYcvZpJJ+ oOd3QdN43B7wjZl8969UTsh1gCRep0BwX0gTJZolS3F2eciUdnSCgXf11hQWQtz1wCvR EPmg==
X-Gm-Message-State: AJaThX5vnTo5xLaW2gYRt7nCamEClp7XQmJxviRdVKUMS6pE08cWdF1U pcylsieS/iDQsYjkg4iiZPU=
X-Google-Smtp-Source: ABhQp+QuFzD+cEPm06Sa9EVbT3rtB/p5K0CaE3F4Fi+kcFn2X8g6ChxUNV0utRYMSjhEXWlqefvvKA==
X-Received: by 10.99.156.26 with SMTP id f26mr1294629pge.433.1510165926021; Wed, 08 Nov 2017 10:32:06 -0800 (PST)
Received: from [10.197.31.157] (173-11-119-245-SFBA.hfc.comcastbusiness.net. [173.11.119.245]) by smtp.gmail.com with ESMTPSA id l10sm8135136pgr.85.2017.11.08.10.32.04 (version=TLS1_2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 bits=128/128); Wed, 08 Nov 2017 10:32:05 -0800 (PST)
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Mime-Version: 1.0 (Mac OS X Mail 11.0 \(3445.1.7\))
From: Dino Farinacci <farinacci@gmail.com>
In-Reply-To: <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com>
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 10:32:03 -0800
Cc: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Message-Id: <A0CD4807-79F2-46AA-8CDF-FE23914A11C0@gmail.com>
References: <20170725221330.GA4821@cs-it-6805697.local> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1707260908550.29724@svl-jtac-lnx02> <20170904141235.GC3194@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709051358300.14937@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com>
To: Jake Holland <jholland@akamai.com>
X-Mailer: Apple Mail (2.3445.1.7)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/MvjtROpiCX1wM_UUH3CdiHPrDd8>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 18:32:09 -0000

Note I use LISP all the time to get multicast over Wifi via =
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-lisp-signal-free-multicast/.

If anyone wants to try it, please send me a private note.

Dino

> On Nov 8, 2017, at 10:22 AM, Holland, Jake <jholland@akamai.com> =
wrote:
>=20
> Hi,
>=20
> FLUTE and NORM are the reliable multicast transports I=E2=80=99ve =
seen:
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6726
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5740
>=20
> AFAIK neither has wide usage, but there=E2=80=99s implementations:
> http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.html
> https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/ncs/products/norm
>=20
> If I understand correctly, Cablelabs=E2=80=99s IP Multicast ABR system =
uses a sort of bastardized version of NORM with a path for out-of-band =
unicast repair that doesn=E2=80=99t let receivers prevent the transmit =
window from sliding forward, since the streaming video use case can=E2=80=99=
t use the norm approach of letting receivers slow down the transmit:
> =
https://apps.cablelabs.com/specification/?category=3DVIDEO&subcat=3DIP%20M=
ULTICAST&query=3D&doctype=3D&content=3Dfalse&archives=3Dfalse
>=20
> There=E2=80=99s some more speculative ongoing work I know of that =
might be relevant.
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-01
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-scheme-01
>=20
> I think FLUTE or NORM implementations could be made to work today for =
a non-time-critical download service, if there were multicast =
connectivity.
>=20
>=20
> I agree with Mikael that there=E2=80=99s more work to do before =
ordinary implementations of open standards can be used to operate a =
video service over multicast IP. I do want to operate a multicast video =
service, but not without FEC or some kind of repair.
>=20
> I also agree that AMT can be a helpful way to get multicast IP over =
wifi as unicast at layer 2 (though I would rather see native multicast =
to the home and either AMT relay or DMS (or both) at the wifi router, =
instead of AMT relays in the ISP, because multicast can help a lot on =
the access network for PON or CMTS, though I do take the point that in =
some cases relay in the ISP is more practical to deploy).
>=20
> But I agree with Stig that it=E2=80=99s not very helpful to make AMT =
reliable, as compared to making a sufficiently reliable multicast =
transport protocol that can work for streaming video.
>=20
> -Jake
>=20
> On 11/8/17, 7:53 AM, "Stig Venaas" <stig@venaas.com> wrote:
>=20
> Hi
>=20
> I only meant that with AMT and Wi-Fi, the experience should hopefully
> be equivalent to regular native multicast. I agree you often need FEC
> to protect against loss, and also in some cases some kind of
> retransmission or unicast assistance. Assuming there is no loss in the
> core until an AMT relay is reached, then I suppose an AMT specific
> solution could work, but I would like a generic solution that can work
> for native multicast. I don't remember exactly what was done for
> reliable multicast in the IETF now. Anyone remember better than me? I
> remember proposals including how to do retransmissions.
>=20
> Stig
>=20
>=20
> On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 1:50 AM, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se> =
wrote:
>> On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:
>>=20
>>> Hi
>>>=20
>>> I don't think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular multicast. =
If
>>=20
>>=20
>> Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC is an operational =
nightmare
>> that never stops. You need to constantly measure customer experience
>> (preferrably in the STBs, all of this with proprietary solutions =
afaik) or
>> try to measure it in your network (using expensive equipement).
>>=20
>> I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at large scale.
>>=20
>>> you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by using AMT to the device, the
>>> packets will be unicast packets, so the regular Wi-Fi handling of =
unicast
>>> packets (including retransmissions) should be sufficient. Do you =
need
>>> additional retransmissions?
>>=20
>>=20
>> Unicast will be far superior to multicast over wifi, but it's =
probably still
>> not enough to give a good enough customer experience without FEC.
>>=20
>> FEC in this aspect means the application deteriorates gracefully =
under
>> packet loss, by smearing out infomation across packets and degrading =
quality
>> without for instance magenta squares gliding along the screen until =
the next
>> full screen update (that might be a second into the future (or =
more)).
>>=20
>> This "FEC" can also be (as some have done), by the devices receiving
>> multicast packets and then requesting (via unicast) from a server of =
some
>> kind, to get the packets it lost. The few solutions available when I =
was
>> involved in this before, were all proprietary. They were also used to =
speed
>> up channel changes by providing full screen update immediately, =
before same
>> information came via the multicast stream.
>>=20
>> In packet networks, packets are lost. It's a fact. They're designed =
to
>> behave this way. =46rom what I can see, there are two ways to handle =
this.
>> Either we come up with a standards based retransmission mechanism for
>> multicast streams that anyone can use, or we punt the problem to the
>> application layer, and let them figure it out. We need to be =
perfectly clear
>> to everybody what our choice is.
>>=20
>>=20
>> --
>> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
>=20
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
>=20
>=20
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned


From nobody Wed Nov  8 10:54:41 2017
Return-Path: <gjshep@gmail.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 9936A129B25 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:54:39 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -1.999
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-1.999 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, FREEMAIL_FROM=0.001, HTML_MESSAGE=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE=-0.0001, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmail.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id jXF6Igb9eGop for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:54:35 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mail-it0-x22b.google.com (mail-it0-x22b.google.com [IPv6:2607:f8b0:4001:c0b::22b]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 (128/128 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 4E2DE129B14 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 10:54:35 -0800 (PST)
Received: by mail-it0-x22b.google.com with SMTP id y15so8088559ita.4 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed, 08 Nov 2017 10:54:35 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20161025;  h=mime-version:reply-to:in-reply-to:references:from:date:message-id :subject:to:cc; bh=/DGXdDHvTlf6I6+GVQfsdAdZFcW1rzN/MuHhE1ZbL+s=; b=f1/JDoSMYo3IJzAnyngLXJEREvbCNZ1ejtG9cGTfsuqHlMyQ++rq1Rb5yHQ21Hv/rE lZt+oxlrkhuUQAqLpL/WilS2wIRKifISAC/MW1tiV3MFCpLhOyeLBnrd0B6dF8gJcNVr bkpXkarLlnF0j00WmL6NhUvumBbR1r0Yz9cU93Qp6BoUJXmQdVgV4g34WIiRZjMd5Lmr 87hMu4xLJTsc0RtCOwYBR9bmcAtU56gMukjnWh6xtnbSRlnUq97OmLkBvY207kH83cBj ZttoO3GxQkM+XCOHy9uNLPJiFVKc8FBqh82OHAddiFwDR9k/oomOho2KVvkDN3AzB96n js3g==
X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:mime-version:reply-to:in-reply-to:references :from:date:message-id:subject:to:cc; bh=/DGXdDHvTlf6I6+GVQfsdAdZFcW1rzN/MuHhE1ZbL+s=; b=UrOE2B7ZFjBTEoScEcN4zd6lr4kBxBCqNMszEcd4nf5cBxcN+c8bpxRqLs330BycnV DbDaBAk7hQ8OiCbnl8NblasjuDv0dNx8NEyC+XaWcZrwM6yZHJtL3KXlWnYsjYf+U1Ya XtYqRvo83UNpgIModJVpoAZ+TAdX7kDWWzzh29KcZ8qQZrrVS6ghqrlHZtf6QsA92XBi BO9Zig9SXwD7koijXkQw4kyA2fBhh+cpMQDsoEx/Ugkh3eGMf82K0e8gxX0MZwr9VPnb OfiXE9xqjVLxz0TSUxLYo3kW7/K52DyHTSgUntmm42D4Go/bk1n9dacszilEVUfZXNht dfEg==
X-Gm-Message-State: AJaThX5N6I2RThw8Zurk/NDTseiI1wdIhguSVlaIuYoNL8lf63/72jWK veAt8tOBxzWG0DJNRfZ5HytmOTduJesH3eoSfY8=
X-Google-Smtp-Source: ABhQp+Q0/9/E8Go2NGcc4F20EuDRvrw2w0pwqeLOvTKCAVsAwASUbn7DiVL8CMf02SsXUZWhHFvYiyDW6T3Id14RR6Q=
X-Received: by 10.36.138.1 with SMTP id v1mr1961451itd.124.1510167274443; Wed, 08 Nov 2017 10:54:34 -0800 (PST)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Received: by 10.2.165.19 with HTTP; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 10:54:33 -0800 (PST)
Reply-To: gjshep@gmail.com
In-Reply-To: <A0CD4807-79F2-46AA-8CDF-FE23914A11C0@gmail.com>
References: <20170725221330.GA4821@cs-it-6805697.local> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1707260908550.29724@svl-jtac-lnx02> <20170904141235.GC3194@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709051358300.14937@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com> <A0CD4807-79F2-46AA-8CDF-FE23914A11C0@gmail.com>
From: Greg Shepherd <gjshep@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 10:54:33 -0800
Message-ID: <CABFReBpWM=jHV4kMUkFXvieVTum7=F_h4CXTn+kDns0Ta-wyFA@mail.gmail.com>
To: Dino Farinacci <farinacci@gmail.com>
Cc: Jake Holland <jholland@akamai.com>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="94eb2c08976af1d8ed055d7d373c"
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/wCU-k19QYyUBSvnaizZVLELDDQw>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 18:54:39 -0000

--94eb2c08976af1d8ed055d7d373c
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 10:32 AM, Dino Farinacci <farinacci@gmail.com> wrote=
:

> Note I use LISP all the time to get multicast over Wifi via
> https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-lisp-signal-free-multicast/.
>
> If anyone wants to try it, please send me a private note.
>
> Dino


Exactly. ANY unicast encap of multicast over wifi will gain from the wifi
loss retransmission.

Greg


> > On Nov 8, 2017, at 10:22 AM, Holland, Jake <jholland@akamai.com> wrote:
> >
> > Hi,
> >
> > FLUTE and NORM are the reliable multicast transports I=E2=80=99ve seen:
> > https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6726
> > https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5740
> >
> > AFAIK neither has wide usage, but there=E2=80=99s implementations:
> > http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.html
> > https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/ncs/products/norm
> >
> > If I understand correctly, Cablelabs=E2=80=99s IP Multicast ABR system =
uses a
> sort of bastardized version of NORM with a path for out-of-band unicast
> repair that doesn=E2=80=99t let receivers prevent the transmit window fro=
m sliding
> forward, since the streaming video use case can=E2=80=99t use the norm ap=
proach of
> letting receivers slow down the transmit:
> > https://apps.cablelabs.com/specification/?category=3DVIDEO&
> subcat=3DIP%20MULTICAST&query=3D&doctype=3D&content=3Dfalse&archives=3Dfa=
lse
> >
> > There=E2=80=99s some more speculative ongoing work I know of that might=
 be
> relevant.
> > https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-01
> > https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-scheme-01
> >
> > I think FLUTE or NORM implementations could be made to work today for a
> non-time-critical download service, if there were multicast connectivity.
> >
> >
> > I agree with Mikael that there=E2=80=99s more work to do before ordinar=
y
> implementations of open standards can be used to operate a video service
> over multicast IP. I do want to operate a multicast video service, but no=
t
> without FEC or some kind of repair.
> >
> > I also agree that AMT can be a helpful way to get multicast IP over wif=
i
> as unicast at layer 2 (though I would rather see native multicast to the
> home and either AMT relay or DMS (or both) at the wifi router, instead of
> AMT relays in the ISP, because multicast can help a lot on the access
> network for PON or CMTS, though I do take the point that in some cases
> relay in the ISP is more practical to deploy).
> >
> > But I agree with Stig that it=E2=80=99s not very helpful to make AMT re=
liable,
> as compared to making a sufficiently reliable multicast transport protoco=
l
> that can work for streaming video.
> >
> > -Jake
> >
> > On 11/8/17, 7:53 AM, "Stig Venaas" <stig@venaas.com> wrote:
> >
> > Hi
> >
> > I only meant that with AMT and Wi-Fi, the experience should hopefully
> > be equivalent to regular native multicast. I agree you often need FEC
> > to protect against loss, and also in some cases some kind of
> > retransmission or unicast assistance. Assuming there is no loss in the
> > core until an AMT relay is reached, then I suppose an AMT specific
> > solution could work, but I would like a generic solution that can work
> > for native multicast. I don't remember exactly what was done for
> > reliable multicast in the IETF now. Anyone remember better than me? I
> > remember proposals including how to do retransmissions.
> >
> > Stig
> >
> >
> > On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 1:50 AM, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
> wrote:
> >> On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:
> >>
> >>> Hi
> >>>
> >>> I don't think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular multicast. I=
f
> >>
> >>
> >> Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC is an operational
> nightmare
> >> that never stops. You need to constantly measure customer experience
> >> (preferrably in the STBs, all of this with proprietary solutions afaik=
)
> or
> >> try to measure it in your network (using expensive equipement).
> >>
> >> I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at large scale.
> >>
> >>> you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by using AMT to the device, the
> >>> packets will be unicast packets, so the regular Wi-Fi handling of
> unicast
> >>> packets (including retransmissions) should be sufficient. Do you need
> >>> additional retransmissions?
> >>
> >>
> >> Unicast will be far superior to multicast over wifi, but it's probably
> still
> >> not enough to give a good enough customer experience without FEC.
> >>
> >> FEC in this aspect means the application deteriorates gracefully under
> >> packet loss, by smearing out infomation across packets and degrading
> quality
> >> without for instance magenta squares gliding along the screen until th=
e
> next
> >> full screen update (that might be a second into the future (or more)).
> >>
> >> This "FEC" can also be (as some have done), by the devices receiving
> >> multicast packets and then requesting (via unicast) from a server of
> some
> >> kind, to get the packets it lost. The few solutions available when I w=
as
> >> involved in this before, were all proprietary. They were also used to
> speed
> >> up channel changes by providing full screen update immediately, before
> same
> >> information came via the multicast stream.
> >>
> >> In packet networks, packets are lost. It's a fact. They're designed to
> >> behave this way. From what I can see, there are two ways to handle thi=
s.
> >> Either we come up with a standards based retransmission mechanism for
> >> multicast streams that anyone can use, or we punt the problem to the
> >> application layer, and let them figure it out. We need to be perfectly
> clear
> >> to everybody what our choice is.
> >>
> >>
> >> --
> >> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > MBONED mailing list
> > MBONED@ietf.org
> > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
> >
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > MBONED mailing list
> > MBONED@ietf.org
> > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
>
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
>

--94eb2c08976af1d8ed055d7d373c
Content-Type: text/html; charset="UTF-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

<div dir=3D"ltr"><br><div class=3D"gmail_extra"><br><div class=3D"gmail_quo=
te">On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 10:32 AM, Dino Farinacci <span dir=3D"ltr">&lt;<=
a href=3D"mailto:farinacci@gmail.com" target=3D"_blank">farinacci@gmail.com=
</a>&gt;</span> wrote:<br><blockquote class=3D"gmail_quote" style=3D"margin=
:0 0 0 .8ex;border-left:1px #ccc solid;padding-left:1ex">Note I use LISP al=
l the time to get multicast over Wifi via <a href=3D"https://datatracker.ie=
tf.org/doc/draft-ietf-lisp-signal-free-multicast/" rel=3D"noreferrer" targe=
t=3D"_blank">https://datatracker.ietf.org/<wbr>doc/draft-ietf-lisp-signal-<=
wbr>free-multicast/</a>.<br>
<br>
If anyone wants to try it, please send me a private note.<br>
<span class=3D"HOEnZb"><font color=3D"#888888"><br>
Dino</font></span></blockquote><div><br></div><div>Exactly. ANY unicast enc=
ap of multicast over wifi will gain from the wifi loss retransmission.</div=
><div><br></div><div>Greg</div><div>=C2=A0</div><blockquote class=3D"gmail_=
quote" style=3D"margin:0 0 0 .8ex;border-left:1px #ccc solid;padding-left:1=
ex"><div class=3D"HOEnZb"><div class=3D"h5">
&gt; On Nov 8, 2017, at 10:22 AM, Holland, Jake &lt;<a href=3D"mailto:jholl=
and@akamai.com">jholland@akamai.com</a>&gt; wrote:<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; Hi,<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; FLUTE and NORM are the reliable multicast transports I=E2=80=99ve seen=
:<br>
&gt; <a href=3D"https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6726" rel=3D"noreferrer" tar=
get=3D"_blank">https://tools.ietf.org/html/<wbr>rfc6726</a><br>
&gt; <a href=3D"https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5740" rel=3D"noreferrer" tar=
get=3D"_blank">https://tools.ietf.org/html/<wbr>rfc5740</a><br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; AFAIK neither has wide usage, but there=E2=80=99s implementations:<br>
&gt; <a href=3D"http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.html" rel=3D"noreferrer" targ=
et=3D"_blank">http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.<wbr>html</a><br>
&gt; <a href=3D"https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/ncs/products/norm" rel=3D"nore=
ferrer" target=3D"_blank">https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/<wbr>ncs/products/no=
rm</a><br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; If I understand correctly, Cablelabs=E2=80=99s IP Multicast ABR system=
 uses a sort of bastardized version of NORM with a path for out-of-band uni=
cast repair that doesn=E2=80=99t let receivers prevent the transmit window =
from sliding forward, since the streaming video use case can=E2=80=99t use =
the norm approach of letting receivers slow down the transmit:<br>
&gt; <a href=3D"https://apps.cablelabs.com/specification/?category=3DVIDEO&=
amp;subcat=3DIP%20MULTICAST&amp;query=3D&amp;doctype=3D&amp;content=3Dfalse=
&amp;archives=3Dfalse" rel=3D"noreferrer" target=3D"_blank">https://apps.ca=
blelabs.com/<wbr>specification/?category=3DVIDEO&amp;<wbr>subcat=3DIP%20MUL=
TICAST&amp;query=3D&amp;<wbr>doctype=3D&amp;content=3Dfalse&amp;<wbr>archiv=
es=3Dfalse</a><br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; There=E2=80=99s some more speculative ongoing work I know of that migh=
t be relevant.<br>
&gt; <a href=3D"https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-01=
" rel=3D"noreferrer" target=3D"_blank">https://tools.ietf.org/html/<wbr>dra=
ft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-<wbr>01</a><br>
&gt; <a href=3D"https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-scheme=
-01" rel=3D"noreferrer" target=3D"_blank">https://tools.ietf.org/html/<wbr>=
draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-<wbr>scheme-01</a><br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; I think FLUTE or NORM implementations could be made to work today for =
a non-time-critical download service, if there were multicast connectivity.=
<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; I agree with Mikael that there=E2=80=99s more work to do before ordina=
ry implementations of open standards can be used to operate a video service=
 over multicast IP. I do want to operate a multicast video service, but not=
 without FEC or some kind of repair.<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; I also agree that AMT can be a helpful way to get multicast IP over wi=
fi as unicast at layer 2 (though I would rather see native multicast to the=
 home and either AMT relay or DMS (or both) at the wifi router, instead of =
AMT relays in the ISP, because multicast can help a lot on the access netwo=
rk for PON or CMTS, though I do take the point that in some cases relay in =
the ISP is more practical to deploy).<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; But I agree with Stig that it=E2=80=99s not very helpful to make AMT r=
eliable, as compared to making a sufficiently reliable multicast transport =
protocol that can work for streaming video.<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; -Jake<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; On 11/8/17, 7:53 AM, &quot;Stig Venaas&quot; &lt;<a href=3D"mailto:sti=
g@venaas.com">stig@venaas.com</a>&gt; wrote:<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; Hi<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; I only meant that with AMT and Wi-Fi, the experience should hopefully<=
br>
&gt; be equivalent to regular native multicast. I agree you often need FEC<=
br>
&gt; to protect against loss, and also in some cases some kind of<br>
&gt; retransmission or unicast assistance. Assuming there is no loss in the=
<br>
&gt; core until an AMT relay is reached, then I suppose an AMT specific<br>
&gt; solution could work, but I would like a generic solution that can work=
<br>
&gt; for native multicast. I don&#39;t remember exactly what was done for<b=
r>
&gt; reliable multicast in the IETF now. Anyone remember better than me? I<=
br>
&gt; remember proposals including how to do retransmissions.<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; Stig<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 1:50 AM, Mikael Abrahamsson &lt;<a href=3D"mail=
to:swmike@swm.pp.se">swmike@swm.pp.se</a>&gt; wrote:<br>
&gt;&gt; On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt;&gt; Hi<br>
&gt;&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt;&gt; I don&#39;t think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular m=
ulticast. If<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt; Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC is an operational ni=
ghtmare<br>
&gt;&gt; that never stops. You need to constantly measure customer experien=
ce<br>
&gt;&gt; (preferrably in the STBs, all of this with proprietary solutions a=
faik) or<br>
&gt;&gt; try to measure it in your network (using expensive equipement).<br=
>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt; I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at large scale.<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt;&gt; you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by using AMT to the device=
, the<br>
&gt;&gt;&gt; packets will be unicast packets, so the regular Wi-Fi handling=
 of unicast<br>
&gt;&gt;&gt; packets (including retransmissions) should be sufficient. Do y=
ou need<br>
&gt;&gt;&gt; additional retransmissions?<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt; Unicast will be far superior to multicast over wifi, but it&#39;s =
probably still<br>
&gt;&gt; not enough to give a good enough customer experience without FEC.<=
br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt; FEC in this aspect means the application deteriorates gracefully u=
nder<br>
&gt;&gt; packet loss, by smearing out infomation across packets and degradi=
ng quality<br>
&gt;&gt; without for instance magenta squares gliding along the screen unti=
l the next<br>
&gt;&gt; full screen update (that might be a second into the future (or mor=
e)).<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt; This &quot;FEC&quot; can also be (as some have done), by the devic=
es receiving<br>
&gt;&gt; multicast packets and then requesting (via unicast) from a server =
of some<br>
&gt;&gt; kind, to get the packets it lost. The few solutions available when=
 I was<br>
&gt;&gt; involved in this before, were all proprietary. They were also used=
 to speed<br>
&gt;&gt; up channel changes by providing full screen update immediately, be=
fore same<br>
&gt;&gt; information came via the multicast stream.<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt; In packet networks, packets are lost. It&#39;s a fact. They&#39;re=
 designed to<br>
&gt;&gt; behave this way. From what I can see, there are two ways to handle=
 this.<br>
&gt;&gt; Either we come up with a standards based retransmission mechanism =
for<br>
&gt;&gt; multicast streams that anyone can use, or we punt the problem to t=
he<br>
&gt;&gt; application layer, and let them figure it out. We need to be perfe=
ctly clear<br>
&gt;&gt; to everybody what our choice is.<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt; --<br>
&gt;&gt; Mikael Abrahamsson=C2=A0 =C2=A0 email: <a href=3D"mailto:swmike@sw=
m.pp.se">swmike@swm.pp.se</a><br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; ______________________________<wbr>_________________<br>
&gt; MBONED mailing list<br>
&gt; <a href=3D"mailto:MBONED@ietf.org">MBONED@ietf.org</a><br>
&gt; <a href=3D"https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned" rel=3D"norefe=
rrer" target=3D"_blank">https://www.ietf.org/mailman/<wbr>listinfo/mboned</=
a><br>
&gt;<br>
&gt;<br>
&gt; ______________________________<wbr>_________________<br>
&gt; MBONED mailing list<br>
&gt; <a href=3D"mailto:MBONED@ietf.org">MBONED@ietf.org</a><br>
&gt; <a href=3D"https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned" rel=3D"norefe=
rrer" target=3D"_blank">https://www.ietf.org/mailman/<wbr>listinfo/mboned</=
a><br>
<br>
______________________________<wbr>_________________<br>
MBONED mailing list<br>
<a href=3D"mailto:MBONED@ietf.org">MBONED@ietf.org</a><br>
<a href=3D"https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned" rel=3D"noreferrer"=
 target=3D"_blank">https://www.ietf.org/mailman/<wbr>listinfo/mboned</a><br=
>
</div></div></blockquote></div><br></div></div>

--94eb2c08976af1d8ed055d7d373c--


From nobody Wed Nov  8 12:34:42 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 2F383129BC5 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 12:34:41 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.199
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.199 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id giMPs0KRVxpE for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 12:34:38 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id DC80D129BA0 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 12:34:37 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 484C158C4D2; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 21:34:33 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 26C2AB0D0FF; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 21:34:33 +0100 (CET)
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 21:34:33 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
Cc: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171108203432.GA11560@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/6dTsOfNHaICMpwn44jQUinS5rFo>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 20:34:41 -0000

On Wed, Nov 08, 2017 at 10:50:34AM +0100, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
> On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:
> 
> >Hi
> >
> >I don't think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular multicast. If
> 
> Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC is an operational
> nightmare that never stops.

I'd limit this to "over non-sp-controlled networks" (e.g.: home). It
works fine since a decade in e.g.: cable networks from headend to fiber/coax
edge for example.

> You need to constantly measure customer
> experience (preferrably in the STBs, all of this with proprietary
> solutions afaik) or try to measure it in your network (using
> expensive equipement).

What standard mechanisms are used to diagnose unicast/ABR into STBs
such as self-unfriendlyness congestion issues ?

But pointing to others aside: Should definitely have a well defined standards & diagnostics
stack profile for multicast TV reception. Not sure if this is a job for Mboned or
some ART group though.

> I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at large scale.

Any published experience from the last 6? years of T-Entertain? IP multicast service ?

[...]
> Unicast will be far superior to multicast over wifi, but it's
> probably still not enough to give a good enough customer experience
> without FEC.
> 
> FEC in this aspect means the application deteriorates gracefully
> under packet loss, by smearing out infomation across packets and
> degrading quality without for instance magenta squares gliding along
> the screen until the next full screen update (that might be a second
> into the future (or more)).

Slick brand marketing!

   "Real-time magenta subscriber diagnostics of wifi problems".

> This "FEC" can also be (as some have done), by the devices receiving
> multicast packets and then requesting (via unicast) from a server of
> some kind, to get the packets it lost. The few solutions available
> when I was involved in this before, were all proprietary. They were
> also used to speed up channel changes by providing full screen
> update immediately, before same information came via the multicast
> stream.

The MSTV solution was proprietary. IETF did standardize RTP extensions
to allow for standardized implementation of these mechanisms: RTCP
retransmission requests to be used both for randomn loss (eg: by DSL/ATM
link) as well as "retransmiss" from last IDR frame after channel change.
Look for RFCs with Ali Begen on it. 

The availability of this standardized RTP/RTCP option of course is
a possible challenger for trying to redo this with AMT or similar.
Especially if we can not figure out how to support the channel change
retransmission equall well. 

These retransmission mechanisms are really orthogonal to FEC but can of
course be combined.

Fixed rate FEC is pretty good for predictable BER cases but not a good
choice for highly irregular and bursty packet loss like on WiFi.
Which is why WiFi itself opted for a retransmission scheme. 

> In packet networks, packets are lost. It's a fact. They're designed
> to behave this way.

Even unicast reliable transport is built with a certain
expectation of reliability in the network layer. One rule is
that network layer protocols must not have repeatable predictable loss.
This was why we dragged on forever with the MSDP data-in-SA discussion.

In reality, the more important loss limit is IMHO the amount of
random (non-congestion caused) loss that transport protocols will support
without assuming congestion - aka: don't downspeed.

If i remember correctly, TCP starts to speed down if it sees loss
while still repairing another loss. So maybe 1 loss per RTT is ok.
<= 200 msec e2e RTT for internet traffic, 20 TCP connections in parallel
== < 1 packet/10 msec random loss.

> From what I can see, there are two ways to
> handle this. Either we come up with a standards based retransmission
> mechanism for multicast streams that anyone can use, or we punt the
> problem to the application layer, and let them figure it out. We
> need to be perfectly clear to everybody what our choice is.

First of all, there are the above mentioned RT(C)P retransmission
schemes, so the question is why those are insufficient:


- automatic feature on home-gateways: could we make these
  RTP retransmissions work automatic on a home-gateway, eg:
  if native IP multicast was used. For random WiFi loss i think
  we can. For fast channel change, i think the RT(C)P feature
  on the home gateway would need to punt the retransmission requests
  back to a cache in the SP network.

- automatic feature on home-gateways in the face of AMT into the
  client device. No change if home gateway is relay. More difficult
  when it is not.

- Use of non-RTP based multicast. Relevant or not ?  If it is relevant
  then we'd have to resolve to some non-rtp based mechanism and maybe some
  scheme like i mentioned in prior email wih TCP might be the best solution.

Live and let Die with RTP [Y/N] ?

Cheers
    Toerless

> -- 
> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
> 
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Wed Nov  8 12:59:22 2017
Return-Path: <morten@steinwurf.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 2CCD81271DF for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 12:59:21 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.599
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.599 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HTML_MESSAGE=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_LOW=-0.7] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id xvk9txVywPr7 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 12:59:18 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mailout-taastrup.gigahost.dk (mailout-taastrup.gigahost.dk [46.183.139.199]) (using TLSv1 with cipher ADH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 7C692126FB3 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 12:59:17 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mailout.gigahost.dk (mailout.gigahost.dk [89.186.169.112]) by mailout-taastrup.gigahost.dk (Postfix) with ESMTP id E3A94844FA3 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 20:59:15 +0000 (UTC)
Received: from smtp.gigahost.dk (smtp.gigahost.dk [89.186.169.109]) by mailout.gigahost.dk (Postfix) with ESMTP id AE660D147A2 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 20:59:15 +0000 (UTC)
Received: by smtp.gigahost.dk (Postfix, from userid 1000) id A7A402721A23; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 20:59:15 +0000 (UTC)
X-Screener-Id: f8b5956341cafa01bc0fc2c7b7d4a245e1dff3de
Received: from [192.168.87.101] (unknown [85.218.156.127]) by smtp.gigahost.dk (Postfix) with ESMTPSA id 4CFEA27214AD for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 20:59:15 +0000 (UTC)
To: mboned@ietf.org
References: <20170725221330.GA4821@cs-it-6805697.local> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709051358300.14937@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com> <A0CD4807-79F2-46AA-8CDF-FE23914A11C0@gmail.com> <CABFReBpWM=jHV4kMUkFXvieVTum7=F_h4CXTn+kDns0Ta-wyFA@mail.gmail.com>
From: "Morten V. Pedersen" <morten@steinwurf.com>
Message-ID: <892dba93-8df4-e5f7-a28b-1ce181982dd2@steinwurf.com>
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 21:59:15 +0100
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:52.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/52.4.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
In-Reply-To: <CABFReBpWM=jHV4kMUkFXvieVTum7=F_h4CXTn+kDns0Ta-wyFA@mail.gmail.com>
Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="------------19DA19A520D4904A5A97CFFE"
Content-Language: en-US
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/6jKCymiAYzcrpuXg4NyC6G_B5dc>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 20:59:21 -0000

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------19DA19A520D4904A5A97CFFE
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8; format=flowed
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit

Hi,
In general providing reliable multicast over WiFi is a challenging 
problem. We did our own implementation of such a transport some years 
back. We have a bit of public information on it here:
http://www.steinwurf.com/products/score.html

Multicast over WiFi is very challenging also due to the way 802.11 
treats multicast traffic:
https://www.ietf.org/id/draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement-01.txt

In my experience it is hard to avoid some form of FEC (erasure coding) 
if the multicast needs to be able to scale up to a substantial amount of 
receivers.

All the best,
Morten

On 11/08/2017 07:54 PM, Greg Shepherd wrote:
>
>
> On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 10:32 AM, Dino Farinacci <farinacci@gmail.com 
> <mailto:farinacci@gmail.com>> wrote:
>
>     Note I use LISP all the time to get multicast over Wifi via
>     https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-lisp-signal-free-multicast/
>     <https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-lisp-signal-free-multicast/>.
>
>     If anyone wants to try it, please send me a private note.
>
>     Dino
>
>
> Exactly. ANY unicast encap of multicast over wifi will gain from the 
> wifi loss retransmission.
>
> Greg
>
>     > On Nov 8, 2017, at 10:22 AM, Holland, Jake <jholland@akamai.com
>     <mailto:jholland@akamai.com>> wrote:
>     >
>     > Hi,
>     >
>     > FLUTE and NORM are the reliable multicast transports I’ve seen:
>     > https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6726
>     <https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6726>
>     > https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5740
>     <https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5740>
>     >
>     > AFAIK neither has wide usage, but there’s implementations:
>     > http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.html
>     <http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.html>
>     > https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/ncs/products/norm
>     <https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/ncs/products/norm>
>     >
>     > If I understand correctly, Cablelabs’s IP Multicast ABR system
>     uses a sort of bastardized version of NORM with a path for
>     out-of-band unicast repair that doesn’t let receivers prevent the
>     transmit window from sliding forward, since the streaming video
>     use case can’t use the norm approach of letting receivers slow
>     down the transmit:
>     >
>     https://apps.cablelabs.com/specification/?category=VIDEO&subcat=IP%20MULTICAST&query=&doctype=&content=false&archives=false
>     <https://apps.cablelabs.com/specification/?category=VIDEO&subcat=IP%20MULTICAST&query=&doctype=&content=false&archives=false>
>     >
>     > There’s some more speculative ongoing work I know of that might
>     be relevant.
>     > https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-01
>     <https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-01>
>     > https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-scheme-01
>     <https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-scheme-01>
>     >
>     > I think FLUTE or NORM implementations could be made to work
>     today for a non-time-critical download service, if there were
>     multicast connectivity.
>     >
>     >
>     > I agree with Mikael that there’s more work to do before ordinary
>     implementations of open standards can be used to operate a video
>     service over multicast IP. I do want to operate a multicast video
>     service, but not without FEC or some kind of repair.
>     >
>     > I also agree that AMT can be a helpful way to get multicast IP
>     over wifi as unicast at layer 2 (though I would rather see native
>     multicast to the home and either AMT relay or DMS (or both) at the
>     wifi router, instead of AMT relays in the ISP, because multicast
>     can help a lot on the access network for PON or CMTS, though I do
>     take the point that in some cases relay in the ISP is more
>     practical to deploy).
>     >
>     > But I agree with Stig that it’s not very helpful to make AMT
>     reliable, as compared to making a sufficiently reliable multicast
>     transport protocol that can work for streaming video.
>     >
>     > -Jake
>     >
>     > On 11/8/17, 7:53 AM, "Stig Venaas" <stig@venaas.com
>     <mailto:stig@venaas.com>> wrote:
>     >
>     > Hi
>     >
>     > I only meant that with AMT and Wi-Fi, the experience should
>     hopefully
>     > be equivalent to regular native multicast. I agree you often
>     need FEC
>     > to protect against loss, and also in some cases some kind of
>     > retransmission or unicast assistance. Assuming there is no loss
>     in the
>     > core until an AMT relay is reached, then I suppose an AMT specific
>     > solution could work, but I would like a generic solution that
>     can work
>     > for native multicast. I don't remember exactly what was done for
>     > reliable multicast in the IETF now. Anyone remember better than
>     me? I
>     > remember proposals including how to do retransmissions.
>     >
>     > Stig
>     >
>     >
>     > On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 1:50 AM, Mikael Abrahamsson
>     <swmike@swm.pp.se <mailto:swmike@swm.pp.se>> wrote:
>     >> On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:
>     >>
>     >>> Hi
>     >>>
>     >>> I don't think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular
>     multicast. If
>     >>
>     >>
>     >> Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC is an operational
>     nightmare
>     >> that never stops. You need to constantly measure customer
>     experience
>     >> (preferrably in the STBs, all of this with proprietary
>     solutions afaik) or
>     >> try to measure it in your network (using expensive equipement).
>     >>
>     >> I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at large scale.
>     >>
>     >>> you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by using AMT to the
>     device, the
>     >>> packets will be unicast packets, so the regular Wi-Fi handling
>     of unicast
>     >>> packets (including retransmissions) should be sufficient. Do
>     you need
>     >>> additional retransmissions?
>     >>
>     >>
>     >> Unicast will be far superior to multicast over wifi, but it's
>     probably still
>     >> not enough to give a good enough customer experience without FEC.
>     >>
>     >> FEC in this aspect means the application deteriorates
>     gracefully under
>     >> packet loss, by smearing out infomation across packets and
>     degrading quality
>     >> without for instance magenta squares gliding along the screen
>     until the next
>     >> full screen update (that might be a second into the future (or
>     more)).
>     >>
>     >> This "FEC" can also be (as some have done), by the devices
>     receiving
>     >> multicast packets and then requesting (via unicast) from a
>     server of some
>     >> kind, to get the packets it lost. The few solutions available
>     when I was
>     >> involved in this before, were all proprietary. They were also
>     used to speed
>     >> up channel changes by providing full screen update immediately,
>     before same
>     >> information came via the multicast stream.
>     >>
>     >> In packet networks, packets are lost. It's a fact. They're
>     designed to
>     >> behave this way. From what I can see, there are two ways to
>     handle this.
>     >> Either we come up with a standards based retransmission
>     mechanism for
>     >> multicast streams that anyone can use, or we punt the problem
>     to the
>     >> application layer, and let them figure it out. We need to be
>     perfectly clear
>     >> to everybody what our choice is.
>     >>
>     >>
>     >> --
>     >> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
>     <mailto:swmike@swm.pp.se>
>     >
>     > _______________________________________________
>     > MBONED mailing list
>     > MBONED@ietf.org <mailto:MBONED@ietf.org>
>     > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
>     <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>
>     >
>     >
>     > _______________________________________________
>     > MBONED mailing list
>     > MBONED@ietf.org <mailto:MBONED@ietf.org>
>     > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
>     <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>
>
>     _______________________________________________
>     MBONED mailing list
>     MBONED@ietf.org <mailto:MBONED@ietf.org>
>     https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
>     <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned


--------------19DA19A520D4904A5A97CFFE
Content-Type: text/html; charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit

<html>
  <head>
    <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=utf-8">
  </head>
  <body bgcolor="#FFFFFF" text="#000000">
    Hi,<br>
    In general providing reliable multicast over WiFi is a challenging
    problem. We did our own implementation of such a transport some
    years back. We have a bit of public information on it here:<br>
    <a class="moz-txt-link-freetext" href="http://www.steinwurf.com/products/score.html">http://www.steinwurf.com/products/score.html</a><br>
    <br>
    Multicast over WiFi is very challenging also due to the way 802.11
    treats multicast traffic:<br>
<a class="moz-txt-link-freetext" href="https://www.ietf.org/id/draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement-01.txt">https://www.ietf.org/id/draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement-01.txt</a><br>
    <br>
    In my experience it is hard to avoid some form of FEC (erasure
    coding) if the multicast needs to be able to scale up to a
    substantial amount of receivers.  <br>
    <br>
    All the best,<br>
    Morten<br>
    <br>
    <div class="moz-cite-prefix">On 11/08/2017 07:54 PM, Greg Shepherd
      wrote:<br>
    </div>
    <blockquote type="cite"
cite="mid:CABFReBpWM=jHV4kMUkFXvieVTum7=F_h4CXTn+kDns0Ta-wyFA@mail.gmail.com">
      <div dir="ltr"><br>
        <div class="gmail_extra"><br>
          <div class="gmail_quote">On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 10:32 AM, Dino
            Farinacci <span dir="ltr">&lt;<a
                href="mailto:farinacci@gmail.com" target="_blank"
                moz-do-not-send="true">farinacci@gmail.com</a>&gt;</span>
            wrote:<br>
            <blockquote class="gmail_quote" style="margin:0 0 0
              .8ex;border-left:1px #ccc solid;padding-left:1ex">Note I
              use LISP all the time to get multicast over Wifi via <a
href="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-lisp-signal-free-multicast/"
                rel="noreferrer" target="_blank" moz-do-not-send="true">https://datatracker.ietf.org/<wbr>doc/draft-ietf-lisp-signal-<wbr>free-multicast/</a>.<br>
              <br>
              If anyone wants to try it, please send me a private note.<br>
              <span class="HOEnZb"><font color="#888888"><br>
                  Dino</font></span></blockquote>
            <div><br>
            </div>
            <div>Exactly. ANY unicast encap of multicast over wifi will
              gain from the wifi loss retransmission.</div>
            <div><br>
            </div>
            <div>Greg</div>
            <div> </div>
            <blockquote class="gmail_quote" style="margin:0 0 0
              .8ex;border-left:1px #ccc solid;padding-left:1ex">
              <div class="HOEnZb">
                <div class="h5">
                  &gt; On Nov 8, 2017, at 10:22 AM, Holland, Jake &lt;<a
                    href="mailto:jholland@akamai.com"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">jholland@akamai.com</a>&gt;
                  wrote:<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; Hi,<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; FLUTE and NORM are the reliable multicast
                  transports I’ve seen:<br>
                  &gt; <a href="https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6726"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">https://tools.ietf.org/html/<wbr>rfc6726</a><br>
                  &gt; <a href="https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5740"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">https://tools.ietf.org/html/<wbr>rfc5740</a><br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; AFAIK neither has wide usage, but there’s
                  implementations:<br>
                  &gt; <a href="http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.html"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.<wbr>html</a><br>
                  &gt; <a
                    href="https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/ncs/products/norm"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/<wbr>ncs/products/norm</a><br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; If I understand correctly, Cablelabs’s IP
                  Multicast ABR system uses a sort of bastardized
                  version of NORM with a path for out-of-band unicast
                  repair that doesn’t let receivers prevent the transmit
                  window from sliding forward, since the streaming video
                  use case can’t use the norm approach of letting
                  receivers slow down the transmit:<br>
                  &gt; <a
href="https://apps.cablelabs.com/specification/?category=VIDEO&amp;subcat=IP%20MULTICAST&amp;query=&amp;doctype=&amp;content=false&amp;archives=false"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">https://apps.cablelabs.com/<wbr>specification/?category=VIDEO&amp;<wbr>subcat=IP%20MULTICAST&amp;query=&amp;<wbr>doctype=&amp;content=false&amp;<wbr>archives=false</a><br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; There’s some more speculative ongoing work I know
                  of that might be relevant.<br>
                  &gt; <a
                    href="https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-01"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">https://tools.ietf.org/html/<wbr>draft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-<wbr>01</a><br>
                  &gt; <a
                    href="https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-scheme-01"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">https://tools.ietf.org/html/<wbr>draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-<wbr>scheme-01</a><br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; I think FLUTE or NORM implementations could be
                  made to work today for a non-time-critical download
                  service, if there were multicast connectivity.<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; I agree with Mikael that there’s more work to do
                  before ordinary implementations of open standards can
                  be used to operate a video service over multicast IP.
                  I do want to operate a multicast video service, but
                  not without FEC or some kind of repair.<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; I also agree that AMT can be a helpful way to get
                  multicast IP over wifi as unicast at layer 2 (though I
                  would rather see native multicast to the home and
                  either AMT relay or DMS (or both) at the wifi router,
                  instead of AMT relays in the ISP, because multicast
                  can help a lot on the access network for PON or CMTS,
                  though I do take the point that in some cases relay in
                  the ISP is more practical to deploy).<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; But I agree with Stig that it’s not very helpful
                  to make AMT reliable, as compared to making a
                  sufficiently reliable multicast transport protocol
                  that can work for streaming video.<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; -Jake<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; On 11/8/17, 7:53 AM, "Stig Venaas" &lt;<a
                    href="mailto:stig@venaas.com" moz-do-not-send="true">stig@venaas.com</a>&gt;
                  wrote:<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; Hi<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; I only meant that with AMT and Wi-Fi, the
                  experience should hopefully<br>
                  &gt; be equivalent to regular native multicast. I
                  agree you often need FEC<br>
                  &gt; to protect against loss, and also in some cases
                  some kind of<br>
                  &gt; retransmission or unicast assistance. Assuming
                  there is no loss in the<br>
                  &gt; core until an AMT relay is reached, then I
                  suppose an AMT specific<br>
                  &gt; solution could work, but I would like a generic
                  solution that can work<br>
                  &gt; for native multicast. I don't remember exactly
                  what was done for<br>
                  &gt; reliable multicast in the IETF now. Anyone
                  remember better than me? I<br>
                  &gt; remember proposals including how to do
                  retransmissions.<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; Stig<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 1:50 AM, Mikael
                  Abrahamsson &lt;<a href="mailto:swmike@swm.pp.se"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">swmike@swm.pp.se</a>&gt;
                  wrote:<br>
                  &gt;&gt; On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt;&gt; Hi<br>
                  &gt;&gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt;&gt; I don't think AMT needs to be more
                  reliable than regular multicast. If<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt; Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC
                  is an operational nightmare<br>
                  &gt;&gt; that never stops. You need to constantly
                  measure customer experience<br>
                  &gt;&gt; (preferrably in the STBs, all of this with
                  proprietary solutions afaik) or<br>
                  &gt;&gt; try to measure it in your network (using
                  expensive equipement).<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt; I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at
                  large scale.<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt;&gt; you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by
                  using AMT to the device, the<br>
                  &gt;&gt;&gt; packets will be unicast packets, so the
                  regular Wi-Fi handling of unicast<br>
                  &gt;&gt;&gt; packets (including retransmissions)
                  should be sufficient. Do you need<br>
                  &gt;&gt;&gt; additional retransmissions?<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt; Unicast will be far superior to multicast
                  over wifi, but it's probably still<br>
                  &gt;&gt; not enough to give a good enough customer
                  experience without FEC.<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt; FEC in this aspect means the application
                  deteriorates gracefully under<br>
                  &gt;&gt; packet loss, by smearing out infomation
                  across packets and degrading quality<br>
                  &gt;&gt; without for instance magenta squares gliding
                  along the screen until the next<br>
                  &gt;&gt; full screen update (that might be a second
                  into the future (or more)).<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt; This "FEC" can also be (as some have done),
                  by the devices receiving<br>
                  &gt;&gt; multicast packets and then requesting (via
                  unicast) from a server of some<br>
                  &gt;&gt; kind, to get the packets it lost. The few
                  solutions available when I was<br>
                  &gt;&gt; involved in this before, were all
                  proprietary. They were also used to speed<br>
                  &gt;&gt; up channel changes by providing full screen
                  update immediately, before same<br>
                  &gt;&gt; information came via the multicast stream.<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt; In packet networks, packets are lost. It's a
                  fact. They're designed to<br>
                  &gt;&gt; behave this way. From what I can see, there
                  are two ways to handle this.<br>
                  &gt;&gt; Either we come up with a standards based
                  retransmission mechanism for<br>
                  &gt;&gt; multicast streams that anyone can use, or we
                  punt the problem to the<br>
                  &gt;&gt; application layer, and let them figure it
                  out. We need to be perfectly clear<br>
                  &gt;&gt; to everybody what our choice is.<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt;<br>
                  &gt;&gt; --<br>
                  &gt;&gt; Mikael Abrahamsson    email: <a
                    href="mailto:swmike@swm.pp.se"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">swmike@swm.pp.se</a><br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; ______________________________<wbr>_________________<br>
                  &gt; MBONED mailing list<br>
                  &gt; <a href="mailto:MBONED@ietf.org"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">MBONED@ietf.org</a><br>
                  &gt; <a
                    href="https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">https://www.ietf.org/mailman/<wbr>listinfo/mboned</a><br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt;<br>
                  &gt; ______________________________<wbr>_________________<br>
                  &gt; MBONED mailing list<br>
                  &gt; <a href="mailto:MBONED@ietf.org"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">MBONED@ietf.org</a><br>
                  &gt; <a
                    href="https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">https://www.ietf.org/mailman/<wbr>listinfo/mboned</a><br>
                  <br>
                  ______________________________<wbr>_________________<br>
                  MBONED mailing list<br>
                  <a href="mailto:MBONED@ietf.org"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">MBONED@ietf.org</a><br>
                  <a href="https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned"
                    rel="noreferrer" target="_blank"
                    moz-do-not-send="true">https://www.ietf.org/mailman/<wbr>listinfo/mboned</a><br>
                </div>
              </div>
            </blockquote>
          </div>
          <br>
        </div>
      </div>
      <br>
      <fieldset class="mimeAttachmentHeader"></fieldset>
      <br>
      <pre wrap="">_______________________________________________
MBONED mailing list
<a class="moz-txt-link-abbreviated" href="mailto:MBONED@ietf.org">MBONED@ietf.org</a>
<a class="moz-txt-link-freetext" href="https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned">https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned</a>
</pre>
    </blockquote>
    <br>
  </body>
</html>

--------------19DA19A520D4904A5A97CFFE--


From nobody Wed Nov  8 13:07:27 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id AE90D126FB3 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 13:07:25 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.199
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.199 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id L68F93HagzCM for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 13:07:24 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id ECCFA1252BA for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 13:07:23 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id B159458C4B2; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 22:07:19 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 8FE5BB0D100; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 22:07:19 +0100 (CET)
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 22:07:19 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: "Holland, Jake" <jholland@akamai.com>
Cc: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171108210719.GA18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/-MfX1l0Dx7ZTAm1zaUtiIbjboUs>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 21:07:25 -0000

The CableLabs solution does not carry IP multicast across the home network.
It makes the home gateway an HTTP proxy where IP multicast + NORM is used
on the uplink to retrieve the content in a scalable fashion between content
server and gateways - via a fairly well controlled SP network only.
The amount of loss that NORM has to cope with should be very small, but of
course it needs to be 0 to support the use case, thats why you still need a
reliable transport protocol.

I was always hoping that there was still a chance to build
the transport solution for rate adaptive video on top of RTP because it
would create a lot less ABR problems like overhead and delay (talk about sports
and delay). I thought there are some solution architectures on the mobile side
that may use RTP, but not quite sure. I've helped build solutions that
do use rate adaptive RTP and i thought that worked very well (low latency et.al.).

For walled garden IPTV use cases, the cablelabs approach should be quite attractive 
you just need to eliminate all the cable specific pieces you don't need, which
shouldn't be difficult. You just won't get a good score on the soccer-goal-delay rankings. 

If we're talking federated or OTT video which is what AMT was looking to support,
then this cablelabs approach direction would rather be an alternative: Just put
an HTTP cache on your home-gateway  to enable local retransmissions from cache
on the gateway and rely on TCP (HTTP(s)) from gateway to client. No multicast
needed.

Cheers
    Toerless

On Wed, Nov 08, 2017 at 06:22:23PM +0000, Holland, Jake wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> FLUTE and NORM are the reliable multicast transports I???ve seen:
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6726
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5740
> 
> AFAIK neither has wide usage, but there???s implementations:
> http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.html
> https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/ncs/products/norm
> 
> If I understand correctly, Cablelabs???s IP Multicast ABR system uses a sort of bastardized version of NORM with a path for out-of-band unicast repair that doesn???t let receivers prevent the transmit window from sliding forward, since the streaming video use case can???t use the norm approach of letting receivers slow down the transmit:
> https://apps.cablelabs.com/specification/?category=VIDEO&subcat=IP%20MULTICAST&query=&doctype=&content=false&archives=false
> 
> There???s some more speculative ongoing work I know of that might be relevant.
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-01
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-scheme-01
> 
> I think FLUTE or NORM implementations could be made to work today for a non-time-critical download service, if there were multicast connectivity.
> 
> 
> I agree with Mikael that there???s more work to do before ordinary implementations of open standards can be used to operate a video service over multicast IP. I do want to operate a multicast video service, but not without FEC or some kind of repair.
> 
> I also agree that AMT can be a helpful way to get multicast IP over wifi as unicast at layer 2 (though I would rather see native multicast to the home and either AMT relay or DMS (or both) at the wifi router, instead of AMT relays in the ISP, because multicast can help a lot on the access network for PON or CMTS, though I do take the point that in some cases relay in the ISP is more practical to deploy).
> 
> But I agree with Stig that it???s not very helpful to make AMT reliable, as compared to making a sufficiently reliable multicast transport protocol that can work for streaming video.
> 
> -Jake
> 
> On 11/8/17, 7:53 AM, "Stig Venaas" <stig@venaas.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi
> 
> I only meant that with AMT and Wi-Fi, the experience should hopefully
> be equivalent to regular native multicast. I agree you often need FEC
> to protect against loss, and also in some cases some kind of
> retransmission or unicast assistance. Assuming there is no loss in the
> core until an AMT relay is reached, then I suppose an AMT specific
> solution could work, but I would like a generic solution that can work
> for native multicast. I don't remember exactly what was done for
> reliable multicast in the IETF now. Anyone remember better than me? I
> remember proposals including how to do retransmissions.
> 
> Stig
> 
> 
> On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 1:50 AM, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se> wrote:
> > On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:
> >
> >> Hi
> >>
> >> I don't think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular multicast. If
> >
> >
> > Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC is an operational nightmare
> > that never stops. You need to constantly measure customer experience
> > (preferrably in the STBs, all of this with proprietary solutions afaik) or
> > try to measure it in your network (using expensive equipement).
> >
> > I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at large scale.
> >
> >> you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by using AMT to the device, the
> >> packets will be unicast packets, so the regular Wi-Fi handling of unicast
> >> packets (including retransmissions) should be sufficient. Do you need
> >> additional retransmissions?
> >
> >
> > Unicast will be far superior to multicast over wifi, but it's probably still
> > not enough to give a good enough customer experience without FEC.
> >
> > FEC in this aspect means the application deteriorates gracefully under
> > packet loss, by smearing out infomation across packets and degrading quality
> > without for instance magenta squares gliding along the screen until the next
> > full screen update (that might be a second into the future (or more)).
> >
> > This "FEC" can also be (as some have done), by the devices receiving
> > multicast packets and then requesting (via unicast) from a server of some
> > kind, to get the packets it lost. The few solutions available when I was
> > involved in this before, were all proprietary. They were also used to speed
> > up channel changes by providing full screen update immediately, before same
> > information came via the multicast stream.
> >
> > In packet networks, packets are lost. It's a fact. They're designed to
> > behave this way. From what I can see, there are two ways to handle this.
> > Either we come up with a standards based retransmission mechanism for
> > multicast streams that anyone can use, or we punt the problem to the
> > application layer, and let them figure it out. We need to be perfectly clear
> > to everybody what our choice is.
> >
> >
> > --
> > Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
> 
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> MBONED mailing list
> MBONED@ietf.org
> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Wed Nov  8 14:00:15 2017
Return-Path: <jholland@akamai.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id B2A7712940E for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 14:00:13 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.001
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.001 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=akamai.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id c5005SKHEaUW for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 14:00:11 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mx0b-00190b01.pphosted.com (mx0b-00190b01.pphosted.com [IPv6:2620:100:9005:57f::1]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id A8F031275FD for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 14:00:11 -0800 (PST)
Received: from pps.filterd (m0122330.ppops.net [127.0.0.1]) by mx0b-00190b01.pphosted.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vA8LwsUG030397; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 22:00:03 GMT
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=akamai.com; h=from : to : cc : subject : date : message-id : references : in-reply-to : content-type : content-id : content-transfer-encoding : mime-version; s=jan2016.eng; bh=11lJ0pMhHsltcE9CndKYFNaS1wUdy88S696Qw7prcyM=; b=QpyeabBNrP5adrqzr6WRDNxEpN6QgEC/98zz+DhkpaNCddXx+MlnJCw5RiJ2Ht/+mutP codXG+lUdrRS5EE/0+4h9ysD6cEPPAazXJNm8kWkyWdDYtAw/F1RpdxRCgu+NR/efQau fjC0+DcHjbPOLmDCsrG/qwx6z5D273Ie8uH9avfIbdhAKlEB3qoF/2pkCASbOj1gyLdw KASJJhNnij1NDU2JP/82sjIjf7//N+kBZsidq7GEcygkaXr4AvDfpoO7LB/KjUxMY862 Sbim6iRzLMZt8kVPwAn5mPPZxyxzHe+PRzYB+wT3VCsYlL0cvL16iYqjZAyHsKyWE5D/ TQ== 
Received: from prod-mail-ppoint3 ([96.6.114.86]) by mx0b-00190b01.pphosted.com with ESMTP id 2e4a3801m4-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Wed, 08 Nov 2017 22:00:02 +0000
Received: from pps.filterd (prod-mail-ppoint3.akamai.com [127.0.0.1]) by prod-mail-ppoint3.akamai.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vA8LuWu4028459; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 17:00:02 -0500
Received: from email.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.31]) by prod-mail-ppoint3.akamai.com with ESMTP id 2e18vw19tj-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Wed, 08 Nov 2017 17:00:01 -0500
Received: from usma1ex-dag1mb6.msg.corp.akamai.com (172.27.123.65) by usma1ex-dag1mb2.msg.corp.akamai.com (172.27.123.102) with Microsoft SMTP Server (TLS) id 15.0.1263.5; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 17:00:00 -0500
Received: from usma1ex-dag1mb6.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.65]) by usma1ex-dag1mb6.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.65]) with mapi id 15.00.1263.000; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 17:00:00 -0500
From: "Holland, Jake" <jholland@akamai.com>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
CC: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
Thread-Index: AQHTKFDU/aqwdbbq5kmpwFCfY4/mJKMKPziAgACyAgCAAGTJgP//pBoAgAC0MoD//4ibgA==
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 22:00:00 +0000
Message-ID: <4F5EB40E-F928-4330-8446-198D38CFE337@akamai.com>
References: <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com> <20171108210719.GA18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
In-Reply-To: <20171108210719.GA18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
Accept-Language: en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
user-agent: Microsoft-MacOutlook/f.24.1.170721
x-ms-exchange-messagesentrepresentingtype: 1
x-ms-exchange-transport-fromentityheader: Hosted
x-originating-ip: [172.19.112.170]
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-ID: <A28659BB48DD124E8569E30745E72501@akamai.com>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-08_04:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 spamscore=0 suspectscore=0 malwarescore=0 phishscore=0 adultscore=0 bulkscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1707230000 definitions=main-1711080290
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-08_04:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 priorityscore=1501 malwarescore=0 suspectscore=0 phishscore=0 bulkscore=0 spamscore=0 clxscore=1011 lowpriorityscore=0 impostorscore=0 adultscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1707230000 definitions=main-1711080290
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/Mv24tvfAf_ojMJ2LAJfc3mPFrPs>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 22:00:14 -0000
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From nobody Wed Nov  8 14:27:03 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 35A3C126D46 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 14:27:01 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.199
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.199 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id BGQ3mEjkxqZB for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 14:26:57 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 93353129488 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 14:26:57 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 0E37158C592; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 23:26:53 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id E8D23B0D100; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 23:26:52 +0100 (CET)
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 23:26:52 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: "Holland, Jake" <jholland@akamai.com>
Cc: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171108222652.GB18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com> <20171108210719.GA18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <4F5EB40E-F928-4330-8446-198D38CFE337@akamai.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <4F5EB40E-F928-4330-8446-198D38CFE337@akamai.com>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/TCMBt0uRWXpNVDXuzTPPkhWvMqM>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 22:27:01 -0000

On Wed, Nov 08, 2017 at 10:00:00PM +0000, Holland, Jake wrote:
> +1 on hoping for RTP. And maybe we should cc payload.
> 
> I still don???t know enough about RTP or video coding to be certain I???m making sense, but from what I understand, the adaptive RTP solutions today have sender back off under congestion? It seems to me that would need to change for multicast.

No, you do not slow down the sender.

RTP schemes are just like ABR schemes, eg: multiple bitrates availalable,
receiver "joins" to the bitrate(s) it can receive without congestion.

Key difference to ABR schemes is that you can docode after usually
every packet you receive as opposed to ABR where you can decode only after
the whole block is received (2 secs or longer usually). And with RTP
you can much easier work in content aware redundancy schemes. E.g.: in ABR
you need 100% reliability and therefore use retransmission like NORM/FLUTE
to get all pakets in a block. In RTP you can decide frame-by-frame
whether a loss of data from that frame results in a visual degradation
that demands retransmisssion or whethre you'd rather not retransmit but
for example interpolate it. And the encoding of different frames can be
done to support such more flexible & dynamic quality vs. delay vs.
burstyness/retransmission choices.

> I think the Scalable Video Coding that???s part of VP9 (and optional in h.264) is a really promising approach for doing ABR with multicast RTP. In theory, if it were supported and the sender were sending the right way, in response to congestion indications like loss or CE markings, the client could leave (S,G)s corresponding to higher-resolution enhancement layers and still keep the lower-resolution video layers at a bandwidth level that works well for his path. If you got it to work well, maybe the purple squares or video skips could be at more like the frequency of the player buffering you???d get in unicast, and mostly only happening when network conditions change.

No idea if VP9 is introducing something new or if this is all just what
we had in MPEG SVC for a decade. I'd hope that they simply copied the
best options and made the IPR free. I'd be surprised though if they had
specific support for some of the low-latency variable loss support details
that commercial MPEG solutions have built.

> As I understand it, that???s not possible today, but if I???m reading the latest diffs correctly, support for the concept has been added to the vp9 payload draft, so it might become possible if somebody takes up the work?
> https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-payload-vp9-04#section-4.5
> 
> I???m not sure about the reliability, because it seems like you???d still get those purple squares on lost packets, but you could at least reduce the incidence of lost packets due to congestion, and maybe that would make it possible for a little bit of FEC to keep up under any reasonably stable network. But I imagine that improving the reliability will be another project of its own, and there???s a bad tradeoff with the delay. But maybe it???s possible to get reliability with less delay than reliable unicast segmented video has to pay.

In general you have frames that are used as references by other frames and
those that are not. Loss in the latter ones can to a good extend be
compensated for by interpolation between the next and prior frame if
you allow for a few frames playout delay and have enogh CPU to do
motion interpolation. Reference frames on the other hand should more
likely be protected by enough FEC so they almosst never have loss. Else
you need low-latency retransmissions like from a nearby cache on the
gateway (assuming last-hop loss on wifi).

> This is precisely what I mean by ???there???s work to do before normal implementations of open standards can do this???. To me it looks probably achievable but not imminent.

Cheers
    Toerless

> -Jake
> 
> On 11/8/17, 1:07 PM, "Toerless Eckert" <tte@cs.fau.de> wrote:
> 
> The CableLabs solution does not carry IP multicast across the home network.
> It makes the home gateway an HTTP proxy where IP multicast + NORM is used
> on the uplink to retrieve the content in a scalable fashion between content
> server and gateways - via a fairly well controlled SP network only.
> The amount of loss that NORM has to cope with should be very small, but of
> course it needs to be 0 to support the use case, thats why you still need a
> reliable transport protocol.
> 
> I was always hoping that there was still a chance to build
> the transport solution for rate adaptive video on top of RTP because it
> would create a lot less ABR problems like overhead and delay (talk about sports
> and delay). I thought there are some solution architectures on the mobile side
> that may use RTP, but not quite sure. I've helped build solutions that
> do use rate adaptive RTP and i thought that worked very well (low latency et.al.).
> 
> For walled garden IPTV use cases, the cablelabs approach should be quite attractive 
> you just need to eliminate all the cable specific pieces you don't need, which
> shouldn't be difficult. You just won't get a good score on the soccer-goal-delay rankings. 
> 
> If we're talking federated or OTT video which is what AMT was looking to support,
> then this cablelabs approach direction would rather be an alternative: Just put
> an HTTP cache on your home-gateway  to enable local retransmissions from cache
> on the gateway and rely on TCP (HTTP(s)) from gateway to client. No multicast
> needed.
> 
> Cheers
>     Toerless
> 
> On Wed, Nov 08, 2017 at 06:22:23PM +0000, Holland, Jake wrote:
> > Hi,
> > 
> > FLUTE and NORM are the reliable multicast transports I???ve seen:
> > https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6726
> > https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5740
> > 
> > AFAIK neither has wide usage, but there???s implementations:
> > http://mad.cs.tut.fi/download.html
> > https://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/ncs/products/norm
> > 
> > If I understand correctly, Cablelabs???s IP Multicast ABR system uses a sort of bastardized version of NORM with a path for out-of-band unicast repair that doesn???t let receivers prevent the transmit window from sliding forward, since the streaming video use case can???t use the norm approach of letting receivers slow down the transmit:
> > https://apps.cablelabs.com/specification/?category=VIDEO&subcat=IP%20MULTICAST&query=&doctype=&content=false&archives=false
> > 
> > There???s some more speculative ongoing work I know of that might be relevant.
> > https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-pardue-quic-http-mcast-01
> > https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rlc-fec-scheme-01
> > 
> > I think FLUTE or NORM implementations could be made to work today for a non-time-critical download service, if there were multicast connectivity.
> > 
> > 
> > I agree with Mikael that there???s more work to do before ordinary implementations of open standards can be used to operate a video service over multicast IP. I do want to operate a multicast video service, but not without FEC or some kind of repair.
> > 
> > I also agree that AMT can be a helpful way to get multicast IP over wifi as unicast at layer 2 (though I would rather see native multicast to the home and either AMT relay or DMS (or both) at the wifi router, instead of AMT relays in the ISP, because multicast can help a lot on the access network for PON or CMTS, though I do take the point that in some cases relay in the ISP is more practical to deploy).
> > 
> > But I agree with Stig that it???s not very helpful to make AMT reliable, as compared to making a sufficiently reliable multicast transport protocol that can work for streaming video.
> > 
> > -Jake
> > 
> > On 11/8/17, 7:53 AM, "Stig Venaas" <stig@venaas.com> wrote:
> > 
> > Hi
> > 
> > I only meant that with AMT and Wi-Fi, the experience should hopefully
> > be equivalent to regular native multicast. I agree you often need FEC
> > to protect against loss, and also in some cases some kind of
> > retransmission or unicast assistance. Assuming there is no loss in the
> > core until an AMT relay is reached, then I suppose an AMT specific
> > solution could work, but I would like a generic solution that can work
> > for native multicast. I don't remember exactly what was done for
> > reliable multicast in the IETF now. Anyone remember better than me? I
> > remember proposals including how to do retransmissions.
> > 
> > Stig
> > 
> > 
> > On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 1:50 AM, Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se> wrote:
> > > On Tue, 7 Nov 2017, Stig Venaas wrote:
> > >
> > >> Hi
> > >>
> > >> I don't think AMT needs to be more reliable than regular multicast. If
> > >
> > >
> > > Deploying multicast for linear TV without FEC is an operational nightmare
> > > that never stops. You need to constantly measure customer experience
> > > (preferrably in the STBs, all of this with proprietary solutions afaik) or
> > > try to measure it in your network (using expensive equipement).
> > >
> > > I recommend all my enemies to deploy this at large scale.
> > >
> > >> you are concerned about Wi-Fi, then by using AMT to the device, the
> > >> packets will be unicast packets, so the regular Wi-Fi handling of unicast
> > >> packets (including retransmissions) should be sufficient. Do you need
> > >> additional retransmissions?
> > >
> > >
> > > Unicast will be far superior to multicast over wifi, but it's probably still
> > > not enough to give a good enough customer experience without FEC.
> > >
> > > FEC in this aspect means the application deteriorates gracefully under
> > > packet loss, by smearing out infomation across packets and degrading quality
> > > without for instance magenta squares gliding along the screen until the next
> > > full screen update (that might be a second into the future (or more)).
> > >
> > > This "FEC" can also be (as some have done), by the devices receiving
> > > multicast packets and then requesting (via unicast) from a server of some
> > > kind, to get the packets it lost. The few solutions available when I was
> > > involved in this before, were all proprietary. They were also used to speed
> > > up channel changes by providing full screen update immediately, before same
> > > information came via the multicast stream.
> > >
> > > In packet networks, packets are lost. It's a fact. They're designed to
> > > behave this way. From what I can see, there are two ways to handle this.
> > > Either we come up with a standards based retransmission mechanism for
> > > multicast streams that anyone can use, or we punt the problem to the
> > > application layer, and let them figure it out. We need to be perfectly clear
> > > to everybody what our choice is.
> > >
> > >
> > > --
> > > Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se
> > 
> > _______________________________________________
> > MBONED mailing list
> > MBONED@ietf.org
> > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
> > 
> > 
> > _______________________________________________
> > MBONED mailing list
> > MBONED@ietf.org
> > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned
> 
> -- 
> ---
> tte@cs.fau.de
> 
> 

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Wed Nov  8 15:13:43 2017
Return-Path: <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 195A6126C22 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 15:13:42 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.221
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.221 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H3=-0.01, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=-0.01, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id kaaDsON7g5fh for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 15:13:40 -0800 (PST)
Received: from phx-mbsout-01.mbs.boeing.net (phx-mbsout-01.mbs.boeing.net [130.76.184.178]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 84ED7124B0A for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 15:13:40 -0800 (PST)
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by phx-mbsout-01.mbs.boeing.net (8.14.4/8.14.4/DOWNSTREAM_MBSOUT) with SMTP id vA8NDdG2046549; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 16:13:39 -0700
Received: from XCH15-06-07.nw.nos.boeing.com (xch15-06-07.nw.nos.boeing.com [137.136.238.213]) by phx-mbsout-01.mbs.boeing.net (8.14.4/8.14.4/UPSTREAM_MBSOUT) with ESMTP id vA8NDVkE046151 (version=TLSv1/SSLv3 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=OK); Wed, 8 Nov 2017 16:13:31 -0700
Received: from XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com (2002:8988:efdc::8988:efdc) by XCH15-06-07.nw.nos.boeing.com (2002:8988:eed5::8988:eed5) with Microsoft SMTP Server (TLS) id 15.0.1320.4; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 15:13:30 -0800
Received: from XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com ([137.136.239.220]) by XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com ([137.136.239.220]) with mapi id 15.00.1320.000; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 15:13:30 -0800
From: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
CC: "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
Thread-Index: AQHTWHcO41vkPGB680CTHTDgUaPOWKMLKAGAgAAqOICAAC4VgIAADrgAgAAHgQD//340gA==
Date: Wed, 8 Nov 2017 23:13:30 +0000
Message-ID: <38ca0bcaf6ef463da8b79c95554045bd@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
References: <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com> <20171108210719.GA18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <4F5EB40E-F928-4330-8446-198D38CFE337@akamai.com> <20171108222652.GB18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
In-Reply-To: <20171108222652.GB18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
Accept-Language: en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
x-ms-exchange-transport-fromentityheader: Hosted
x-originating-ip: [137.136.248.6]
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-TM-AS-MML: disable
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/GriF-Fz2hoIhPg2mBjGwNL7lz30>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 08 Nov 2017 23:13:42 -0000

-----Original Message-----
From: MBONED [mailto:mboned-bounces@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Toerless Eckert

> No, you do not slow down the sender.
>
> RTP schemes are just like ABR schemes, eg: multiple bitrates availalable,
> receiver "joins" to the bitrate(s) it can receive without congestion.

This might be splitting hairs, but in effect, with RTP, you can be slowing =
down or speeding up the sender. Even if the sender, or intermediate mixer, =
is no more advanced than just making various streams available for a given =
content, depending on the feedback from RTCP, the sender will be sending a =
more or a less compressed stream, to that unicast destination. Which is an =
adjustment of the sender's bits/sec, nicht war?

(The effect can be striking, if you have a slow interface like ADSL. I've s=
een it start at poor quality, then ramp up in a few seconds, in very obviou=
s increments, and very consistently.)

RTP multicast can't be this responsive to individual destinations, however =
RTCP feedback is usable there too.

But mostly, I don't think RTP cares exactly how one uses the RTCP feedback.=
 If you want to send the feedback as a control to the MPEG encoder, for the=
 encoder to decide how much to compress the signal in real time, RTP wouldn=
't even know. That's entirely up to the implementation, I would think.

Here's from RFC 3550:

2.4 Layered Encodings

   Multimedia applications should be able to adjust the transmission
   rate to match the capacity of the receiver or to adapt to network
   congestion.  Many implementations place the responsibility of rate-
   adaptivity at the source.  This does not work well with multicast
   transmission because of the conflicting bandwidth requirements of
   heterogeneous receivers.  The result is often a least-common
   denominator scenario, where the smallest pipe in the network mesh
   dictates the quality and fidelity of the overall live multimedia
   "broadcast".

   Instead, responsibility for rate-adaptation can be placed at the
   receivers by combining a layered encoding with a layered transmission
   system.  In the context of RTP over IP multicast, the source can
   stripe the progressive layers of a hierarchically represented signal
   across multiple RTP sessions each carried on its own multicast group.
   Receivers can then adapt to network heterogeneity and control their
   reception bandwidth by joining only the appropriate subset of the
   multicast groups.

6. RTP Control Protocol -- RTCP

   The RTP control protocol (RTCP) is based on the periodic transmission
   of control packets to all participants in the session, using the same
   distribution mechanism as the data packets.  The underlying protocol
   MUST provide multiplexing of the data and control packets, for
   example using separate port numbers with UDP.  RTCP performs four
   functions:

   1. The primary function is to provide feedback on the quality of the
      data distribution.  This is an integral part of the RTP's role as
      a transport protocol and is related to the flow and congestion
      control functions of other transport protocols (see Section 10 on
      the requirement for congestion control).  The feedback may be
      directly useful for control of adaptive encodings [18,19], but
      experiments with IP multicasting have shown that it is also
      critical to get feedback from the receivers to diagnose faults in
      the distribution.  Sending reception feedback reports to all
      participants allows one who is observing problems to evaluate
      whether those problems are local or global.  With a distribution
      mechanism like IP multicast, it is also possible for an entity
      such as a network service provider who is not otherwise involved
      in the session to receive the feedback information and act as a
      third-party monitor to diagnose network problems.  This feedback
      function is performed by the RTCP sender and receiver reports,
      described below in Section 6.4.

Bert



From nobody Wed Nov  8 18:03:18 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 6B8E5126FB3 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 18:03:16 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.198
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.198 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 6Hm65Xbn1ZcY for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 18:03:14 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 0971C124B18 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 18:03:13 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 2D4EB58C592; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 03:03:10 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 14AD5B0D102; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 03:03:09 +0100 (CET)
Date: Thu, 9 Nov 2017 03:03:09 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
Cc: "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171109020309.GC18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com> <20171108210719.GA18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <4F5EB40E-F928-4330-8446-198D38CFE337@akamai.com> <20171108222652.GB18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <38ca0bcaf6ef463da8b79c95554045bd@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <38ca0bcaf6ef463da8b79c95554045bd@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/h9l-wL3eUFLC5c9HYjp1pOno52g>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 09 Nov 2017 02:03:16 -0000

Bert,

Not sure i recognize the hair you're trying to split.
Is this about me using the word "sender" when it should have been "codec/encoder" ?

Aka: As soon as you want to distribute content to large set of receivers reachable via
different speeds, you will figure out a sete of streams of diffeernt bitrates layered
or not and the encoding parameters of these streams will not depend on near term
dynamic changes of the set of receivers or their receive bandwidth. Instead only
those reeivers will perform rate adaptation by receiving a subset of streams. Thats
what i called "no you do not slow down the sender".

Of course, if your overall set of receivers starts to expose an overall shift in 
required bitrates, like when everybody wants to watch movies on wrist watches or
everybody gets FTTH, then you will readjust the bitrates of your streams and/or their
number or dependency composition. 

Did i find the hair ?

Cheers
    Toerless

On Wed, Nov 08, 2017 at 11:13:30PM +0000, Manfredi, Albert E wrote:
> -----Original Message-----
> From: MBONED [mailto:mboned-bounces@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Toerless Eckert
> 
> > No, you do not slow down the sender.
> >
> > RTP schemes are just like ABR schemes, eg: multiple bitrates availalable,
> > receiver "joins" to the bitrate(s) it can receive without congestion.
> 
> This might be splitting hairs, but in effect, with RTP, you can be slowing down or speeding up the sender. Even if the sender, or intermediate mixer, is no more advanced than just making various streams available for a given content, depending on the feedback from RTCP, the sender will be sending a more or a less compressed stream, to that unicast destination. Which is an adjustment of the sender's bits/sec, nicht war?
> 
> (The effect can be striking, if you have a slow interface like ADSL. I've seen it start at poor quality, then ramp up in a few seconds, in very obvious increments, and very consistently.)
> 
> RTP multicast can't be this responsive to individual destinations, however RTCP feedback is usable there too.
> 
> But mostly, I don't think RTP cares exactly how one uses the RTCP feedback. If you want to send the feedback as a control to the MPEG encoder, for the encoder to decide how much to compress the signal in real time, RTP wouldn't even know. That's entirely up to the implementation, I would think.
> 
> Here's from RFC 3550:
> 
> 2.4 Layered Encodings
> 
>    Multimedia applications should be able to adjust the transmission
>    rate to match the capacity of the receiver or to adapt to network
>    congestion.  Many implementations place the responsibility of rate-
>    adaptivity at the source.  This does not work well with multicast
>    transmission because of the conflicting bandwidth requirements of
>    heterogeneous receivers.  The result is often a least-common
>    denominator scenario, where the smallest pipe in the network mesh
>    dictates the quality and fidelity of the overall live multimedia
>    "broadcast".
> 
>    Instead, responsibility for rate-adaptation can be placed at the
>    receivers by combining a layered encoding with a layered transmission
>    system.  In the context of RTP over IP multicast, the source can
>    stripe the progressive layers of a hierarchically represented signal
>    across multiple RTP sessions each carried on its own multicast group.
>    Receivers can then adapt to network heterogeneity and control their
>    reception bandwidth by joining only the appropriate subset of the
>    multicast groups.
> 
> 6. RTP Control Protocol -- RTCP
> 
>    The RTP control protocol (RTCP) is based on the periodic transmission
>    of control packets to all participants in the session, using the same
>    distribution mechanism as the data packets.  The underlying protocol
>    MUST provide multiplexing of the data and control packets, for
>    example using separate port numbers with UDP.  RTCP performs four
>    functions:
> 
>    1. The primary function is to provide feedback on the quality of the
>       data distribution.  This is an integral part of the RTP's role as
>       a transport protocol and is related to the flow and congestion
>       control functions of other transport protocols (see Section 10 on
>       the requirement for congestion control).  The feedback may be
>       directly useful for control of adaptive encodings [18,19], but
>       experiments with IP multicasting have shown that it is also
>       critical to get feedback from the receivers to diagnose faults in
>       the distribution.  Sending reception feedback reports to all
>       participants allows one who is observing problems to evaluate
>       whether those problems are local or global.  With a distribution
>       mechanism like IP multicast, it is also possible for an entity
>       such as a network service provider who is not otherwise involved
>       in the session to receive the feedback information and act as a
>       third-party monitor to diagnose network problems.  This feedback
>       function is performed by the RTCP sender and receiver reports,
>       described below in Section 6.4.
> 
> Bert
> 

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Wed Nov  8 19:22:44 2017
Return-Path: <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 88174129AD4 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 19:22:42 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.221
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.221 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H3=-0.01, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=-0.01, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id PqfubKizBz19 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 19:22:41 -0800 (PST)
Received: from phx-mbsout-01.mbs.boeing.net (phx-mbsout-01.mbs.boeing.net [130.76.184.178]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 24921129467 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 19:22:40 -0800 (PST)
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by phx-mbsout-01.mbs.boeing.net (8.14.4/8.14.4/DOWNSTREAM_MBSOUT) with SMTP id vA93Me6F024068; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 20:22:40 -0700
Received: from XCH15-06-07.nw.nos.boeing.com (xch15-06-07.nw.nos.boeing.com [137.136.238.213]) by phx-mbsout-01.mbs.boeing.net (8.14.4/8.14.4/UPSTREAM_MBSOUT) with ESMTP id vA93Mbm5024051 (version=TLSv1/SSLv3 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=OK); Wed, 8 Nov 2017 20:22:37 -0700
Received: from XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com (2002:8988:efdc::8988:efdc) by XCH15-06-07.nw.nos.boeing.com (2002:8988:eed5::8988:eed5) with Microsoft SMTP Server (TLS) id 15.0.1320.4; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 19:22:36 -0800
Received: from XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com ([137.136.239.220]) by XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com ([137.136.239.220]) with mapi id 15.00.1320.000; Wed, 8 Nov 2017 19:22:36 -0800
From: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
CC: "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
Thread-Index: AQHTWHcO41vkPGB680CTHTDgUaPOWKMLKAGAgAAqOICAAC4VgIAADrgAgAAHgQD//340gIAAvjqA//97EuA=
Date: Thu, 9 Nov 2017 03:22:36 +0000
Message-ID: <b8e6f044807f4deeba8f5fc08b13b6fa@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
References: <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com> <20171108210719.GA18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <4F5EB40E-F928-4330-8446-198D38CFE337@akamai.com> <20171108222652.GB18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <38ca0bcaf6ef463da8b79c95554045bd@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <20171109020309.GC18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
In-Reply-To: <20171109020309.GC18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
Accept-Language: en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
x-ms-exchange-transport-fromentityheader: Hosted
x-originating-ip: [137.136.248.6]
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-TM-AS-MML: disable
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/r1-sem6P39GA3R56CAJ-RuukQFI>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 09 Nov 2017 03:22:42 -0000

-----Original Message-----
From: Toerless Eckert [mailto:tte@cs.fau.de]=20

> Not sure i recognize the hair you're trying to split.
> Is this about me using the word "sender" when it should have been "codec/=
encoder" ?

It's when you said:

> No, you do not slow down the sender.
>
> RTP schemes are just like ABR schemes, eg: multiple bitrates availalable,
> receiver "joins" to the bitrate(s) it can receive without congestion.

I'm saying, depending how this is done, in principle you can be slowing dow=
n or speeding up the stream dynamically, to each device, when unicast.

> Aka: As soon as you want to distribute content to large set of receivers
> reachable via different speeds, you will figure out a sete of streams of
> diffeernt bitrates layered or not and the encoding parameters of these
> streams will not depend on near term dynamic changes of the set of receiv=
ers
> or their receive bandwidth.

Okay. But RTP/RTCP doesn't restrict you to just using that layered approach=
, or having the destination device do the hard work. It looks like, at leas=
t in the US, that the large majority of media streams are from distributed =
servers to individual user devices, in *unicast* sessions. Multiple thousan=
ds of streams, from each server, obviously more thousands when in SD qualit=
y than HD. Furthermore, that vast majority are also "on demand" as opposed =
to "live." Most people are not watching IP streams by appointment, let's sa=
y. In any event, live or not, most of these streams are unicast, at least i=
n the US.

In these unicast cases, it's also possible to use this method, explained in=
 RFC 3550, Sections 6 and 10:

   [RTCP feedback] is an integral part of the RTP's role as
   a transport protocol and is related to the flow and congestion
   control functions of other transport protocols (see Section 10 on
   the requirement for congestion control).  The feedback may be
   directly useful for control of adaptive encodings [18,19], ...

That last sentence above, before the RFC begins talking about multicast. Th=
en more detail in Section 10. After stating that RTP is often inelastic, it=
 does say the following:

   Therefore, congestion control SHOULD be
   defined in each RTP profile as appropriate.  For some profiles, it
   may be sufficient to include an applicability statement restricting
   the use of that profile to environments where congestion is avoided
   by engineering.  For other profiles, specific methods such as data
   rate adaptation based on RTCP feedback may be required.

Again, the last sentence in the quote. The encoder can be quite advanced, a=
nd RTP will support it.

> Did i find the hair ?

Fast (Deutsch fast).

Bert



From nobody Wed Nov  8 21:44:49 2017
Return-Path: <swmike@swm.pp.se>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 2F02C12EB5A for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 21:44:47 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.3
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.3 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, SPF_PASS=-0.001, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=swm.pp.se
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id z7ULfNtzHxay for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 21:44:44 -0800 (PST)
Received: from uplift.swm.pp.se (swm.pp.se [212.247.200.143]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 0C7D512EB59 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed,  8 Nov 2017 21:44:43 -0800 (PST)
Received: by uplift.swm.pp.se (Postfix, from userid 501) id 6BB03B5; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 06:44:40 +0100 (CET)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/simple; d=swm.pp.se; s=mail; t=1510206280; bh=WrMJtkWTc97UmdLvEVazDOC7soF9IEr3VGs6AGGEJPk=; h=Date:From:To:cc:Subject:In-Reply-To:References:From; b=CiTH1/hqVZE6pINdIZ2t0kUMdg3VhonfpOwPEH3pa2tO62edkBWXTsxl3Vm2L4ODh Ze/L0tyQLGSpMFojeJQhofImZV5uAK1hVK2KmSP/20WAX1JZ5Jt0itEoshpC/5V/fG mCEhXV3bJ1s0+sbWk5u0Qc/zghrfm+ZQC351hQjc=
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by uplift.swm.pp.se (Postfix) with ESMTP id 524E6B4; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 06:44:40 +0100 (CET)
Date: Thu, 9 Nov 2017 06:44:40 +0100 (CET)
From: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
cc: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
In-Reply-To: <20171108203432.GA11560@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
Message-ID: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711090640020.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se>
References: <f911d57bf77245b8b074d3c557ab28f2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709060825330.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20171108203432.GA11560@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
User-Agent: Alpine 2.20 (DEB 67 2015-01-07)
Organization: People's Front Against WWW
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII; format=flowed
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/FHUJQleAo-Jm5Kw3fCituPI0NuY>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 09 Nov 2017 05:44:47 -0000

On Wed, 8 Nov 2017, Toerless Eckert wrote:

> I'd limit this to "over non-sp-controlled networks" (e.g.: home). It 
> works fine since a decade in e.g.: cable networks from headend to 
> fiber/coax edge for example.

"works fine" is interesting choice of words.

My main point is that with Internet access, your customers won't really 
notice if you're dropping 1/1000 to 1/10000 packets. TCP starts to behave 
noticably much worse for normal consumers somewhere around 0.1-0.5% packet 
loss in my experience. With multicast TV without any "trickery" (just put 
those DVB cells into packets and feed them into the STB) you need more 
along the line of 1/million packet loss (one MPEG artifact per 2 hours or 
so) for customers to not get upset.

This is several orders of magnitude more sensitive compared to any other 
application your residential access network will have to work with, it's 
also probably two orders of magnitude more demanding regarding packet loss 
compared to most business SLAs as well.

-- 
Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se


From nobody Thu Nov  9 01:24:42 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 9264A12ECCB for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 01:24:40 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.198
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.198 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id SxGd-OdObSkI for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 01:24:38 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 33BD212ECC9 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 01:24:37 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 3E7AF58C592; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 10:24:34 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 25477B0D10C; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 10:24:34 +0100 (CET)
Date: Thu, 9 Nov 2017 10:24:34 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
Cc: "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171109092433.GD18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBtL8q16ZBLL6dgkirVg4GwXW7v40G26Q5DYdNnBO_XW22Q@mail.gmail.com> <ECC976E8-2633-45C1-A46C-F706DADD184F@akamai.com> <20171108210719.GA18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <4F5EB40E-F928-4330-8446-198D38CFE337@akamai.com> <20171108222652.GB18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <38ca0bcaf6ef463da8b79c95554045bd@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <20171109020309.GC18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <b8e6f044807f4deeba8f5fc08b13b6fa@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <b8e6f044807f4deeba8f5fc08b13b6fa@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/UExvTkEqGqNzK3RYdHtSYWd1hmo>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 09 Nov 2017 09:24:40 -0000

Albert,

ABR does not rely on RTP. There is no per-stream re-encoding of video
done in unicast streaming.

You could implement RTP unicast streaming from the same multi-bitrate content
source used by ABR by using the RTCP feedback from the receiver, determining a
good bitrate from that and then selecting the best available bitrate
stream and RTP packetizing it. And with RTP you wouldn't get the same
playout delay as with ABR. On the other hand, upspeeding is easier with
the ABR scheme: Because you burst every segment, you can easier measure
the actual available bitrate with every segment. If you stream real-time
with RTP its very hard to to measure how much more available bitrate you have.
If you do not have ECN, the only way is to get loss and then rely on FEC
or retransmissions. But of course as soon as you accept retransmissions,
you are in territory where TCP may have been the easier choice. 

Cheers
    Toerless

On Thu, Nov 09, 2017 at 03:22:36AM +0000, Manfredi, Albert E wrote:
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Toerless Eckert [mailto:tte@cs.fau.de] 
> 
> > Not sure i recognize the hair you're trying to split.
> > Is this about me using the word "sender" when it should have been "codec/encoder" ?
> 
> It's when you said:
> 
> > No, you do not slow down the sender.
> >
> > RTP schemes are just like ABR schemes, eg: multiple bitrates availalable,
> > receiver "joins" to the bitrate(s) it can receive without congestion.
> 
> I'm saying, depending how this is done, in principle you can be slowing down or speeding up the stream dynamically, to each device, when unicast.
> 
> > Aka: As soon as you want to distribute content to large set of receivers
> > reachable via different speeds, you will figure out a sete of streams of
> > diffeernt bitrates layered or not and the encoding parameters of these
> > streams will not depend on near term dynamic changes of the set of receivers
> > or their receive bandwidth.
> 
> Okay. But RTP/RTCP doesn't restrict you to just using that layered approach, or having the destination device do the hard work. It looks like, at least in the US, that the large majority of media streams are from distributed servers to individual user devices, in *unicast* sessions. Multiple thousands of streams, from each server, obviously more thousands when in SD quality than HD. Furthermore, that vast majority are also "on demand" as opposed to "live." Most people are not watching IP streams by appointment, let's say. In any event, live or not, most of these streams are unicast, at least in the US.
> 
> In these unicast cases, it's also possible to use this method, explained in RFC 3550, Sections 6 and 10:
> 
>    [RTCP feedback] is an integral part of the RTP's role as
>    a transport protocol and is related to the flow and congestion
>    control functions of other transport protocols (see Section 10 on
>    the requirement for congestion control).  The feedback may be
>    directly useful for control of adaptive encodings [18,19], ...
> 
> That last sentence above, before the RFC begins talking about multicast. Then more detail in Section 10. After stating that RTP is often inelastic, it does say the following:
> 
>    Therefore, congestion control SHOULD be
>    defined in each RTP profile as appropriate.  For some profiles, it
>    may be sufficient to include an applicability statement restricting
>    the use of that profile to environments where congestion is avoided
>    by engineering.  For other profiles, specific methods such as data
>    rate adaptation based on RTCP feedback may be required.
> 
> Again, the last sentence in the quote. The encoder can be quite advanced, and RTP will support it.
> 
> > Did i find the hair ?
> 
> Fast (Deutsch fast).
> 
> Bert
> 

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Thu Nov  9 08:49:21 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id D492B124C27 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 08:49:19 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.198
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.198 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id vxRUP58uUIxd for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 08:49:17 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 7B7A012025C for <mboned@ietf.org>; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 08:49:17 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 5F7FF58C4AF; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 17:49:13 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 40022B0D10F; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 17:49:13 +0100 (CET)
Date: Thu, 9 Nov 2017 17:49:13 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
Cc: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171109164913.GE18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20171108203432.GA11560@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711090640020.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711090640020.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/RE4-PcHN2a0iwRSaNeYKXwcm2zU>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 09 Nov 2017 16:49:20 -0000

Thanks, Mikael

+1 on all your statements, but just because a requirement (zero loss for
IPTV) is uncommon does not mean its difficult or novel.

"works fine" was about lossless IP multicast in networks (up to controllable
subscriber edge).  That was in production in early 2000 for financials,
military and big distributed app, so it was never one of IP multicasts problem
after 2008 with IPTV/linear-tv. And now detnet wants to take these services
in SP networks out of those niche markets into mainstream.

But lets set that discus aside, because i did not mean to derail from
your main point, which is the loss @home/WiFi that SPs can not manage at
network layer:

For any SP who wants to have existing IP multicast realtime walled garden
linear TV reliable across a home/wifi, we can easily add AMT over TCP as a
simple RFC. Mandate AMT/TCP relay on home gateway, mandate sock buffers
good enough for 5 seconds of playout, and be done with 98% of your wifi 
problems IMHO (one outage every 4 hours ? ;-). Thats easy enough written
up so that it wouldn't matter if we only get adoption by the selct few
"non-ABR crowd".

The main detail enhancement we need to include IMHO is that AMT
(S,G) joins should be allowed to carry the "real relay"
address, so that the home-GW can either join native walled-garden IPTV
multicast directly or become gateway for another AMT tunnel to the
over-the-top-content.

If anybody thinks he could work on getting this implemented in home
gateway and client-app, i would be happy to help writing this up as a draft. 

Cheers
    Toerless

On Thu, Nov 09, 2017 at 06:44:40AM +0100, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
> On Wed, 8 Nov 2017, Toerless Eckert wrote:
> 
> >I'd limit this to "over non-sp-controlled networks" (e.g.: home).
> >It works fine since a decade in e.g.: cable networks from headend
> >to fiber/coax edge for example.
> 
> "works fine" is interesting choice of words.
> 
> My main point is that with Internet access, your customers won't
> really notice if you're dropping 1/1000 to 1/10000 packets. TCP
> starts to behave noticably much worse for normal consumers somewhere
> around 0.1-0.5% packet loss in my experience. With multicast TV
> without any "trickery" (just put those DVB cells into packets and
> feed them into the STB) you need more along the line of 1/million
> packet loss (one MPEG artifact per 2 hours or so) for customers to
> not get upset.
> 
> This is several orders of magnitude more sensitive compared to any
> other application your residential access network will have to work
> with, it's also probably two orders of magnitude more demanding
> regarding packet loss compared to most business SLAs as well.
> 
> -- 
> Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Thu Nov  9 09:43:26 2017
Return-Path: <swmike@swm.pp.se>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id BA86C128768 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 09:43:24 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.3
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.3 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, SPF_PASS=-0.001, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=swm.pp.se
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 7hOap8prduvH for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 09:43:22 -0800 (PST)
Received: from uplift.swm.pp.se (swm.pp.se [212.247.200.143]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 93A4F12896F for <mboned@ietf.org>; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 09:43:07 -0800 (PST)
Received: by uplift.swm.pp.se (Postfix, from userid 501) id 75239B4; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 18:43:05 +0100 (CET)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/simple; d=swm.pp.se; s=mail; t=1510249385; bh=qfPrbGT/QZgYSdNu6y+kKt8fMvUcVLlYo/bsFP7K1NI=; h=Date:From:To:cc:Subject:In-Reply-To:References:From; b=azH9BXsH7dZJORWCCeHdRFgr+JF3J2sJnfYrdwJryfd2/Dmf5+XQe5spEO023wwJY 9I8NUk+5TMw4fOs+5ndDG66uaUQ3vEKZ7n2YTmPLLpUFeQIKq7xTSNrlaeS+ENeo15 SBpP6EI0TCLrAo0Ex2m4c8AZeJhHWb4iBIwFRtow=
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by uplift.swm.pp.se (Postfix) with ESMTP id 70063AF; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 18:43:05 +0100 (CET)
Date: Thu, 9 Nov 2017 18:43:05 +0100 (CET)
From: Mikael Abrahamsson <swmike@swm.pp.se>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
cc: Stig Venaas <stig@venaas.com>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
In-Reply-To: <20171109164913.GE18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
Message-ID: <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711091839380.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se>
References: <20170907134500.GB23219@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709071602420.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1709071111270.19087@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709072213470.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <bd1f3dab5846485a89bf443bd17b5ec4@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1709080445130.29378@uplift.swm.pp.se> <CAHANBt+G3EAOqmntE7O2dZddq_CXdEjcw62F_VE6ShLWEswWjg@mail.gmail.com> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711081040500.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20171108203432.GA11560@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <alpine.DEB.2.20.1711090640020.16389@uplift.swm.pp.se> <20171109164913.GE18166@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
User-Agent: Alpine 2.20 (DEB 67 2015-01-07)
Organization: People's Front Against WWW
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII; format=flowed
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/hxTXT5OTZ20D5KTuVVZ8QEO2OHw>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] deploying internet-wide multicast (RE: deprecating MSDP)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 09 Nov 2017 17:43:25 -0000

On Thu, 9 Nov 2017, Toerless Eckert wrote:

> Thanks, Mikael
>
> +1 on all your statements, but just because a requirement (zero loss for
> IPTV) is uncommon does not mean its difficult or novel.

Compared to setting up a network that has 0.02% packet loss compared to 
one 0.00001% packet loss, I would not say the latter is easy. It takes a 
completely different effort compared to the 0.02% one.

If you have 100.000 customers and 500 of them want linear TV, it might be 
a lot easier for you to not support native multicast at all in your 
network and just run AMT tunnels with retransmits (of some kind). That way 
you can get away with 0.02% packet loss network. I would of course like to 
have the AMT relays report in retransmits because that's valuable 
operational data.

> For any SP who wants to have existing IP multicast realtime walled garden
> linear TV reliable across a home/wifi, we can easily add AMT over TCP as a
> simple RFC. Mandate AMT/TCP relay on home gateway, mandate sock buffers
> good enough for 5 seconds of playout, and be done with 98% of your wifi
> problems IMHO (one outage every 4 hours ? ;-). Thats easy enough written
> up so that it wouldn't matter if we only get adoption by the selct few
> "non-ABR crowd".

Agreed.

> The main detail enhancement we need to include IMHO is that AMT
> (S,G) joins should be allowed to carry the "real relay"
> address, so that the home-GW can either join native walled-garden IPTV
> multicast directly or become gateway for another AMT tunnel to the
> over-the-top-content.

Right.

-- 
Mikael Abrahamsson    email: swmike@swm.pp.se


From nobody Thu Nov  9 19:58:29 2017
Return-Path: <iesg-secretary@ietf.org>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietf.org
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from ietfa.amsl.com (localhost [IPv6:::1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id D4D45120713; Thu,  9 Nov 2017 19:58:21 -0800 (PST)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
From: The IESG <iesg-secretary@ietf.org>
To: "IETF-Announce" <ietf-announce@ietf.org>
X-Test-IDTracker: no
X-IETF-IDTracker: 6.65.1
Auto-Submitted: auto-generated
Precedence: bulk
CC: Leonard Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>, lenny@juniper.net, draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2@ietf.org, mboned@ietf.org, mboned-chairs@ietf.org,  warren@kumari.net
Reply-To: ietf@ietf.org
Sender: <iesg-secretary@ietf.org>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Message-ID: <151028630182.29822.15830488305612346028.idtracker@ietfa.amsl.com>
Date: Thu, 09 Nov 2017 19:58:21 -0800
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/6FqivBHKcQ7upipAsBiR3nP2NXg>
Subject: [MBONED] Last Call: <draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2-21.txt> (Mtrace Version 2: Traceroute Facility for IP Multicast) to Proposed Standard
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 10 Nov 2017 03:58:22 -0000

The IESG has received a request from the MBONE Deployment WG (mboned) to
consider the following document: - 'Mtrace Version 2: Traceroute Facility for
IP Multicast'
  <draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2-21.txt> as Proposed Standard

The IESG plans to make a decision in the next few weeks, and solicits final
comments on this action. Please send substantive comments to the
ietf@ietf.org mailing lists by 2017-11-23. Exceptionally, comments may be
sent to iesg@ietf.org instead. In either case, please retain the beginning of
the Subject line to allow automated sorting.

Abstract


   This document describes the IP multicast traceroute facility, named
   Mtrace version 2 (Mtrace2).  Unlike unicast traceroute, Mtrace2
   requires special implementations on the part of routers.  This
   specification describes the required functionality in multicast
   routers, as well as how an Mtrace2 client invokes a query and
   receives a reply.




The file can be obtained via
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2/

IESG discussion can be tracked via
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-mboned-mtrace-v2/ballot/


No IPR declarations have been submitted directly on this I-D.





From nobody Fri Nov 10 02:01:26 2017
Return-Path: <tim.chown@jisc.ac.uk>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 6B4D7129432 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 02:01:24 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.321
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.321 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H3=-0.01, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=-0.01, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=jisc.ac.uk
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id CewNvG9Gfe41 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 02:01:21 -0800 (PST)
Received: from eu-smtp-delivery-189.mimecast.com (eu-smtp-delivery-189.mimecast.com [146.101.78.189]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 4E3CF12EC17 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 02:01:21 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=jisc.ac.uk; s=mimecast20170213; t=1510308079; h=from:subject:date:message-id:to:cc:mime-version:content-type:content-transfer-encoding:in-reply-to:references; bh=ayUzF4xbQyv7MvbNwEZqd37hI+n75h9PpXXV/0uB4Ms=; b=RlyQNwOiKSyCAWnbfTXyOWE8tNF9erFC12RfIdp5QfmNyoumnPCLcgacnbzb/J95p31zM4h1rvML2wsSWFUGclltGCq9dS7IliGEfOtpzVc7Mg4WLuprMuwDrL6OyMrtbAJIrU3Hj5QZe4EVHT5R8j/GCaLRCmYc2rMznoC5jJM=
Received: from EUR02-VE1-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-ve1eur02lp0055.outbound.protection.outlook.com [213.199.154.55]) (Using TLS) by eu-smtp-1.mimecast.com with ESMTP id uk-mta-77-qIbhW19hPdmykN3oKQKlow-1; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 10:01:14 +0000
Received: from AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com (10.163.188.14) by AM3PR07MB1139.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com (10.163.188.13) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384_P384) id 15.20.239.4; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 10:01:12 +0000
Received: from AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com ([fe80::d9b7:5aa5:5084:74c2]) by AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com ([fe80::d9b7:5aa5:5084:74c2%13]) with mapi id 15.20.0239.004; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 10:01:12 +0000
From: Tim Chown <Tim.Chown@jisc.ac.uk>
To: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
CC: MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: I-D Action: draft-acg-mboned-multicast-models-02.txt
Thread-Index: AQHTUdYPqU0dK+jzYE2Aawd+iPMOX6L9H2QAgBBSm4A=
Date: Fri, 10 Nov 2017 10:01:12 +0000
Message-ID: <0AB23114-4E96-4521-834E-E4C1D87991D8@jisc.ac.uk>
References: <150940561832.28310.1470763748333970243@ietfa.amsl.com> <C54D2DC2-6EA7-41D2-BEC2-81A27BC202BF@jisc.ac.uk> <9563781e07234ac7919ecaf64b02073e@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
In-Reply-To: <9563781e07234ac7919ecaf64b02073e@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
Accept-Language: en-GB, en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
x-mailer: Apple Mail (2.3445.4.7)
x-originating-ip: [2001:a88:d510:1101:d436:2662:84f0:9614]
x-ms-publictraffictype: Email
x-microsoft-exchange-diagnostics: 1; AM3PR07MB1139; 20:3s+3F/v/JK+xzjs/6/rBJMPPYZyjn43NQU02HAhHLwIB3ZzBcS/Do2YQdn6GiQiM0CIwOiMMOTtA4qS4Z9Z/1UtzL76Fv1aIKkfmOIgbzUwDVTqfOmjjdCdY37I/g9rcNlSY6JvuP07d3x8y/BSAfmeTZNM9A1WenaL3zFuzvUQ=
x-ms-exchange-antispam-srfa-diagnostics: SSOS;
x-ms-office365-filtering-correlation-id: c37de46e-918a-44dd-0c5c-08d52821f96a
x-microsoft-antispam: UriScan:; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(22001)(4534020)(4602075)(4627115)(201703031133081)(201702281549075)(2017052603199); SRVR:AM3PR07MB1139; 
x-ms-traffictypediagnostic: AM3PR07MB1139:
x-exchange-antispam-report-test: UriScan:(278428928389397)(120809045254105)(192374486261705)(39337521807258); 
x-microsoft-antispam-prvs: <AM3PR07MB113923FA11ABB1B038C1DCCDD6540@AM3PR07MB1139.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com>
x-exchange-antispam-report-cfa-test: BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000700101)(100105000095)(100000701101)(100105300095)(100000702101)(100105100095)(6040450)(2401047)(8121501046)(5005006)(100000703101)(100105400095)(3231021)(10201501046)(3002001)(93006095)(93001095)(6041248)(20161123555025)(20161123560025)(20161123564025)(20161123558100)(20161123562025)(201703131423075)(201702281529075)(201702281528075)(201703061421075)(201703061406153)(6072148)(201708071742011)(100000704101)(100105200095)(100000705101)(100105500095); SRVR:AM3PR07MB1139; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000800101)(100110000095)(100000801101)(100110300095)(100000802101)(100110100095)(100000803101)(100110400095)(100000804101)(100110200095)(100000805101)(100110500095); SRVR:AM3PR07MB1139; 
x-forefront-prvs: 0487C0DB7E
x-forefront-antispam-report: SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10009020)(6009001)(346002)(376002)(24454002)(51444003)(377424004)(189002)(199003)(51914003)(6116002)(68736007)(102836003)(2906002)(81156014)(76176999)(99286004)(86362001)(478600001)(105586002)(97736004)(5250100002)(82746002)(106356001)(786003)(81166006)(316002)(6486002)(50226002)(8936002)(6506006)(6436002)(36756003)(3280700002)(53546010)(57306001)(4001150100001)(74482002)(8666007)(3660700001)(5660300001)(4326008)(229853002)(25786009)(6246003)(33656002)(72206003)(6512007)(7736002)(6306002)(14454004)(305945005)(8676002)(83716003)(189998001)(42882006)(53936002)(6916009)(230783001)(101416001)(2900100001)(50986999)(2950100002)(966005)(24704002); DIR:OUT; SFP:1101; SCL:1; SRVR:AM3PR07MB1139; H:AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com; FPR:; SPF:None; PTR:InfoNoRecords;  MX:1; A:1; LANG:en; 
spamdiagnosticoutput: 1:99
spamdiagnosticmetadata: NSPM
Content-ID: <AC11A053647A204D92B8938F1EA2F86D@eurprd07.prod.outlook.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-OriginatorOrg: jisc.ac.uk
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: c37de46e-918a-44dd-0c5c-08d52821f96a
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-originalarrivaltime: 10 Nov 2017 10:01:12.5676 (UTC)
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-fromentityheader: Hosted
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-id: 48f9394d-8a14-4d27-82a6-f35f12361205
X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: AM3PR07MB1139
X-MC-Unique: qIbhW19hPdmykN3oKQKlow-1
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/VFLczCG7PMg20xxLTJjqqcK-OuE>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] I-D Action: draft-acg-mboned-multicast-models-02.txt
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 10 Nov 2017 10:01:24 -0000
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From nobody Fri Nov 10 08:56:58 2017
Return-Path: <lenny@juniper.net>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 0B0FC12EB2B for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 08:56:57 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.021
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.021 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE=-0.0001, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H4=-0.01, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=-0.01, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=juniper.net
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 5VwaM_XUkvPb for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 08:56:55 -0800 (PST)
Received: from NAM02-CY1-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-cys01nam02on0128.outbound.protection.outlook.com [104.47.37.128]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 56E5F128A32 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 08:56:55 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=juniper.net; s=selector1; h=From:Date:Subject:Message-ID:Content-Type:MIME-Version; bh=qJ0rTmKwrKIMmJ63DSPgYGRzoCi6tRd1RNCS/Kk/Lug=; b=X6sKMMjfKrGiAG0jFgAps9mUCUoCqcq36nfxyCSqqKDrUcSSY9QTSQijcudUenh9lg8EMGT8VQMth+WNcubPfUW9eOigUR77wLvBoJLrOdMIKOtPPlAu5PDlwjplH1ipW8eDR7CQ78eLGgJKnN9OxoFEPv/jaebXuSStB9Y4abg=
Received: from BY1PR0501CA0032.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.162.139.42) by BLUPR0501MB2068.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.164.23.26) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384_P384) id 15.20.239.4; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 16:56:53 +0000
Received: from CO1NAM05FT063.eop-nam05.prod.protection.outlook.com (2a01:111:f400:7e50::205) by BY1PR0501CA0032.outlook.office365.com (2a01:111:e400:4821::42) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384) id 15.20.239.4 via Frontend Transport; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 16:56:53 +0000
Authentication-Results: spf=softfail (sender IP is 66.129.239.15) smtp.mailfrom=juniper.net; ietf.org; dkim=none (message not signed) header.d=none;ietf.org; dmarc=fail action=none header.from=juniper.net;
Received-SPF: SoftFail (protection.outlook.com: domain of transitioning juniper.net discourages use of 66.129.239.15 as permitted sender)
Received: from P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (66.129.239.15) by CO1NAM05FT063.mail.protection.outlook.com (10.152.96.181) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_0, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA_P256) id 15.20.218.12 via Frontend Transport; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 16:56:51 +0000
Received: from svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (172.17.28.215) by P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (172.24.192.21) with Microsoft SMTP Server id 14.3.123.3; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 08:56:51 -0800
Received: by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix, from userid 1709)	id 28F689F932; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 08:56:51 -0800 (PST)
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1])	by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix) with ESMTP id 25EB19F931	for <mboned@ietf.org>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 08:56:51 -0800 (PST)
Date: Fri, 10 Nov 2017 08:56:51 -0800
From: Leonard Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>
To: MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <alpine.DEB.2.02.1711100851270.22804@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net>
User-Agent: Alpine 2.02 (DEB 1266 2009-07-14)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; format=flowed; charset="US-ASCII"
X-EOPAttributedMessage: 0
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-HT: Tenant
X-Forefront-Antispam-Report: CIP:66.129.239.15; IPV:NLI; CTRY:US; EFV:NLI; SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10019020)(6009001)(39860400002)(376002)(346002)(2980300002)(199003)(189002)(77096006)(8936002)(105596002)(46386002)(47776003)(76506005)(57986006)(45336002)(106466001)(86362001)(67846002)(83506002)(90966002)(54356999)(23726003)(50986999)(8676002)(81156014)(478600001)(2810700001)(81166006)(53936002)(5005980100005)(3240700002)(58126008)(189998001)(5660300001)(7126002)(316002)(69596002)(6916009)(305945005)(50466002)(2906002)(16586007)(68736007)(97736004)(356003)(6266002)(42262002); DIR:OUT; SFP:1102; SCL:1; SRVR:BLUPR0501MB2068; H:P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net; FPR:; SPF:SoftFail; PTR:InfoDomainNonexistent; A:1; MX:1; LANG:en; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; CO1NAM05FT063; 1:AeHCf0URCm37CJ6PjwiTZKBvG8cIRXkdcB4YugoOkBirMecZwBwRCB/uK5OrgLueyJ7SEP7ke2cMsiBtKMNC/kuxqdhXj2hp2+B8so7i3SL8mdKPscS+Eq3jN6fYVMz/
X-MS-PublicTrafficType: Email
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-Correlation-Id: 43d33f8b-b87c-4253-4ef7-08d5285c0a66
X-Microsoft-Antispam: UriScan:; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(22001)(4534020)(4602075)(4627115)(201703031133081)(201702281549075)(2017052603199); SRVR:BLUPR0501MB2068; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BLUPR0501MB2068; 3:Q5JxnzRQyReIyaTyq0C+BujVJXADcbOXTqqyary2NS+xeubBojVC/1V66QVuXgm00BYj/oP1gV60XgrsAIKdx0AiUrA6YTDEjKJnbkq9cxERJ++bN59J8Jsm03KvogA0HgGWz51nWs+JgubHbcfKRhd3Nfkue+Jbj1ar7ENsci9g2jQPEA61yCbMPTXrFbY/o9Jl+BBLNKiSPxO4JNoAgPWYlK2yj8gel2fSm6+UAx+S1stKIvcldiy2VOrzCEB/VSQozALq11lKs2atS8h/mS5M86iLMqso9Q7cfNrUrfcMvBBoDfxdBj/dsm3uHSebA6KGicdUoTkKjIf1qxFKb84lGvAiD8mZbvLOq0mKJXU=; 25:v1HdlQCga6qG1asSAJ/EV6U3ix5q6tQJCjopZ5LxOgRyEMcHJFEDzhFxQ4ebCroA3HLB88WpldpuHzsohL6vfDYGnX2I8NOg/5IwI0vlDuezZf4cdmR6qbjV7G6kkPJ7NyuYYAa9tA7Tkpoq0gG5TlhKXndKIauYF5dNXJYAOycjIgeAfen1sJd5W/BG7ODjeB7y/FP9Vz3v6BWC/XSF9fLTSijaiYH5/IRPTWgczNzQx44NyQuLSOuuzHI9P2r3GhueEU6v8YKIRmqS6FGPI8vKUrPahj0QLsbF6yKJ3ACxjpzAeWQtP7PZdXqxxZIeIBHV7rnZbByTZgI7L4gbjw==
X-MS-TrafficTypeDiagnostic: BLUPR0501MB2068:
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BLUPR0501MB2068; 31:C0BQvx8zDK+/HQzIsGWRU+G/Jj8YCfbI3mF75ttAk0lOstfpQ7L7U12VEFQARMpLu5A0DKkIKeJtFbMkV4ujRRu4fBHGzudCpNW86XQgLBbwIA8t7S+jtpZnoiR0XbNta+7tu8psLtW8dq7C76lpWYdLHrO5DAKwPWNetiPrEnvB6zDp6o8WSW6+aKYWb1WsbgR0cp3EEgWMarYULO9NnvFTmyziQB5JouBudVj6mpM=; 20: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
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-Test: UriScan:;
X-Microsoft-Antispam-PRVS: <BLUPR0501MB2068190974E59F7E03964B3AA4540@BLUPR0501MB2068.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-CFA-Test: BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000700101)(100105000095)(100000701101)(100105300095)(100000702101)(100105100095)(6040450)(2401047)(5005006)(8121501046)(3002001)(10201501046)(3231021)(93006095)(93001095)(100000703101)(100105400095)(6055026)(6041248)(20161123555025)(201703131423075)(201702281528075)(201703061421075)(201703061406153)(20161123558100)(20161123562025)(20161123564025)(20161123560025)(6072148)(201708071742011)(100000704101)(100105200095)(100000705101)(100105500095); SRVR:BLUPR0501MB2068; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000800101)(100110000095)(100000801101)(100110300095)(100000802101)(100110100095)(100000803101)(100110400095)(100000804101)(100110200095)(100000805101)(100110500095); SRVR:BLUPR0501MB2068; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BLUPR0501MB2068; 4:SIvwx25ZLhpVsLuqyyNo3q48KP4289uZYNrEPk98mwRdMEJ4B9ZFezao83akliVJGCSwBd8wPelOoDHWOVnomV5Mk85nDFLtaK2vnz4lzYcQBFheFX19ALxOMenjgGV5vuNmoWPexujd8NqD/3R3IrIbu/NWHMtLeLs142aULt4Htmy0G0MH1MkWna8KcfrKLczZyzRLyOQmkYVQ8olOXEISYl459lqoov+kQiN0CUC7OOckd0ZwoACjOSM8x+tdwIcA9zEYkGGxTbdRn68MKg==
X-Forefront-PRVS: 0487C0DB7E
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: =?us-ascii?Q?1; BLUPR0501MB2068; 23:OTELzLjQUh480pbw+AjC+w8BgaUUFPHxMstPfL8?= =?us-ascii?Q?oaxnURNl3JBCUileAR1EJ7VBcKm/+YHcn8iMPywmE7xHRYo//GlcuECV82MH?= =?us-ascii?Q?cB9zRrPicBSXRfe6VVXiLgsJ8IsbQuU2UbYTQQvcF9LmmkAjVoYvTXPTxcyK?= =?us-ascii?Q?L7t7RfqdesRkkMWltvhHwkG1R1wcl+cf+qo8eDimNk8Tt0aGVVTnGeas/zYc?= =?us-ascii?Q?8SKwHIXSMIc1/F5gj4pV3TEp7uH1WveVwOii7XTzUXSpJlrO5NA6LB7ILEE6?= =?us-ascii?Q?waPQpMfxqqswvorRlvHDbYC9YLhI4VowzSUCENbqDHuTQEyeS4/eHIfMGZJc?= =?us-ascii?Q?rc10Lle6KZItkt+Jguga2TUcemv5KeIPDsBQRz+F0PJbgu0KkIWrgtMK+mGA?= =?us-ascii?Q?5/UDgwug9k4mWYijyYgQtSIZL1TWcJw2C/M5Qx2vtdEPNmseyxHyL95k7ETS?= =?us-ascii?Q?KG90UgLpR5LDg60cSelzlhRff779IO5C7IT3Nm86k69IiSeVtmdj5MHHZ8jk?= =?us-ascii?Q?+TMB0qx0PA2HkCJ2e9kbcvrRSgLN7yFqBojb2/RsXYVh7/1rvXEGL3zNH36W?= =?us-ascii?Q?SCPISn2ln9s8MjNkeuIE6W9cb+O2XGQOUV+ErfEakr5fv78xApIWbX00chiL?= =?us-ascii?Q?cNFTkz7fxUELGcQdHpP8olK31yDP6LbBwBmSWroSwneks8aPhgSJdMq3pIlH?= =?us-ascii?Q?nA/M5r7F3kK7UKUPJhj41aYKwhB1GLNRuviyLrpOB/vZE4W3NDMKomXenamN?= =?us-ascii?Q?X6MIc1umVsAufQ4cgC0QqFutKWyxxPxnOYrl+ZL1rLOS2X6LC2Ib8Ndgf6Uk?= =?us-ascii?Q?tHL0yxDumyps7ktBCjOB3UWulkOhGhCiHOLb5vvpRFth5Ya950dukxJWOMyk?= =?us-ascii?Q?b1D+rDLTa1VqY9sN1JMGcYNG6GrMeqOGNGQbxKY0quUoFPOfR9Wq/psBybt0?= =?us-ascii?Q?9qv+QUA0XeG64oa5zVopKsNA36vhn+4KA3MEbIs3P6or8QT7owygaHimmIr4?= =?us-ascii?Q?Z7y94NIo1r+CTOCipQqCZj0AthSHFIIufJvpIOO/xW2jM3Eyp6IPOaxOA+E0?= =?us-ascii?Q?gSBovvYwthxV3oBLZ4o4IhcpZKuzsl6rjuuaCe+S7iueN7eh6LWc0Wsa3UxB?= =?us-ascii?Q?mzv469YiALOo=3D?=
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BLUPR0501MB2068; 6:ArzzvPHkIQ6phNRSxr8IKCElItyVjZlp9VbxvzFMHA6sSyMqkUlp06h2UxKV5zZjXI97MXHcv4mvUDIjAorwL2+llXJQTpzYY3I7pvEzaPyT4L/oa+aBsRwFNB9xZvOLT+GfLnVHtcI+xbtIXq7iMDd1Hau20/5yijFJ+bXEVol+tJh9GMIh+bxFsMcDjnHbryDKTaB+RepHM37MDdeWykQkR4Q1IRDgi8CCTaDDc/vK71h+gBvJ3thlpd2T0KE+ay9tTK/GrUxWcR+eCd6ChAokxAhHEXtCV9CvrmOeryY4oE1LZY8prbSOVQzVAV3Ab2CGyV80eNVubJRlWBfft7XKfrjCr96/knx1vIXvf/c=; 5:LcPBHRMppcSrXUQxVxB8CEo1j7HPzaO0WV6C4DgXjleHBZeGRK+eojxakYtiq7yzy8qtirB6eeUsrJflX/lYVeh7bM67WwVR/5DAxaPM4cA+lt8evgzT1o4hLvQy1dr7vcrY4SYwCq/SkBKrMmeDjiCFegNWdmms95pI3EnmetA=; 24:3WeDtUDrCMWU76shUtW7WDhyM3iwfKcM5GsC7fnR/mwEeHn+CuHPHx/ecVaFRIRGatWFp93/8eYQXI/eVkEz19E6iSHlhwhTv49ls92r2eY=; 7:hf5rggE1phOAx/ZmJ8z3naT41K6ALfu4I7522+DhSuGAqcTRIDCATPN95ce4cWMC4BHJ5oTCLp19DkfKJW8fyFgFY/KvAcBFEBdIjxTmH/yMSu8kNBTV8MktLyxw+S4/4DfeM2ZIy3coAMQA5ESOqEyQRF3yI5F6KsBhzrPeL4cFB2ZeAC+a/BuMnIwV9PBXPCNAHZzVIhrh2h2lZN3T0qVvFczGkJ0YUK2WrLlyApU/0O+auqc+cy1i1YB90yCV
SpamDiagnosticOutput: 1:99
SpamDiagnosticMetadata: NSPM
X-OriginatorOrg: juniper.net
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalArrivalTime: 10 Nov 2017 16:56:51.6716 (UTC)
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: 43d33f8b-b87c-4253-4ef7-08d5285c0a66
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Id: bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalAttributedTenantConnectingIp: TenantId=bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4; Ip=[66.129.239.15];  Helo=[P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net]
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-FromEntityHeader: HybridOnPrem
X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: BLUPR0501MB2068
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/kdYwkNEK5IQr2kUUGX2b8P8YJB8>
Subject: [MBONED] Agenda for MBONED in Singapore
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 10 Nov 2017 16:56:57 -0000

All,

We have an action-packed agenda for MBONED on Tues morning in Singapore. 
Please let us know if we missed anyone.  Also, still need some slides from 
folks (thanks Sandy, Tim and Jeffrey for getting those in early).  Mike 
and Toerless- please get those to the chairs by Nov 11 so folks have 
enough time to review beforehand.



IETF 100 Singapore
MBONED Agenda
Tues, Nov 14, 2017
9:30AM-12PM
VIP A (Held jointly with PIM WG)

Status of WG items
Chairs, 5 min

draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement-01
McBride, 15 mins

draft-acg-mboned-multicast-models-00
Chown, 20 min

draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp
Eckert, 10 mins

draft-zhang-mboned-multicast-info-model-02
Sandy Zheng, 10 mins

draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
Jeffrey Zhang, 15 mins


From nobody Fri Nov 10 12:10:03 2017
Return-Path: <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 2675C129466 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 12:10:02 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.221
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.221 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H3=-0.01, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=-0.01, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id OmUaPZUhCsrF for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 12:10:00 -0800 (PST)
Received: from phx-mbsout-02.mbs.boeing.net (phx-mbsout-02.mbs.boeing.net [130.76.184.179]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 557E2124F57 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 12:10:00 -0800 (PST)
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by phx-mbsout-02.mbs.boeing.net (8.14.4/8.14.4/DOWNSTREAM_MBSOUT) with SMTP id vAAK9xUE021560; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 13:09:59 -0700
Received: from XCH15-06-09.nw.nos.boeing.com (xch15-06-09.nw.nos.boeing.com [137.136.239.172]) by phx-mbsout-02.mbs.boeing.net (8.14.4/8.14.4/UPSTREAM_MBSOUT) with ESMTP id vAAK9nhJ021450 (version=TLSv1/SSLv3 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=OK); Fri, 10 Nov 2017 13:09:49 -0700
Received: from XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com (2002:8988:efdc::8988:efdc) by XCH15-06-09.nw.nos.boeing.com (2002:8988:efac::8988:efac) with Microsoft SMTP Server (TLS) id 15.0.1320.4; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 12:09:48 -0800
Received: from XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com ([137.136.239.220]) by XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com ([137.136.239.220]) with mapi id 15.00.1320.000; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 12:09:48 -0800
From: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
To: Tim Chown <Tim.Chown@jisc.ac.uk>
CC: MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: I-D Action: draft-acg-mboned-multicast-models-02.txt
Thread-Index: AQHTUdYPqU0dK+jzYE2Aawd+iPMOX6L9H2QAgBBSm4CAAJH84A==
Date: Fri, 10 Nov 2017 20:09:48 +0000
Message-ID: <96877569f0524339bb7841e8d61736c2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
References: <150940561832.28310.1470763748333970243@ietfa.amsl.com> <C54D2DC2-6EA7-41D2-BEC2-81A27BC202BF@jisc.ac.uk> <9563781e07234ac7919ecaf64b02073e@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <0AB23114-4E96-4521-834E-E4C1D87991D8@jisc.ac.uk>
In-Reply-To: <0AB23114-4E96-4521-834E-E4C1D87991D8@jisc.ac.uk>
Accept-Language: en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
x-ms-exchange-transport-fromentityheader: Hosted
x-originating-ip: [137.136.248.6]
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-TM-AS-MML: disable
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/kIT2RmIZws4TBKE7rvO6bcdTU_4>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] I-D Action: draft-acg-mboned-multicast-models-02.txt
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 10 Nov 2017 20:10:02 -0000

LS0tLS1PcmlnaW5hbCBNZXNzYWdlLS0tLS0NCkZyb206IFRpbSBDaG93biBbbWFpbHRvOlRpbS5D
aG93bkBqaXNjLmFjLnVrXSANCg0KPj4gSSB0aGluayB0aGF0IGluIHByYWN0aWNlLCBpbnRlcmRv
bWFpbiBtdWx0aWNhc3QgaXMgbm93IGJlaW5nIGRpc2NvdXJhZ2VkDQo+PiBmb3Igc2VjdXJpdHkg
cmVhc29ucy4gQ29udmVyc2VseSwgQVNNLCB3aXRoaW4gYSBzaW5nbGUgZG9tYWluIHJlbWFpbnMg
dmVyeQ0KPj4gdXNlZnVsLiBUaGF04oCZcyB3aHkgSeKAmWQgYmUgdW5jb21mb3J0YWJsZSB3aXRo
IGEgYmxhbmtldCBjb25kZW1uYXRpb24gb2YgQVNNLg0KPg0KPiBJIHRoaW5rIHRoYXTigJlzIHdo
YXQgdGhlIGRyYWZ0IGN1cnJlbnRseSBzYXlzLCBidXQgd2hpbGUgYWxzbyByZWNvbW1lbmRpbmcN
Cj4gU1NNIGluIGdlbmVyYWwsIGVzcC4gZm9yIG5ldyBhcHBsaWNhdGlvbnMuDQo+DQo+IFRoZSBS
YXRpb25hbGUgc2VjdGlvbg0KDQpIaSBUaW0sIHRoYW5rcy4gWWVzLCBJJ2QgcHJlZmVyIG9ubHkg
dG8gcmVkdWNlIHRoZSBzdHJlbmd0aCBvZiB0aGUgcmVjb21tZW5kYXRpb24gYWdhaW5zdCBpbnRy
YWRvbWFpbiBBU00uIFZlcnkgc2ltcGxlIGNoYW5nZXMgdG8gdGhlIHRleHQuDQoNCj4+IEV2ZXJ5
dGhpbmcgZGVwZW5kcyBvbiB1c2UgY2FzZS4gSW4gYSBjb250cm9sIHN5c3RlbSBzY2VuYXJpbywg
QVNNIG1heSB3ZWxsDQo+PiAuLi4gT3IsIGFsc28gZnJlcXVlbnRseSwgbXVsdGljYXN0IGlzIHVz
ZWQgZm9yIHN0YXR1cyBtZXNzYWdlcyBmcm9tIG1hbnkNCj4+IHNvdXJjZXMsIHNvbWUgb3IgYWxs
IG9mIHdoaWNoIGhhdmUgcmVkdW5kYW50IGludGVyZmFjZXMuIFNvIGhhdmluZyBldmVyeSBob3N0
DQo+PiBjb25maWd1cmVkIHRvIGtub3cgYWxsIHRoZSBwb3NzaWJsZSBzb3VyY2VzLCBhbmQgam9p
biBhbGwgb2YgdGhlIHBvc3NpYmxlDQo+PiBtdWx0aWNhc3QgZ3JvdXBzLCBiZWNvbWVzIGEgaHVn
ZSBwYWluLiBIYXJkbHkg4oCcc2ltcGxlcuKAnSB0aGFuIEFTTS4NCj4NCj4gV2VsbCwgdGhlIHBv
aW50IGlzIHRoYXQgc291cmNlIGRpc2NvdmVyeSBpcyBwdXNoZWQgZnJvbSB0aGUgbmV0d29yayBs
YXllciB0byBhDQo+IGhpZ2hlciBsYXllciwgc2ltcGxpZnlpbmcgbmV0d29yayBzdGF0ZSwgYW5k
IHB1dHRpbmcgdGhlIHJlc3BvbnNpYmlsaXR5IG9uIHRoZQ0KPiBhcHBsaWNhdGlvbnMgdG8gY29t
bXVuaWNhdGUgYWJvdXQgb3IgZGlzY292ZXIgYXBwcm9wcmlhdGUgc291cmNlcy4NCg0KSSBhZ3Jl
ZSB0aGF0IHNvdXJjZSBkaXNjb3ZlcnkgaGFzIGJlZW4gcHVzaGVkIHRvIGhpZ2hlciBsYXllcnMs
IGJ1dCBJJ20gYWxzbyBjb25jZXJuZWQgYWJvdXQgY29tcGxpY2F0aW9uIGJlaW5nIGFkZGVkIGF0
IHRob3NlIHVwcGVyIGxheWVycyEgTXkgcG9pbnQgaXMgdGhhdCBpdCdzIHByZWZlcmFibGUgdG8g
YXZvaWQgYWxsIHRoZSBiYWNrZ3JvdW5kIGNoYXR0ZXIgdGhhdCB3b3VsZCBoYXZlIHRvIG9jY3Vy
LCBpbiBzb21lIG11bHRpY2FzdCBzY2VuYXJpb3Mgc3VjaCBhcyB0aGUgb25lIGRlc2NyaWJlZCBh
Ym92ZSwgZm9yIGV2ZXJ5IGhvc3QgaW4gdGhlIG11bHRpY2FzdCBncm91cCB0byBrZWVwIHRyYWNr
IHRoZSBzb3VyY2UocykgdGhhdCBtaWdodCBiZSByZWxldmFudCBhdCBhbnkgZ2l2ZW4gdGltZS4g
VGhpcyBjb3VsZCBiZWNvbWUgcmVhbGx5IGxhYm9yaW91cyBhbmQgdW5uZWNlc3NhcnksIHdoZXRo
ZXIgaXQncyBkb25lIGR5bmFtaWNhbGx5LCBvciBhaGVhZCBvZiB0aW1lLCBhcyBhIHN0YXRpYyBj
b25maWd1cmF0aW9uIHJlcXVpcmVtZW50Lg0KDQpFbmZvcmNpbmcgU1NNIG9ubHkgaXMgbGlrZSBk
b2luZyBJUCBtdWx0aWNhc3Qgb3ZlciBBVE0gb3IgYW55IG90aGVyIGNpcmN1aXQtc3dpdGNoZWQg
c3lzdGVtLiBZb3UgaGF2ZSB0byBnbyB0aHJvdWdoIHRoZSBjaG9yZSBvZiBzZXR0aW5nIHVwIHB0
LW1wdCBTVkNzIGJlZm9yZSB5b3UgY2FuIHVzZSBtdWx0aWNhc3QsIHdoaWNoIGltcGxpZXMga25v
d2xlZGdlIG9mIGV2ZXJ5IHBvdGVudGlhbCBzb3VyY2UuIFRoZSBhcHByb2FjaCByZW1vdmVzIG9u
ZSByZWFsbHkgYXBwZWFsaW5nIGFzcGVjdCBvZiB0aGUgbGVhZiBqb2luIG1vZGVsIHBvc3NpYmxl
IHdoZW4gdXNpbmcgZnJhbWUgc3dpdGNoaW5nIHNjaGVtZXMgbGlrZSBFdGhlcm5ldC4gSSBnZXQg
dGhhdCBmb3IgaW50ZXJkb21haW4gdXNlLCBpdCdzIGEgd2F5IHNpbXBsZXIgYXBwcm9hY2gsIGJ1
dCBpdCB3b3VsZCBiZSBhIHNoYW1lIGZvciBldmVyeXRoaW5nIHRvIGhhdmUgdG8gYmUgZG9uZSB0
aGF0IHdheSwgYWx3YXlzLg0KDQo+IFdlIGNvdWxkIGFkZCBzb21lIHRleHQgYWxvbmcgdGhlIGxp
bmVzIHlvdeKAmXZlIHdyaXR0ZW4gYWJvdmUgdG8gc2VjdGlvbiA3LjMuICBDYXJlIHRvIGRyYWZ0
IGEgcGFyYWdyYXBoPw0KDQpJJ2Qgc3RhcnQgYnkgcmVtb3ZpbmcgZW50aXJlbHksIG9yIGF0IGxl
YXN0IHNvZnRlbmluZywgdGhlIGxhc3Qgc2VudGVuY2Ugb2YgU2VjdGlvbiA3Lg0KDQo3LiAgUmVj
b21tZW5kYXRpb25zIG9uIEFTTSBhbmQgU1NNIGRlcGxveW1lbnQNCg0KICAgVGhpcyBkb2N1bWVu
dCByZWNvbW1lbmRzIHRoYXQgdGhlIHVzZSBvZiBpbnRlcmRvbWFpbiBBU00gaXMNCiAgIGRlcHJl
Y2F0ZWQsIGkuZS4sIG9ubHkgU1NNIGlzIHRvIGJlIHVzZWQgZm9yIGludGVyZG9tYWluIG11bHRp
Y2FzdC4NCiAgIEludHJhZG9tYWluIG11bHRpY2FzdCBtYXkgc3RpbGwgYmVuZWZpdCBmcm9tIEFT
TSwgaG93ZXZlciBzZWN1cml0eQ0KICAgY29uc2lkZXJhdGlvbnMgbWF5IHBvdGVudGlhbGx5IG1h
a2UgaW50cmFkb21haW4gU1NNIHByZWZlcmFibGUuDQoNCkFuZCB0aGVuIGluIFNlY3Rpb24gNy4z
LCBqdXN0IGEgbWlub3IgY2hhbmdlLCBhbmQgcmVtb3ZlIHRoZSBsYXN0IHNlbnRlbmNlOg0KDQo3
LjMuICBJbnRyYWRvbWFpbiBBU00NCg0KICAgVGhlIHVzZSBvZiBBU00gd2l0aGluIGEgc2luZ2xl
IG11bHRpY2FzdCBkb21haW4sIHN1Y2ggYXMgYW4NCiAgIGVudGVycHJpc2Ugb3IgY2FtcHVzLCBp
cyByZWxhdGl2ZWx5IGNvbW1vbiB0b2RheS4gU3VjaCBzaXRlcyBtYXkNCiAgIGNvbmZpZ3VyZSBh
biBSUCBmb3IgdGhlIHNpdGUsIGFuZCBtYXkgY2hvb3NlIHRvIHVzZSBBbnljYXN0LVJQIG9yIE1T
RFANCiAgIGZvciBSUCByZXNpbGllbmNlLiBBbHRlcm5hdGl2ZWx5LCBzdWNoIHNpdGVzIG1heSBk
ZXBsb3kgbXVsdGljYXN0DQogICByb3V0aW5nIGFsZ29yaXRobXMgdGhhdCBkbyBub3QgcmVxdWly
ZSBhbnkgUlAsIHdpdGhpbiB0aGUgZG9tYWluLg0KICAgUmVnYXJkbGVzcywgdGhpcyBkb2N1bWVu
dCBkb2VzIG5vdCBwcmVjbHVkZSBjb250aW51ZWQgdXNlIG9mIEFTTSBpbg0KICAgdGhlIGludHJh
ZG9tYWluIHNjZW5hcmlvLg0KDQpTb21lIG90aGVyIHdvcmRpbmcsIGluIFNlY3Rpb25zIDcuNSBh
bmQgNy42LCBjb3VsZCBhbHNvIGJlIHNvZnRlbmVkLiBGb3IgaW5zdGFuY2UsIGluIDcuNiwgaXQg
c2F5czoNCg0KICAgVGh1cywgaW4gdGhlb3J5LCBpdCBzaG91bGQgYmUgcG9zc2libGUgdG8gcG9y
dCBBU00tb25seSBhcHBsaWNhdGlvbnMNCiAgIHRvIGJlIGFibGUgdG8gcnVuIHVzaW5nIFNTTSwg
aWYgYW4gYXBwcm9wcmlhdGUgb3V0LW9mLWJhbmQgbWVjaGFuaXNtDQogICBjYW4gYmUgY2hvc2Vu
IHRvIGNvbnZleSB0aGUgcGFydGljaXBhbnQgc291cmNlIGFkZHJlc3Nlcy4NCg0KVHJ1ZSBlbm91
Z2guIFBvaW50IGJlaW5nLCBoYXZpbmcgdG8gY3JlYXRlIHRoaXMgb3RoZXIgIm91dCBvZiBiYW5k
IG1lY2hhbmlzbSIgYmVjb21lcyBhbiBleHRyYSBjb21wbGljYXRpb24gaW1wb3NlZCBieSBhbiBT
U00tb25seSByZWdpbWUuIEluIG5vIHdheSBjYW4gdGhpcyBiZSBjYWxsZWQgc2ltcGxpZmljYXRp
b24uIE1vdmluZyB0aGUgY29tcGxleGl0eSB1cCB0aGUgcHJvdG9jb2wgbGFkZGVyIGRvZXMgbm90
IG1lYW4gdGhlIGNvbXBsZXhpdHkgaGFzIGJlZW4gZWxpbWluYXRlZC4gSXQncyBtdWNoIGxpa2Ug
SVAgbXVsdGljYXN0IG92ZXIgQVRNLCB3aGVyZSBub3cgc29tZXRoaW5nIGV4dHJhIGhhcyB0byBi
ZSBwcm9ncmFtbWVkLCB0byBzZXQgdXAgdGhlIG11bHRpcGxlIG5lY2Vzc2FyeSBjaXJjdWl0cy4N
Cg0KQmVydA0KDQo=


From nobody Fri Nov 10 23:58:51 2017
Return-Path: <alissa@cooperw.in>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietf.org
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from ietfa.amsl.com (localhost [IPv6:::1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 44F9A120726; Fri, 10 Nov 2017 23:58:44 -0800 (PST)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
From: Alissa Cooper <alissa@cooperw.in>
To: "The IESG" <iesg@ietf.org>
Cc: draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp@ietf.org, mboned-chairs@ietf.org, tim.chown@jisc.ac.uk, mboned@ietf.org
X-Test-IDTracker: no
X-IETF-IDTracker: 6.65.1
Auto-Submitted: auto-generated
Precedence: bulk
Message-ID: <151038712425.16073.17226985345922427477.idtracker@ietfa.amsl.com>
Date: Fri, 10 Nov 2017 23:58:44 -0800
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/6SI51BgtyI-rPInWHJC7a_YcGWY>
Subject: [MBONED] Alissa Cooper's No Objection on draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14: (with COMMENT)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Sat, 11 Nov 2017 07:58:44 -0000

Alissa Cooper has entered the following ballot position for
draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14: No Objection

When responding, please keep the subject line intact and reply to all
email addresses included in the To and CC lines. (Feel free to cut this
introductory paragraph, however.)


Please refer to https://www.ietf.org/iesg/statement/discuss-criteria.html
for more information about IESG DISCUSS and COMMENT positions.


The document, along with other ballot positions, can be found here:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp/



----------------------------------------------------------------------
COMMENT:
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Thank for addressing my DISCUSS and COMMENTs.



From nobody Sat Nov 11 01:24:19 2017
Return-Path: <iesg-secretary@ietf.org>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietf.org
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from ietfa.amsl.com (localhost [IPv6:::1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 71092129462; Sat, 11 Nov 2017 01:24:05 -0800 (PST)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
From: The IESG <iesg-secretary@ietf.org>
To: "IETF-Announce" <ietf-announce@ietf.org>
X-Test-IDTracker: no
X-IETF-IDTracker: 6.65.1
Auto-Submitted: auto-generated
Precedence: bulk
Cc: The IESG <iesg@ietf.org>, draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp@ietf.org, tim.chown@jisc.ac.uk, mboned@ietf.org, mboned-chairs@ietf.org, warren@kumari.net, rfc-editor@rfc-editor.org
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Message-ID: <151039224543.16215.6980204389475563555.idtracker@ietfa.amsl.com>
Date: Sat, 11 Nov 2017 01:24:05 -0800
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/orEtz-0KP4gquhmI8mcmWeH1uRM>
Subject: [MBONED] Protocol Action: 'Use of Multicast Across Inter-Domain Peering Points' to Best Current Practice (draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14.txt)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Sat, 11 Nov 2017 09:24:06 -0000

The IESG has approved the following document:
- 'Use of Multicast Across Inter-Domain Peering Points'
  (draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14.txt) as Best Current Practice

This document is the product of the MBONE Deployment Working Group.

The IESG contact persons are Warren Kumari and Benoit Claise.

A URL of this Internet Draft is:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp/





Technical Summary

   This document describes best practice for setup and configuration of 
   inter-domain multicast peering, between different administrative domains,
   for a set of use cases. It focuses on source-specific multicast (SSM).

Working Group Summary

   There is strong consensus in the WG for publication of this document.

Document Quality

   The document is generally well written. It is lengthy, and probably 
   could be streamlined, but having reached consensus on the current text, 
   it would seem better to publish as is than delay publication further 
   while the text is abbreviated. During the evolution of the document, 
   good discussion was held on a number of points in the document, and 
   a number of changes made as a result, e.g., the focus on SSM.

   Contributions to this document were made by multiple mboned WG members 
   and from multiple vendors.

Personnel

   Shepherd: Tim Chown
   RAD: Warren Kumari


From nobody Sat Nov 11 22:30:26 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id B4EDD120713; Sat, 11 Nov 2017 22:30:23 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.199
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.199 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 4lOTQRl-MJdv; Sat, 11 Nov 2017 22:30:21 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 9C163126C0F; Sat, 11 Nov 2017 22:30:21 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 8EC4A58C4B0; Sun, 12 Nov 2017 07:30:17 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 7810BB0D124; Sun, 12 Nov 2017 07:30:17 +0100 (CET)
Date: Sun, 12 Nov 2017 07:30:17 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: Alissa Cooper <alissa@cooperw.in>
Cc: The IESG <iesg@ietf.org>, draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp@ietf.org, mboned-chairs@ietf.org, tim.chown@jisc.ac.uk, mboned@ietf.org
Message-ID: <20171112063017.GA14226@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <151038712425.16073.17226985345922427477.idtracker@ietfa.amsl.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <151038712425.16073.17226985345922427477.idtracker@ietfa.amsl.com>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/2b8zfUJlxWGpAUnKFpiqNJtDDmw>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] Alissa Cooper's No Objection on draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14: (with COMMENT)
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Sun, 12 Nov 2017 06:30:24 -0000

Thanks, Alissa for approving this!

Cheers
    Toerless

On Fri, Nov 10, 2017 at 11:58:44PM -0800, Alissa Cooper wrote:
> Alissa Cooper has entered the following ballot position for
> draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp-14: No Objection
> 
> When responding, please keep the subject line intact and reply to all
> email addresses included in the To and CC lines. (Feel free to cut this
> introductory paragraph, however.)
> 
> 
> Please refer to https://www.ietf.org/iesg/statement/discuss-criteria.html
> for more information about IESG DISCUSS and COMMENT positions.
> 
> 
> The document, along with other ballot positions, can be found here:
> https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-mboned-interdomain-peering-bcp/
> 
> 
> 
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
> COMMENT:
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
> Thank for addressing my DISCUSS and COMMENTs.


From nobody Mon Nov 13 05:38:01 2017
Return-Path: <tim.chown@jisc.ac.uk>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 4895B1294D2 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 05:37:59 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.32
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.32 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H4=-0.01, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=-0.01, SPF_PASS=-0.001, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=jisc.ac.uk
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 24xnMxSfCThK for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 05:37:57 -0800 (PST)
Received: from eu-smtp-delivery-189.mimecast.com (eu-smtp-delivery-189.mimecast.com [207.82.80.189]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 38465129562 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 05:37:57 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=jisc.ac.uk; s=mimecast20170213; t=1510580275; h=from:subject:date:message-id:to:cc:mime-version:content-type:content-transfer-encoding:in-reply-to:references; bh=NAmqydMjebtoK/uyI86lFd/lxw1d0JTwOYJWMujKRFo=; b=J1FYNQeb3iuiXAtIK6zyotfT753WRlhbbiupXaxO9ycR4BuRRJabXnZUqjg1UJRL7MlMEYcU+jmxPqw0yhHlLaLj8c01mVsBbSbsToNBThL+Rc2YD66/GzXUlizcSL+XS0MPdCfr8Hozn3coLLIUKNbUZIUSvDJyBtd3PtvLMAU=
Received: from EUR01-DB5-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-db5eur01lp0179.outbound.protection.outlook.com [213.199.154.179]) (Using TLS) by eu-smtp-1.mimecast.com with ESMTP id uk-mta-34-UGPICxIOPzKhu7Xoe9zoHw-1; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 13:37:51 +0000
Received: from AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com (10.163.188.14) by AM3PR07MB1137.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com (10.163.188.11) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384_P384) id 15.20.239.4; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 13:37:50 +0000
Received: from AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com ([fe80::d9b7:5aa5:5084:74c2]) by AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com ([fe80::d9b7:5aa5:5084:74c2%13]) with mapi id 15.20.0239.005; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 13:37:50 +0000
From: Tim Chown <Tim.Chown@jisc.ac.uk>
To: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>
CC: MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: I-D Action: draft-acg-mboned-multicast-models-02.txt
Thread-Index: AQHTUdYPqU0dK+jzYE2Aawd+iPMOX6L9H2QAgBBSm4CAAJH84IAEYYqA
Date: Mon, 13 Nov 2017 13:37:50 +0000
Message-ID: <C277749D-6811-4D60-8ECB-E64C1D00D56F@jisc.ac.uk>
References: <150940561832.28310.1470763748333970243@ietfa.amsl.com> <C54D2DC2-6EA7-41D2-BEC2-81A27BC202BF@jisc.ac.uk> <9563781e07234ac7919ecaf64b02073e@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <0AB23114-4E96-4521-834E-E4C1D87991D8@jisc.ac.uk> <96877569f0524339bb7841e8d61736c2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
In-Reply-To: <96877569f0524339bb7841e8d61736c2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com>
Accept-Language: en-GB, en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
x-mailer: Apple Mail (2.3445.4.7)
x-originating-ip: [2001:a88:d510:1101:e565:a751:53f4:fd9a]
x-ms-publictraffictype: Email
x-microsoft-exchange-diagnostics: 1; AM3PR07MB1137; 20:46aHJM9b5ph9uMavnUmBZyipEkrIlA3OzAvcZ0gc2BJbUAKR9q9s5TRVNubCj8wLtCaDKku5HpZJu4Zory2icbq1Qgiq0zXbH7s7yzMJFSrQcOGqJX19HS45na3hWf/3jBmtm4ZU1AMrDsqvnrWqDmA3bAyMCF4NnpSgqB2plig=
x-ms-exchange-antispam-srfa-diagnostics: SSOS;
x-ms-office365-filtering-correlation-id: 064f6728-cfcb-4758-c195-08d52a9bbbdb
x-microsoft-antispam: UriScan:; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(22001)(4534020)(4602075)(4627115)(201703031133081)(201702281549075)(2017052603199); SRVR:AM3PR07MB1137; 
x-ms-traffictypediagnostic: AM3PR07MB1137:
x-microsoft-antispam-prvs: <AM3PR07MB1137A17670A53682A1F13614D62B0@AM3PR07MB1137.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com>
x-exchange-antispam-report-test: UriScan:(274715658323672)(278428928389397)(192374486261705)(39337521807258)(100405760836317);
x-exchange-antispam-report-cfa-test: BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000700101)(100105000095)(100000701101)(100105300095)(100000702101)(100105100095)(6040450)(2401047)(8121501046)(5005006)(3002001)(10201501046)(3231022)(100000703101)(100105400095)(93006095)(93001095)(6041248)(20161123560025)(20161123555025)(20161123558100)(201703131423075)(201702281529075)(201702281528075)(201703061421075)(201703061406153)(20161123562025)(20161123564025)(6072148)(201708071742011)(100000704101)(100105200095)(100000705101)(100105500095); SRVR:AM3PR07MB1137; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000800101)(100110000095)(100000801101)(100110300095)(100000802101)(100110100095)(100000803101)(100110400095)(100000804101)(100110200095)(100000805101)(100110500095); SRVR:AM3PR07MB1137; 
x-forefront-prvs: 0490BBA1F0
x-forefront-antispam-report: SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10009020)(6009001)(346002)(376002)(199003)(51444003)(189002)(13464003)(24454002)(81156014)(53546010)(81166006)(72206003)(76176999)(36756003)(786003)(478600001)(6486002)(99286004)(7736002)(86362001)(106356001)(4326008)(82746002)(316002)(8936002)(5660300001)(83716003)(33656002)(101416001)(93886005)(25786009)(105586002)(14454004)(561944003)(189998001)(8676002)(50986999)(6506006)(6246003)(3660700001)(3280700002)(6436002)(2906002)(8666007)(5250100002)(74482002)(230783001)(2900100001)(229853002)(2950100002)(6116002)(68736007)(102836003)(97736004)(6512007)(305945005)(42882006)(6916009)(50226002)(53936002)(57306001); DIR:OUT; SFP:1101; SCL:1; SRVR:AM3PR07MB1137; H:AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com; FPR:; SPF:None; PTR:InfoNoRecords;  A:1; MX:1; LANG:en; 
spamdiagnosticoutput: 1:99
spamdiagnosticmetadata: NSPM
Content-ID: <BA51E458BBBE5B4DAB86500602A9C1E8@eurprd07.prod.outlook.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-OriginatorOrg: jisc.ac.uk
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: 064f6728-cfcb-4758-c195-08d52a9bbbdb
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-originalarrivaltime: 13 Nov 2017 13:37:50.1894 (UTC)
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-fromentityheader: Hosted
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-id: 48f9394d-8a14-4d27-82a6-f35f12361205
X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: AM3PR07MB1137
X-MC-Unique: UGPICxIOPzKhu7Xoe9zoHw-1
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/QMry3_oL2QwUU0-Nr2JvW2qwvC8>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] I-D Action: draft-acg-mboned-multicast-models-02.txt
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Mon, 13 Nov 2017 13:37:59 -0000
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From nobody Mon Nov 13 11:24:24 2017
Return-Path: <lenny@juniper.net>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 07214129B39 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 11:24:22 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.021
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.021 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE=-0.0001, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H3=-0.01, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=-0.01, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=juniper.net
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id jM2i18nZmP3j for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 11:24:20 -0800 (PST)
Received: from NAM02-CY1-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-cys01nam02on0111.outbound.protection.outlook.com [104.47.37.111]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id B248D129B09 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 11:24:19 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=juniper.net; s=selector1; h=From:Date:Subject:Message-ID:Content-Type:MIME-Version; bh=u2XKqER7+BPOoUAQGWYKsWb5jgJsVc7tExs2T+FSUN0=; b=hrtLkOoT5TbfeQsBZ+Hu5+QF8GSLLj6EfrHyX9OgFCMKj1o8+21bXq4M6yxqaYPtK6Q955KPSNOGOTYr8sjKlS3rjAwPyOwGEeYoKeBkrptOtgB6Jp0jv7Ie8WgNJ0lyt5P+CY4y/qJVID675U/2UqcICagAs7eGo6raZd3SSLo=
Received: from BLUPR05CA0082.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.141.20.52) by BN6PR05MB3601.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.174.234.166) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384_P384) id 15.20.239.4; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 19:24:18 +0000
Received: from BY2NAM05FT015.eop-nam05.prod.protection.outlook.com (2a01:111:f400:7e52::201) by BLUPR05CA0082.outlook.office365.com (2a01:111:e400:855::52) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384) id 15.20.239.4 via Frontend Transport; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 19:24:18 +0000
Received-SPF: SoftFail (protection.outlook.com: domain of transitioning juniper.net discourages use of 66.129.239.15 as permitted sender)
Received: from P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (66.129.239.15) by BY2NAM05FT015.mail.protection.outlook.com (10.152.100.152) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_0, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA_P256) id 15.20.218.12 via Frontend Transport; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 19:24:17 +0000
Received: from svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (172.17.28.215) by P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (172.24.192.21) with Microsoft SMTP Server id 14.3.123.3; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 11:24:16 -0800
Received: by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix, from userid 1709)	id C72749F932; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 11:24:15 -0800 (PST)
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1])	by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix) with ESMTP id C14489F931; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 11:24:15 -0800 (PST)
Date: Mon, 13 Nov 2017 11:24:14 -0800
From: Leonard Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>
To: Tim Chown <Tim.Chown@jisc.ac.uk>
CC: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@boeing.com>, MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>
In-Reply-To: <C277749D-6811-4D60-8ECB-E64C1D00D56F@jisc.ac.uk>
Message-ID: <alpine.DEB.2.02.1711131059100.13000@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net>
References: <150940561832.28310.1470763748333970243@ietfa.amsl.com> <C54D2DC2-6EA7-41D2-BEC2-81A27BC202BF@jisc.ac.uk> <9563781e07234ac7919ecaf64b02073e@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <0AB23114-4E96-4521-834E-E4C1D87991D8@jisc.ac.uk> <96877569f0524339bb7841e8d61736c2@XCH15-06-11.nw.nos.boeing.com> <C277749D-6811-4D60-8ECB-E64C1D00D56F@jisc.ac.uk>
User-Agent: Alpine 2.02 (DEB 1266 2009-07-14)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8BIT
X-EOPAttributedMessage: 0
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-HT: Tenant
X-Forefront-Antispam-Report: CIP:66.129.239.15; IPV:NLI; CTRY:US; EFV:NLI; SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10019020)(6009001)(346002)(376002)(39860400002)(2980300002)(3190300001)(24454002)(189002)(199003)(68736007)(83506002)(8936002)(23676003)(5660300001)(77096006)(86362001)(6916009)(58126008)(54906003)(305945005)(2950100002)(189998001)(7126002)(229853002)(230783001)(316002)(5005980100005)(53936002)(46386002)(93886005)(47776003)(478600001)(45336002)(6246003)(97736004)(76176999)(69596002)(50466002)(90966002)(2810700001)(50986999)(57986006)(8666007)(76506005)(54356999)(8676002)(106466001)(6266002)(81156014)(81166006)(2870700001)(2906002)(105596002)(356003)(4326008)(3240700002)(42262002); DIR:OUT; SFP:1102; SCL:1; SRVR:BN6PR05MB3601; H:P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net; FPR:;  SPF:SoftFail; PTR:InfoDomainNonexistent; MX:1; A:1; LANG:en; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BY2NAM05FT015; 1:qs/7SBYPZsb0pHwH+5LE68WmKhA5bZi/sf85o0A4MpkEWUUxkB4vHd8/rgZ+2NAduCFC1Uh+FSlcjXwaFWJpCqYB2G+lBYXluc9m/T6dYlw7z6IDxjKflmTyo3JxFEuM
X-MS-PublicTrafficType: Email
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-Correlation-Id: bdbc8da2-27e0-433b-6705-08d52acc2256
X-Microsoft-Antispam: UriScan:; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(22001)(4534020)(4602075)(4627115)(201703031133081)(201702281549075)(2017052603258); SRVR:BN6PR05MB3601; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BN6PR05MB3601; 3:XswEdeFy8xi9Zx5HsBaHEglRMCvnO2oJnSPwkisN0nBPRVZD/DSogNkxGeL14TSWfkJ8a4E4qWnuaIs9a1W/SbHRWbbIjQrOhWTbj80utbnKXce6Y8obzuGKHz7Kcw7Ac8isN/150k9h2J4TtR+qj2YLb+PblmmGolhwGyv9yZ2oUe1W82xu/4UJpmVLq97yS61YHXWAGWH+P0rPwg4BPzd6tV37TuoQvtyUAxHyUd0I5/tsOiaFawNw6ZDDxzn5FyBTCgLwSsi1clT9QvWFIZXK6mpnL2G4SsdR+LN0I7vrvsJOJDaloylWFbQ2y3CnPL0oIYYUh3h201VR+Ga0o826ayf85Hl2QZQwUVBHGvU=; 25:bcxfqPnxiafwLMpU2OCtvTJ+S42TCCFD6PCPbxErn6OseHB1kPXnwqq6ZSyOKiuJACsyFf1GsZ9+3v0UnMBOgDT29pQPdGzcYbZq/9xqPlqakp5fk9Vkbu2atulShUv/EaZhjASi3imacCpWr+i1ePHexiFTPN+ommxM71NT2MQeRNUbliQKNsrVH8+ixIVSfPMpr6t+W7+6h6rp9yRBkCfGQj7uDycDrJ7tx/AZoHpiJshajcthjIq2ZaZ4L6lONszJywWTjnR/88lP6HpxUUh1xWtje8StNzQhfjXBvXH+d3aqUkN3CiVW1FxHAveVtEqheg8I11/F6bXjzkiYfA==
X-MS-TrafficTypeDiagnostic: BN6PR05MB3601:
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BN6PR05MB3601; 31:+PeodcSiUPn/5a7hYABSAHKRmrUCjQ1vfIyBiW1YabP0Q1JcaLD0xLaemTJJRe2N0Pi0IRTW5GUO5kMvsfdVVn/w7wZ4o6gRTeanDenQxcVLe5mX4tymyHA1lz7T/y+m3qR5RJTpcN0nHQO42/0/G6x4fRaf60GqqobVlAAfy0a31J2lHJ8O/Opz97EMG9DWbXJ1DxhDcpnI0skABcM13qKJvaVqmkTor2e6TXQ+x6w=; 20: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
X-Microsoft-Antispam-PRVS: <BN6PR05MB3601394BBB2069C126818470A42B0@BN6PR05MB3601.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-Test: UriScan:(278428928389397);
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-CFA-Test: BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000700101)(100105000095)(100000701101)(100105300095)(100000702101)(100105100095)(6040450)(2401047)(5005006)(8121501046)(10201501046)(93006095)(93001095)(100000703101)(100105400095)(3002001)(3231022)(6055026)(6041248)(20161123558100)(201703131423075)(201702281528075)(201703061421075)(201703061406153)(20161123564025)(20161123562025)(20161123560025)(20161123555025)(6072148)(201708071742011)(100000704101)(100105200095)(100000705101)(100105500095); SRVR:BN6PR05MB3601; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000800101)(100110000095)(100000801101)(100110300095)(100000802101)(100110100095)(100000803101)(100110400095)(100000804101)(100110200095)(100000805101)(100110500095); SRVR:BN6PR05MB3601; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BN6PR05MB3601; 4:DDLCC0VAKXZsVqsf1nQgtkzNyb/P5nTU99FU4Ft9ARWD0ctLM5k6KFUkmOFP2N+nmdofIanjjf6MkLshUgTu/IQGYqwwSRpr5x3gu1j3r13QQ5wYzV2V6eB7+AvZTQqB3X99wNJpFoJn5wvhFIvpLmd4mqoHXrQ6xtnPhlKSSn9d8FtUa5J/G+Xn6TZh8V7/qbNOAStXboi+THrcnRowoZc1KmGeqpHnkPLXLEjBLXK59H8oxFKRe07YCLLQ0jv8f9r12JsExAWbaLsxuW/AMSED9XgFgn32E/3V0QJ6LA9o0ZvY0gNg0ib9ck+jkdSD
X-Forefront-PRVS: 0490BBA1F0
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: =?utf-8?B?MTtCTjZQUjA1TUIzNjAxOzIzOktmQTZSYjEraDZFd0NyOVVabWpqeHVZTm16?= =?utf-8?B?ZnRBZ1J4N2I1djl2NndwNlBxUjZuSy9DaWlIaHNkMW8wQTNMRHV0MTZrWi9t?= =?utf-8?B?YkpuWHd6MGdoSisyTGZwc0hzY1o5eTZCcDVBZkliRkV2Ly9mRDY4S3R3UmhE?= =?utf-8?B?VkZ2SnkxUWJJQktYdHBweXNWdVdSdEp3MDN6K1NqZC95SzFHRlQ5aG1wQ1BV?= =?utf-8?B?YVFPRkdBY0o4OWkzRmVlL0xEU0UzUHpQa005WmtQSXloTGozWGdFT2VEL1pl?= =?utf-8?B?ZnE4ckhZSFgxUzBycXczY1FMUW1XZEtTSDlXOTgrSU42dVNCK3hjWThJenNu?= =?utf-8?B?cWZyeWNwR3A2QXM2OUc1bDlkaFFXTjc3VnZaajFQclcwekMzVVU4T2xMNDRj?= =?utf-8?B?cGJmYXA5djc1OXg3YnRLNjEwQi9BYU9KUGhyZEpaMmJKZDRpb3NBaC9sT2M0?= =?utf-8?B?eHFkVWNON2QwcTFWL0lXTHhqbkhDSXBNRUk2ZlZERFF2RFBWc1NhRGtGUWEv?= =?utf-8?B?Mmc0bW9WdDd3amNJOUNiVFl5SHJOUjVTajQ4aWllVW1nSG5EVHdsWTJpV3V1?= =?utf-8?B?UDFLWk1XbE8rUVN1MFRkWks3TUtFVE9jWUgxc09Na3M1ZHhFcTRpMjhLdnZ1?= =?utf-8?B?UmRwYVhwQXZEdXQyUUVPNHUxZXFSWmdBeTFlYVpaeFVTc01Qc25ZZjRrTjUv?= =?utf-8?B?QzFWMFkzY09nSGdYa21yeWI1bHhrMTE2eEo5eVR1QnVCR09wTE1pUlhPNEcz?= =?utf-8?B?TzVEQU1hMGROYUFiakdQcXNaYjlPb0l6SXVOZnBKUURDeFYwcFFaYW50UDRn?= =?utf-8?B?K2JXb2JndnpkT1pWZXFTRXkzdkZsdk8wTTJRNFpsdDE0aWVOQmplZktHa29v?= =?utf-8?B?dERPcGt3ZzdlYjc5ZWpxOTBwYjg0WURQbWNQdlFBZEhhV3kvK3JXWWVDVGFi?= =?utf-8?B?ZnREbHZoQlVUNms0bjFlR0xNQi9jMVFwMUJLSmdNeW1rMVNWeUN2bzRpdGl0?= =?utf-8?B?QzhVRUk1eVZYMUx4clFlZmF3MXV6TS85Z2F3UzNieHVBSG5kSGo3L3krb3cv?= =?utf-8?B?M2dVM3l6ekkvd1BTU2dIRTBxZ2JXT3E4NjgyMTVnK0VwQXBBcmt2WkRzZEVF?= =?utf-8?B?cTNzTjdIdmlTNDBsL1F5QzhUSGRmOW1EL1lzWWNOc29SMmRuMXNaS0JSUUVk?= =?utf-8?B?TUYvd2Fvc08rVm5MUmtubk44L05pbEZGUVVkeDRWVEhnUmFFS1lHZjVzblpo?= =?utf-8?B?MlZHOUlqSG1kM2pPamZRbzV5enZYR1BzM1ZuQ1AveGw2a1hXSEI4WnVkVER1?= =?utf-8?B?eGNpakVVazUyaTBEZW95M3A2dFhYTnFIbkMzbEpJYnA2V2R2THA5bGU5ZzBO?= =?utf-8?B?M05MM0dBSVNiKzNxK3J1VzRGVHRQOWlPT3hRYnJibkQxaEtCY1NhTE5zS2d4?= =?utf-8?B?MVFmMWtnSGVFTGxZUERvbnR0R0wvQmNqUlBaT01GNnM4Yi8xa29nakhqMUxK?= =?utf-8?B?dVRrc0V1eDBlM1NlQW9xUzFmY2ZvVG8wSDNOdEV2NWxBMWlHQUdiaG0vOWR3?= =?utf-8?B?TTlaVmwvbUhaOWNJeXdZRTNPQVJDeVpQZ2ptUVNnU0Y0ektzbHljNVFLWHcx?= =?utf-8?B?bnExNkU3WUZQeE5YQUpzNkxHTXNJWCtUU054UzlSYzBSLzdjeHQyVG5DQ2Ft?= =?utf-8?B?UUdmdFlOSTQ3RENlekVhMlBEK2pDenFjNEEzdG40NjlWT3BCT0xiSThrb1FG?= =?utf-8?B?Sis3cWR1d0VjbTM5VnZRWXRiNkJDQk1aMEVjWnh2ZWZCNkhJYk5oY0ZHazdW?= =?utf-8?B?SVg0VzlrUlFIYzlEMmNPd29lTU1nZlRCRDFIQVlyUEJxeHc9PQ==?=
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BN6PR05MB3601; 6:PNy4HJTQdkJpfpSICwX++Z3tHN8kWmdfNgMwzYgiXf7WzahI7mdpRq/nArxKpy1hsKFPxBDSlOWvAF0w6n7HOrfXB+nWZgUhAxlXOPgx745aaWtp6kRpCwFBEGjLsM55NlRbMPahPUWd1Vk+8YbVuihueZY01hJ518eIGyjjVT6z/0XnhmZ6I9jmBomEs2L470SlHhYXFhGfEe3XxkJa1jZhcUuVLpAth0Fpca6iP2vcrX0jfjgDjF7RIOYj81RQsmQo+gyisohBHwK2v5YrWMbp2T+AARnDwsVR0Ng66hVX1+EXdJa4Dg97MkO9mbv+bTpkQis+tNC4Nt8CCfwNUHjKGE65Jh2XMkrDez03nAI=; 5:Paybta8BSZ3gskA7XPaNPgLb7vzSlfBqGmINt/aS7Ga2OCs4RMKlrDyjkpL1rN2QB1LlQTLthopOvx6pDhdJ81xuDPw5fMp30Am8HO8veJy+snIU39tcHmtk7kvyTarlRsILte0ccyE29oPDoj09IuvADTxM2rmzHuq2IuDYn90=; 24:NTTBOfKOGZHCRVKX6Eg0NXE5g6zKpeYskHmzJA5arMs6VFc6wXVRn2NOJUpcg2viuxgWE76tNdV4AQ/+K7QaqbVRjJWGOSROUzgGEepRhrE=; 7:lCbxQqnPj9oIIStq6RBjvSiPH1c9E9Y/rLUnGHoJSeR6rOk9R4ZfpcojfMB6FSQlN2SDPga+Z+99bAH5k+Yg4sgiDJZBhTIAEZkqTKuHnlHVpdaXG7t6BuoM8K8V9yjNG4GTChoziHuskgRpYUM8Af6lQ34JkHDw3b5X4qZzoEY/bub7ucf3M3danzWTCvO18aw+QvdjzyEckTRRN7FkLmwZ13k+hmoYQLQSsEUOpM8DQUDJgQe4EabG+o4v89HD
SpamDiagnosticOutput: 1:99
SpamDiagnosticMetadata: NSPM
X-OriginatorOrg: juniper.net
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalArrivalTime: 13 Nov 2017 19:24:17.8232 (UTC)
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: bdbc8da2-27e0-433b-6705-08d52acc2256
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Id: bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalAttributedTenantConnectingIp: TenantId=bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4; Ip=[66.129.239.15];  Helo=[P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net]
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-FromEntityHeader: HybridOnPrem
X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: BN6PR05MB3601
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/PukcX46D-iaQ3FKXFISD0TH_aj8>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] I-D Action: draft-acg-mboned-multicast-models-02.txt
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Mon, 13 Nov 2017 19:24:22 -0000

On Mon, 13 Nov 2017, Tim Chown wrote:

| > Hi Tim, thanks. Yes, I'd prefer only to reduce the strength of the recommendation against intradomain ASM. Very simple changes to the text.
| 
| OK, we’ll get a feel for the room in the WG session this week, and take your comment into account.  I won’t be there in person, but Mikael will present the draft.

I think it's important that we don't water down the recommendation so much 
that the message gets lost.  My pref would be to strongly recommend SSM 
(and thus, no-ASM) for interdomain and provide some gentle nudging for SSM 
in intradomain, while recognizing that what one does in his own network is 
his own business.  We can't really mandate/decree, but it is our 
role/responsibility to provide guidance and recommendations based on our 
expertise.

There certainly are use cases for ASM (eg, many-to-many device discovery).  
So we can mention this in the text.  But the fact is that the vast 
majority of mcast apps (interdomain and intradomain) can handle source 
discovery in the app layer.  As an operational WG tasked with providing 
guidance on issues of mcast operation, I think it's very appropriate to 
mention this.  I'm not quite following the concern that the recommendation 
gets in the hands of the "wrong people"- not sure who those wrong people 
are?  IMO, the bigger problem we've always had is that these 
recommendations never got in the hands of the "right people" bc we've 
never come out with clear guidance.  What seems so obvious to all of us in 
the WG never got messaged out well to those outside of this WG.  
Hopefully, we can fix that here.

| >> Well, the point is that source discovery is pushed from the network layer to a
| 
| >> higher layer, simplifying network state, and putting the responsibility on the
| 
| >> applications to communicate about or discover appropriate sources.
| 
| > 
| 
| > I agree that source discovery has been pushed to higher layers, but 
| I'm also concerned about complication being added at those upper layers! 

Agree that moving complexity doesn't eliminate it.  But it's also quite 
true that the application layer provide much greater flexibility for 
innovation, experimentation and scale when it comes to the task of source 
discovery.


From nobody Mon Nov 13 17:58:34 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id E9C661294FA for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 17:58:31 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.199
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.199 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id V1kBzOpVhemw for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 17:58:29 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 2BE97129AC4 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 17:58:24 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id D897A58C55A for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 02:58:19 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id C5817B0D180; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 02:58:19 +0100 (CET)
Date: Tue, 14 Nov 2017 02:58:19 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: mboned@ietf.org
Message-ID: <20171114015819.GE19390@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/cJypGeKOsncliyQScru_YCefZbs>
Subject: [MBONED] Mboned: draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Tue, 14 Nov 2017 01:58:32 -0000

To repeat my statement on the mike in Singapore:

It would be great if the title and abstract of the document could be loosened
up to make it more obvious that the draft can noy only talk about the
problem, but also about existing or possible future workaround or real solutions
as well as possible current BCP - such as increasing minimum bitrate on WiFi APs
for multicast.

Thanks!
    Toerless


From nobody Mon Nov 13 18:42:44 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 1CFB81275C5; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 18:42:43 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -3.092
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-3.092 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, LOCALPART_IN_SUBJECT=1.107, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id yUaEka8uJfZ5; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 18:42:42 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id B403C12726E; Mon, 13 Nov 2017 18:42:37 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id C313D58C55B; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 03:42:33 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id AEEAFB0D181; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 03:42:33 +0100 (CET)
Date: Tue, 14 Nov 2017 03:42:33 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte+ietf@cs.fau.de>
To: bess@ietf.org
Cc: mboned@ietf.org
Message-ID: <20171114024232.GF19390@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/7kqHJbIlfWPLPgUl7_ARNLN92ig>
Subject: [MBONED] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Tue, 14 Nov 2017 02:42:43 -0000

Jeffrey presented subject draft in mboned. Given how i am
not usually tracking BESS WG mailing list and may not be around:

I would like to see subject draft to be adopted as a WG document in BESS
and become an update to RFC6514 (not to say bugfix ;-).

Feeedback detail: The draft should be amended to fix the same problem not only for
MSDP SA but also RFC4610 and probably accordingly change the draft name.

Cross-posted to mboned (sorry) because there where a couple of MBoned
participants expressing support for the draft in BESS and may like me not
be BESS regulars.

Cheers
    Toerless


From nobody Tue Nov 14 13:38:34 2017
Return-Path: <jholland@akamai.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 93DF7129401 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 13:38:32 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.701
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.701 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_LOW=-0.7, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=akamai.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id jgTiIB48RDZC for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 13:38:31 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mx0a-00190b01.pphosted.com (mx0a-00190b01.pphosted.com [IPv6:2620:100:9001:583::1]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id F0C3D127419 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 13:38:30 -0800 (PST)
Received: from pps.filterd (m0122332.ppops.net [127.0.0.1]) by mx0a-00190b01.pphosted.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vAELbT1X006270; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 21:38:23 GMT
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=akamai.com; h=from : to : subject : date : message-id : references : in-reply-to : content-type : content-id : content-transfer-encoding : mime-version; s=jan2016.eng; bh=fB7QBEmErP/1lXA2/+COwgTU7ik/x0EiDDwlJLhvqhY=; b=LuHqIHqxIMImBZtuf52lpfSpTPdFYxcq/FfNXEYauaFrtDDdk9wu02g6Biav/YEG7Eyw teFGiz4WVc2j89/KAUhm0mF8Bl9h+Xtmsxhowi/kre+3PAIuAKsPguOMu9CojvAmbIFo fFPeNSLFjjPvcMZnM/qBC2c9hEYxFqrw3KnU25inc/87pBLzZtwvYs2temuPMzoyfl4C kTSzR9XPUDHFYjev/dZhvQouyhmcMzFwoer1JIxlmZTaMfVwt7wf3qWUtt//6FsGVv3a 9HMbTAhBbsENGw1yMIj3w6Ncokan3lSQdWj6wqqm3M3xwlNlWMv/PF0nfZ8qosi6tDcJ iw== 
Received: from prod-mail-ppoint1 (prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com [184.51.33.18]) by mx0a-00190b01.pphosted.com with ESMTP id 2e7p3yaqjg-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Tue, 14 Nov 2017 21:38:22 +0000
Received: from pps.filterd (prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com [127.0.0.1]) by prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vAELVPuQ013973; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 16:38:21 -0500
Received: from email.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.32]) by prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com with ESMTP id 2e7p3wjx6d-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Tue, 14 Nov 2017 16:38:21 -0500
Received: from USMA1EX-DAG1MB4.msg.corp.akamai.com (172.27.123.104) by usma1ex-dag1mb3.msg.corp.akamai.com (172.27.123.103) with Microsoft SMTP Server (TLS) id 15.0.1263.5; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 16:38:20 -0500
Received: from USMA1EX-DAG1MB4.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.104]) by usma1ex-dag1mb4.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.104]) with mapi id 15.00.1263.000; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 16:38:20 -0500
From: "Holland, Jake" <jholland@akamai.com>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: [MBONED] Mboned: draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement
Thread-Index: AQHTXOwxyseuRBF9m0qUJ24eihYeBqMUu7+A
Date: Tue, 14 Nov 2017 21:38:20 +0000
Message-ID: <DAAAC4DE-23CE-4D3C-A063-FD87C7A43E99@akamai.com>
References: <20171114015819.GE19390@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
In-Reply-To: <20171114015819.GE19390@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
Accept-Language: en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
user-agent: Microsoft-MacOutlook/f.27.0.171010
x-ms-exchange-messagesentrepresentingtype: 1
x-ms-exchange-transport-fromentityheader: Hosted
x-originating-ip: [172.19.118.182]
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-ID: <1774E819CAFC2A4AA53B45BADBA79AD8@akamai.com>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-14_10:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 spamscore=0 suspectscore=0 malwarescore=0 phishscore=0 adultscore=0 bulkscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1709140000 definitions=main-1711140287
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-14_11:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 priorityscore=1501 malwarescore=0 suspectscore=0 phishscore=0 bulkscore=0 spamscore=0 clxscore=1011 lowpriorityscore=0 impostorscore=0 adultscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1709140000 definitions=main-1711140288
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/UjUwsQLbjnUFTzsv1SUk7Z29JWQ>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] Mboned: draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Tue, 14 Nov 2017 21:38:32 -0000
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From nobody Tue Nov 14 18:38:07 2017
Return-Path: <joelja@bogus.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id CEABB127010; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 18:37:59 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -6.899
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-6.899 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_HI=-5, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id ztDqckcc1Pls; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 18:37:58 -0800 (PST)
Received: from nagasaki.bogus.com (nagasaki.bogus.com [IPv6:2001:418:1::81]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id E71271201F2; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 18:37:51 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mb.local ([IPv6:2001:67c:370:1998:78fa:30c8:8d1d:2a52]) (authenticated bits=0) by nagasaki.bogus.com (8.15.2/8.15.2) with ESMTPSA id vAF2blHs039040 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 bits=128 verify=NOT); Wed, 15 Nov 2017 02:37:49 GMT (envelope-from joelja@bogus.com)
X-Authentication-Warning: nagasaki.bogus.com: Host [IPv6:2001:67c:370:1998:78fa:30c8:8d1d:2a52] claimed to be mb.local
From: joel jaeggli <joelja@bogus.com>
To: draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement@ietf.org, draft-perkins-intarea-multicast-ieee802@ietf.org, Internet Area <int-area@ietf.org>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <8140d9e4-b322-7f39-a37c-a96ab7283ffe@bogus.com>
Date: Wed, 15 Nov 2017 10:36:59 +0800
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10.13; rv:56.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/56.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Language: en-US
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/04NLYfKGX86YzbpHt6FPKQf_1Xs>
Subject: [MBONED] review of draft-perkins-intarea-multicast-ieee802-03 draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement-01
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 15 Nov 2017 02:38:00 -0000

Greetings,

I have chosen to review both of these documents at this time as they
appear to me to be attempts to address the same problem space from the
vantage point of slightly different but overlapping communities
(evidenced by the authors) both of which have a vested interest in IP
multicast operation on ieee 802.xx wireless networks. This review is
seperated into the observations common to both followed by (limited)
commentary on each document.

While both documents address the challenges of arp / ND and aperiodic
multicast transmission,
draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement-01 has more focus on
application use of multicast above and beyond basic
subnet/adjacency/resource discovery applications.

draft-perkins-intarea-multicast-ieee802-03 takes a more technical and
nuanced look at the underlying 802.xx implementation of
multicast/broadcast packet transmission. It is oddly specific in some
areas to experiences gleaned from the IETF network, which while it may
be a product of our experience, is  by no means a unique environment,
and these challenges are to a great degree common or in fact worse  in
other wireless environments (where there might be more low powered
devices, less spectrum or radio coordination, a diversity of management
domains and so on.

it's  not clear to me from the outset what the audience for an
eventually published document might be.

	Advice to implementors?

	Feedback to the IEEE?

	Operational advice?

	Go from problem statment towards work on conclusions?

draft-perkins-intarea-multicast-ieee802-03  is the slightly more mature
document of the two,  I don't think that there is much justification for
advancing both given that they have fairly high overlap without being
complimentary, so I would encourage consolidation and coordination
between the int interests and those of the mbone/multicast community
towards something that is more than the union of the two.

>From my vantage-point the best outcome is one where the IETF provides
advice to vendors (becaue there are implementation specific tweaks and
optimation that can make many situations better) an the IEEE that
results in the employment of multicast being less disruptive and costly
and potentially to devices on wireless lans. work on ietf protocols
associated with arp/nd resource discovery to make them generally less
costly on the wire and more sensitive to power / cpu usage is a
desirable property as well pariticularly  of there are situations where
they can be avoided entirely (for example not having to defend addresses
via DAD because of something like
https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-v6ops-unique-ipv6-prefix-per-host-13).


Some comments specific to each document

- draft-perkins-intarea-multicast-ieee802-03 -

   	3.1.2.  Lower Data Rate

   	this rate might be as low as 6 Mbps, when
   	some unicast links in the same cell can be operating at rates up to
   	600 Mbps.

In fact backward compatibility and  multi-stream implementations mean
that the maximum unicast rates are currently up to a few Gb/s so there
can be a more than 3 order of magnitude difference in the transmission
rate from the basic rates to optimal unicast forwarding. some techinues
employed to increase spectral efficiency such a spatial multiplexing in
mimo systems are literally unavailable with more then one intended
reciever so it's not simply the case that nominal transmission rates
available are limited by backwards compatibility.

	3.2.2. IPv6 issues

Respecting some of the cost of multicast on wireless networks these are
not strictly wireless problems reductions in the amount of signaling
required is better for the control-planes of routers, and for all hosts
ultimately, whether that is unicast RAs, prefix per host, or simply rate
limits on layer 2 learning e.g. https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6583
problems. 3.2.4 and 3.2.2 therefore are very much problems that extend
beyond the wireless domain.

Specifically with 3.2.4 the arp problem also applies to ND, in both
cases non-standard counter-measures (arp sponging unlearned entries as
in 5.1 for v4) various forms of off-net vs on-net driven ND suppression.

	On a wired network, there is not a huge difference amongst unicast,
	multicast and broadcast traffic;

Inadvertent flooded traffic or high amounts of ethernet multicast on
wired networks can be quite a bit less costly due to nic filtering, then
in cases where devices have to wake up effectively to process packets.
also the fact that these networks tend to be switched futher reduces
impact (there is effectively no collision / scheduling problem until you
get to extremely high port utilization)

	4.3

not clear how this directly impacts multicast / except that a unicast
optimization ight seperately send to different STAs at different times.
optimization around long DTIM intervals to allow clients to sleep longer
clearly has impacts on performance, convergence time and how uch needs
to be sent which the device wakes up.

	4.6

	DMS is not currently implemented in products.

work on and review of DMS
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7969670/?reload=true
http://eprints.networks.imdea.org/524/1/video_v01.pdf

	5.1

barely deals with ipv6, even though the problems are essntially the same.


- draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement-01 -

	1.

	And many end devices are increasingly using
	wifi for their connectivity.

it's not really that this is a new and increasing alternative to wired
connectivity. there's no serious or common alternative to wirless 802.x
network usage.

 	One of the primary problems multicast
   	over wifi faces is that link local 802.11 doesn't necessarily support
   	multicast, it supports broadcast.

This is a possibly necessarily simplification, there are not naturally
great mechanisms within a common collision domain to limit reciever
membership so even the ability to limit membersship to recievers that
are part of the reciept naturally makes the air interface unavailable
for a time.

	4.
   	Apple's Bonjour protocol, for instance, provides service discovery
   	(for printing)

mdns service discovery covers a great deal of (and increasing number) of
diverse services. most of them are more or less invisible to users, e.g.
they're not aware that they re using a service discovering mechanism, or
that autonomous deivces are using them irespective of user input.


From nobody Tue Nov 14 22:54:30 2017
Return-Path: <joelja@bogus.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id C7E6A1274D0 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 22:54:28 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -6.899
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-6.899 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_HI=-5, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 6eikDGv0jDtz for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 22:54:27 -0800 (PST)
Received: from nagasaki.bogus.com (nagasaki.bogus.com [IPv6:2001:418:1::81]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 561261270A0 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Tue, 14 Nov 2017 22:54:27 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mb.local ([IPv6:2001:67c:370:1998:99ab:a1e3:5eff:84c9]) (authenticated bits=0) by nagasaki.bogus.com (8.15.2/8.15.2) with ESMTPSA id vAF6sO29041210 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 bits=128 verify=NOT) for <mboned@ietf.org>; Wed, 15 Nov 2017 06:54:26 GMT (envelope-from joelja@bogus.com)
X-Authentication-Warning: nagasaki.bogus.com: Host [IPv6:2001:67c:370:1998:99ab:a1e3:5eff:84c9] claimed to be mb.local
To: "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
From: joel jaeggli <joelja@bogus.com>
Message-ID: <0299a7d7-bd86-0a0e-fd49-a80fb8440539@bogus.com>
Date: Wed, 15 Nov 2017 14:53:30 +0800
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10.13; rv:56.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/56.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Language: en-US
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/9lbfL7pSNALgF9vgRjNBHYc6bPU>
Subject: [MBONED] draft-ietf-tsvwg-rfc6040update-shim-05 - implications for AMT.
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 15 Nov 2017 06:54:29 -0000

Hi,

I would call the attention of the working group to AMT tunnel
negotiation changes proposed in:

https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rfc6040update-shim-05

in particular

https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-tsvwg-rfc6040update-shim-05#section-5.1.4

this might be something that you want to comment on.

joel


From nobody Thu Nov 16 08:57:54 2017
Return-Path: <jholland@akamai.com>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id B3BFA1296CD for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Thu, 16 Nov 2017 08:57:52 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.001
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.001 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, SPF_PASS=-0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=akamai.com
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id JwEtPK_nuaUR for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Thu, 16 Nov 2017 08:57:50 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mx0b-00190b01.pphosted.com (mx0b-00190b01.pphosted.com [IPv6:2620:100:9005:57f::1]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id AC57B1296B0 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Thu, 16 Nov 2017 08:57:50 -0800 (PST)
Received: from pps.filterd (m0050102.ppops.net [127.0.0.1]) by mx0b-00190b01.pphosted.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vAGGs1Zn032693; Thu, 16 Nov 2017 16:57:46 GMT
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=akamai.com; h=from : to : subject : date : message-id : references : in-reply-to : content-type : content-id : content-transfer-encoding : mime-version; s=jan2016.eng; bh=oBDW2G+JDFEB4vKQbNorI/qROlvr5oq3/PNfQcrdf5M=; b=OUWVZJKSY2eWa3ExTGMmIWsiSnnfEkbSSc0WwJidSFSy7LpqaBAnkRRvyRsFXK7QInZ6 odh3pSExUUnpUncBYTJ4iiXSC+1Hhl0H6LoMC3XVbdb+fwqUjQuLLfQwr1o70VEFpunv cc2tzsWOPh393s6bBTJNDmikFhoZr/n4GUwM/xyAJRDtaIRwgpxe2RoyMM8+JXvhn1e5 15qfl3nvH3kgEuSQ+O7eNDwSBjxEj7tBJ4itnbNzStXumWFZE8JkZ9vY3H1oS+xs/x7k z4xruHcSw2kCYi1lX6hVpPo29FrqwgdF2NJf4SfPok+7XPMHTVTFEYj+c96ioOuNplMI iw== 
Received: from prod-mail-ppoint1 (prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com [184.51.33.18]) by m0050102.ppops.net-00190b01. with ESMTP id 2e8d5654gm-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Thu, 16 Nov 2017 16:57:45 +0000
Received: from pps.filterd (prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com [127.0.0.1]) by prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vAGGqNM9030704; Thu, 16 Nov 2017 11:57:44 -0500
Received: from email.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.31]) by prod-mail-ppoint1.akamai.com with ESMTP id 2e7p3wt7ab-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Thu, 16 Nov 2017 11:57:44 -0500
Received: from USMA1EX-DAG1MB4.msg.corp.akamai.com (172.27.123.104) by usma1ex-dag1mb6.msg.corp.akamai.com (172.27.123.65) with Microsoft SMTP Server (TLS) id 15.0.1263.5; Thu, 16 Nov 2017 11:57:44 -0500
Received: from USMA1EX-DAG1MB4.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.104]) by usma1ex-dag1mb4.msg.corp.akamai.com ([172.27.123.104]) with mapi id 15.00.1263.000; Thu, 16 Nov 2017 11:57:44 -0500
From: "Holland, Jake" <jholland@akamai.com>
To: joel jaeggli <joelja@bogus.com>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: [MBONED] draft-ietf-tsvwg-rfc6040update-shim-05 - implications for AMT.
Thread-Index: AQHTXd6Xb7Pos99e4UKEg6lPRqJ2nqMXkBwA
Date: Thu, 16 Nov 2017 16:57:43 +0000
Message-ID: <3F35C34C-6A59-451E-A69F-4C3CF35FB36F@akamai.com>
References: <0299a7d7-bd86-0a0e-fd49-a80fb8440539@bogus.com>
In-Reply-To: <0299a7d7-bd86-0a0e-fd49-a80fb8440539@bogus.com>
Accept-Language: en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
user-agent: Microsoft-MacOutlook/f.27.0.171010
x-ms-exchange-messagesentrepresentingtype: 1
x-ms-exchange-transport-fromentityheader: Hosted
x-originating-ip: [172.19.119.128]
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-ID: <0FC6128B0C8BF342B84E2C3B2186BB43@akamai.com>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-16_06:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 spamscore=0 suspectscore=0 malwarescore=0 phishscore=0 adultscore=0 bulkscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1709140000 definitions=main-1711160226
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-16_06:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 priorityscore=1501 malwarescore=0 suspectscore=0 phishscore=0 bulkscore=0 spamscore=0 clxscore=1011 lowpriorityscore=0 impostorscore=0 adultscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1709140000 definitions=main-1711160226
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/K8oPNv0tJxhv6LjilUIdca2r6Os>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] draft-ietf-tsvwg-rfc6040update-shim-05 - implications for AMT.
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 16 Nov 2017 16:57:53 -0000

SGkgSm9lbCwNCg0KSSBzdWdnZXN0ZWQgdG8gQm9iIGluY2x1ZGluZyBBTVQgaW4gdGhlIDYwNDAg
dXBkYXRlLg0KDQpJ4oCZbSBub3QgdXNpbmcgaXQgeWV0LCBidXQgSSB0aGluayBFQ04gd291bGQg
YmUgYSB1c2VmdWwgc2lnbmFsLCBhbmQgaXQgd291bGQgYWRkaXRpb25hbGx5IGJlIHVzZWZ1bCB0
byBiZSBhYmxlIHRvIHByb3BhZ2F0ZSBpdCB0aHJvdWdoIEFNVCB0dW5uZWxzLg0KDQpUaGUgbmV3
IHByb3Bvc2VkIEVDTi1jYXBhYmlsaXR5IGFkdmVydGlzZW1lbnQgZm9yIEFNVCBpcyBhIDEtd2F5
IGFkdmVydGlzZW1lbnQsIHNpbmNlIHRoZSBkYXRhIHBhY2tldHMgYXJlIGEgMS13YXkgZmxvdywg
YW5kIGl0IGdvZXMgaW4gdGhlIFJlcXVlc3QgbWVzc2FnZSBzbyB0aGUgcmVsYXkgd2lsbCBnZXQg
aXQuIEJvYiBoYWQgb3JpZ2luYWxseSBzdWdnZXN0ZWQgdGhlIFJlbGF5IERpc2NvdmVyeSBtZXNz
YWdlLCBidXQgSSBhc2tlZCB0byBtb3ZlIGl0IHRvIHRoZSBSZXF1ZXN0IG1lc3NhZ2UgYmVjYXVz
ZSB0aGUgUmVsYXkgRGlzY292ZXJ5IHdvbuKAmXQgYWx3YXlzIGdvIHRvIHRoZSByZWxheSB0aGF0
IGZvcndhcmRzIHRoZSBkYXRhLg0KDQpUaGUgcmVsYXkgd2lsbCBpZ25vcmUgdGhlIGJpdCBpZiBp
dCBkb2VzbuKAmXQgdW5kZXJzdGFuZCBpdCwgd2hpY2ggKGNvcnJlY3RseSkgcmVzdWx0cyBpbiB1
c2luZyBub24tRUNUIG9uIHRoZSBvdXRlciBJUCBhbmQgbGVhdmluZyB0aGUgaW5uZXIgSVAgdW5t
b2RpZmllZCwgYnV0IHdoZW4gdGhlIGdhdGV3YXkgYWR2ZXJ0aXNlcyBzdXBwb3J0IHdpdGggdGhl
IG5ldyBFLWJpdCBhbmQgdGhlIHJlbGF5IHVuZGVyc3RhbmRzIGl0LCB0aGUgNjA0MC1iaXMgYmVo
YXZpb3IgaXMgdXNlZCBpbnN0ZWFkLCB3aGljaCB3aWxsIHByb3BhZ2F0ZSB0aGUgRUNUIGZyb20g
dGhlIGlubmVyIElQIHRvIHRoZSBvdXRlciB3cmFwcGVyIGF0IHRoZSBSZWxheSBhbmQgcHJvcGFn
YXRlIG5ldyBDRSBzaWduYWxzIGZyb20gdGhlIG91dGVyIElQIHRvIHRoZSBmb3J3YXJkZWQgZGF0
YSBwYWNrZXRzIGluIHRoZSBHYXRld2F5Lg0KDQpJIGhvcGUgd2l0aGluIGEgZmV3IHllYXJzIHRv
IHVzZSB0aG9zZSBDRSBzaWduYWxzIHRvIGhlbHAgd2l0aCBtYWtpbmcgQUJSIGRlY2lzaW9ucy4N
Cg0KVGhlIHF1ZXN0aW9uIG9mIGhvdyB0byBzYWZlbHkgaW5jbHVkZSBFQ1QgaW4gdGhlIDEtd2F5
IG11bHRpY2FzdCBkYXRhIGZsb3dzIGluIHRoZSBmaXJzdCBwbGFjZSBpcyBub3QgbmVjZXNzYXJp
bHkgb2J2aW91c+KAlEnigJltIHRoaW5raW5nIG1vc3QgbGlrZWx5IHdoZW4gSSB0cnkgdGhpcyBJ
4oCZbGwgcnVuIDIgZGlmZmVyZW50IGNoYW5uZWxzLCBvbmUgbWFya2VkIHdpdGggRUNUKDApIGFu
ZCBvbmUgd2l0aG91dCAoYW5kIHBvc3NpYmx5IGFub3RoZXIgb25lIGZvciBFQ1QoMSkgZXZlbnR1
YWxseSwgZGVwZW5kaW5nIGhvdyB0aGUgTDRTIGV4cGVyaW1lbnRzIGdvKSwgYW5kIHRoZSBleHBl
Y3RlZCBtYXJraW5nIGZvciB0aGUgY2hhbm5lbCB3aWxsIGJlIGtub3duIGJ5IHRoZSBjbGllbnQg
YXMgcGFydCBvZiB0aGUgYXBwbGljYXRpb24tbGF5ZXIgZmxvdyBkaXNjb3ZlcnksIGFuZCBvbmx5
IHRoZSByZWNlaXZlcnMgdGhhdCBrbm93IGhvdyB0byByZXNwb25kIHRvIENFIHdpbGwgam9pbiB0
aGUgRUNUIGZsb3dzLg0KDQpUaGFua3MgZm9yIHNlbmRpbmcgdG8gbWJvbmVkLCB0aGF04oCZcyBh
IGdvb2QgaWRlYSB0aGF0IHByb2JhYmx5IHNob3VsZCBoYXZlIG9jY3VycmVkIHRvIG1lLg0KDQpS
ZWdhcmRzLA0KSmFrZQ0KDQpPbiAxMS8xNC8xNywgMTA6NTQgUE0sICJqb2VsIGphZWdnbGkiIDxq
b2VsamFAYm9ndXMuY29tPiB3cm90ZToNCg0KSGksDQoNCkkgd291bGQgY2FsbCB0aGUgYXR0ZW50
aW9uIG9mIHRoZSB3b3JraW5nIGdyb3VwIHRvIEFNVCB0dW5uZWwNCm5lZ290aWF0aW9uIGNoYW5n
ZXMgcHJvcG9zZWQgaW46DQoNCmh0dHBzOi8vdG9vbHMuaWV0Zi5vcmcvaHRtbC9kcmFmdC1pZXRm
LXRzdndnLXJmYzYwNDB1cGRhdGUtc2hpbS0wNQ0KDQppbiBwYXJ0aWN1bGFyDQoNCmh0dHBzOi8v
dG9vbHMuaWV0Zi5vcmcvaHRtbC9kcmFmdC1pZXRmLXRzdndnLXJmYzYwNDB1cGRhdGUtc2hpbS0w
NSNzZWN0aW9uLTUuMS40DQoNCnRoaXMgbWlnaHQgYmUgc29tZXRoaW5nIHRoYXQgeW91IHdhbnQg
dG8gY29tbWVudCBvbi4NCg0Kam9lbA0KDQpfX19fX19fX19fX19fX19fX19fX19fX19fX19fX19f
X19fX19fX19fX19fX19fXw0KTUJPTkVEIG1haWxpbmcgbGlzdA0KTUJPTkVEQGlldGYub3JnDQpo
dHRwczovL3d3dy5pZXRmLm9yZy9tYWlsbWFuL2xpc3RpbmZvL21ib25lZA0KDQoNCg==


From nobody Fri Nov 17 08:33:01 2017
Return-Path: <tim.chown@jisc.ac.uk>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 082DB12896F for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 08:33:00 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.32
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.32 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_H4=-0.01, RCVD_IN_MSPIKE_WL=-0.01, SPF_PASS=-0.001, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.d=jisc.ac.uk
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id RDAjKUZ5Zd9d for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 08:32:57 -0800 (PST)
Received: from eu-smtp-delivery-189.mimecast.com (eu-smtp-delivery-189.mimecast.com [207.82.80.189]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id E4F541243FE for <mboned@ietf.org>; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 08:32:56 -0800 (PST)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=jisc.ac.uk; s=mimecast20170213; t=1510936375; h=from:subject:date:message-id:to:cc:mime-version:content-type:content-transfer-encoding:in-reply-to:references; bh=UtJZVTR6vzDk4ejY5OXrwiL+3pyyOVWXm/5hc2pmjFc=; b=K9lT75uHxBbRwtfqfHeYvzxabbVhbtA3KHiQbW0NVhbU0EfPjcpBbRq5KvhtF4ZjSFQDu1mrL+qYfMK6itIn5nI7xpbm00HmXkKzMU6tjiC3rVpo2c2GWKslWkXroH4IRefweRkYDCl8BHxK2CZBufGXINjxJl2DOsYce1bpwqk=
Received: from EUR01-DB5-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-db5eur01lp0180.outbound.protection.outlook.com [213.199.154.180]) (Using TLS) by eu-smtp-1.mimecast.com with ESMTP id uk-mta-94-Ba8rOleoO_qsAq0yiM93dw-1; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 16:32:53 +0000
Received: from AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com (10.163.188.14) by AM3PR07MB1138.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com (10.163.188.12) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384_P256) id 15.20.260.2; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 16:32:51 +0000
Received: from AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com ([fe80::d9b7:5aa5:5084:74c2]) by AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com ([fe80::d9b7:5aa5:5084:74c2%13]) with mapi id 15.20.0260.001; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 16:32:51 +0000
From: Tim Chown <Tim.Chown@jisc.ac.uk>
To: "Holland, Jake" <jholland@akamai.com>
CC: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>, "mboned@ietf.org" <mboned@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: [MBONED] Mboned: draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement
Thread-Index: AQHTXOw1h5z9Zspwk0qYxBmAv/s7z6MUZ+4AgARhpAA=
Date: Fri, 17 Nov 2017 16:32:51 +0000
Message-ID: <E8C306D8-AC28-4DEB-9340-B1C3552D2311@jisc.ac.uk>
References: <20171114015819.GE19390@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <DAAAC4DE-23CE-4D3C-A063-FD87C7A43E99@akamai.com>
In-Reply-To: <DAAAC4DE-23CE-4D3C-A063-FD87C7A43E99@akamai.com>
Accept-Language: en-GB, en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
x-mailer: Apple Mail (2.3445.4.7)
x-originating-ip: [2001:a88:d510:1101:291b:568f:8b2c:9a0]
x-ms-publictraffictype: Email
x-microsoft-exchange-diagnostics: 1; AM3PR07MB1138; 20:rgmIf3mlqPWRhvfLTzxSeQXuhMzyVm+wrXyjXJWGtYKIB0yeiuOZrIE+u3Z3kvY3PT/S1UjYRGHxOHEv378jBBaLsenW/4nmlGU9SMTbVj5MMUu1x2NQDRH3Lwx27+IdT7O59qOfmnRMcuOqfcHgaSlKLQCzHkyMlDhO4AS6Tkw=
x-ms-exchange-antispam-srfa-diagnostics: SSOS;
x-ms-office365-filtering-correlation-id: 2311bce8-3ce8-439b-30e2-08d52dd8d8e4
x-microsoft-antispam: UriScan:; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(22001)(4534020)(4602075)(4627115)(201703031133081)(201702281549075)(2017052603258); SRVR:AM3PR07MB1138; 
x-ms-traffictypediagnostic: AM3PR07MB1138:
x-microsoft-antispam-prvs: <AM3PR07MB11385BD086B4428F154B11DCD62F0@AM3PR07MB1138.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com>
x-exchange-antispam-report-test: UriScan:(120809045254105);
x-exchange-antispam-report-cfa-test: BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000700101)(100105000095)(100000701101)(100105300095)(100000702101)(100105100095)(6040450)(2401047)(8121501046)(5005006)(3231022)(10201501046)(100000703101)(100105400095)(3002001)(93006095)(93001095)(6041248)(20161123558100)(20161123555025)(201703131423075)(201702281529075)(201702281528075)(201703061421075)(201703061406153)(20161123560025)(20161123562025)(20161123564025)(6072148)(201708071742011)(100000704101)(100105200095)(100000705101)(100105500095); SRVR:AM3PR07MB1138; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000800101)(100110000095)(100000801101)(100110300095)(100000802101)(100110100095)(100000803101)(100110400095)(100000804101)(100110200095)(100000805101)(100110500095); SRVR:AM3PR07MB1138; 
x-forefront-prvs: 049486C505
x-forefront-antispam-report: SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10009020)(6009001)(376002)(346002)(199003)(24454002)(51444003)(51694002)(189002)(6306002)(6512007)(230783001)(6246003)(5250100002)(33656002)(42882006)(2950100002)(53936002)(2906002)(99286004)(97736004)(6916009)(14454004)(3660700001)(5660300001)(57306001)(68736007)(72206003)(36756003)(6436002)(966005)(3280700002)(82746002)(478600001)(53546010)(4326008)(229853002)(101416001)(25786009)(2900100001)(6506006)(6486002)(50986999)(76176999)(83716003)(8936002)(8676002)(74482002)(86362001)(81166006)(81156014)(189998001)(54906003)(786003)(106356001)(105586002)(305945005)(50226002)(6116002)(102836003)(7736002)(316002); DIR:OUT; SFP:1101; SCL:1; SRVR:AM3PR07MB1138; H:AM3PR07MB1140.eurprd07.prod.outlook.com; FPR:; SPF:None; PTR:InfoNoRecords;  A:1; MX:1; LANG:en; 
spamdiagnosticoutput: 1:99
spamdiagnosticmetadata: NSPM
Content-ID: <13D9ED50B7446847A1367E51284D6E2F@eurprd07.prod.outlook.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-OriginatorOrg: jisc.ac.uk
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: 2311bce8-3ce8-439b-30e2-08d52dd8d8e4
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-originalarrivaltime: 17 Nov 2017 16:32:51.7031 (UTC)
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-fromentityheader: Hosted
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-id: 48f9394d-8a14-4d27-82a6-f35f12361205
X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: AM3PR07MB1138
X-MC-Unique: Ba8rOleoO_qsAq0yiM93dw-1
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/Hrt_MBB2UhNeuZ0NgwoPT6zPLvI>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] Mboned: draft-mcbride-mboned-wifi-mcast-problem-statement
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 17 Nov 2017 16:33:00 -0000
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==


From nobody Fri Nov 17 13:22:12 2017
Return-Path: <lenny@juniper.net>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id BB302124B17 for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 13:22:10 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9,  DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, SPF_PASS=-0.001,  URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=juniper.net
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 72ME9wV3UhKs for <mboned@ietfa.amsl.com>; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 13:22:08 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mx0b-00273201.pphosted.com (mx0b-00273201.pphosted.com [67.231.152.164]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 56C611200B9 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 13:22:08 -0800 (PST)
Received: from pps.filterd (m0108162.ppops.net [127.0.0.1]) by mx0b-00273201.pphosted.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vAHLJHRu031100 for <mboned@ietf.org>; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 13:22:06 -0800
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=juniper.net; h=date : from : to : subject : message-id : mime-version : content-type; s=PPS1017; bh=imK4cfOXjx0YPHOeRKGGpca9uRNC6f/8P9efsN6EpnY=; b=m4yxuCAy4khPUH2lB8j7Sl9sbki2kaQbDSb3kCEWqOYA0D7n0an+arBHrC3ETDDaKp2F EJnz1vkws9tDBLx88AcTizJx5+M2naVA3B8jEgH9WWkQRhP399jhuevvRRtkGFvXgcKI /z1kDnwogxOAxCxy4V8ZP88PnDY2Io4SomyFKXM+KgRYNbIqmHGH3CvenzqfeBlO1hIQ DlnXlweOlqH5AKnEmKa4abb9c4DUHmGAeXOxOUGJZwAo0mmOX8YyuOUPxp7RlgSD1o2J TfeuV7ydBBaKkHrZodUsckKazcn/ShQ5y2+KL2bpAZodT2PgbOLy76vUo7H/n0WbaEkO kg== 
Received: from nam02-bl2-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-bl2nam02lp0082.outbound.protection.outlook.com [207.46.163.82]) by mx0b-00273201.pphosted.com with ESMTP id 2ea6p6g4a6-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT) for <mboned@ietf.org>; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 13:22:05 -0800
Received: from CO2PR05CA0006.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.166.88.144) by BN6PR05MB3604.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.174.235.12) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384_P256) id 15.20.260.2; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 21:21:55 +0000
Received: from BY2NAM05FT029.eop-nam05.prod.protection.outlook.com (2a01:111:f400:7e52::206) by CO2PR05CA0006.outlook.office365.com (2603:10b6:102:2::16) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384) id 15.20.239.4 via Frontend Transport; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 21:21:54 +0000
Received-SPF: SoftFail (protection.outlook.com: domain of transitioning juniper.net discourages use of 66.129.239.15 as permitted sender)
Received: from P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (66.129.239.15) by BY2NAM05FT029.mail.protection.outlook.com (10.152.100.166) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_0, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA_P256) id 15.20.239.4 via Frontend Transport; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 21:21:54 +0000
Received: from svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (172.17.28.215) by P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (172.24.192.21) with Microsoft SMTP Server id 14.3.123.3; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 13:21:47 -0800
Received: by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix, from userid 1709)	id 98D0D9F954; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 13:21:46 -0800 (PST)
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1])	by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix) with ESMTP id 925C09F951	for <mboned@ietf.org>; Fri, 17 Nov 2017 13:21:46 -0800 (PST)
Date: Fri, 17 Nov 2017 13:21:46 -0800
From: Leonard Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>
To: MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <alpine.DEB.2.02.1711171320420.13629@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net>
User-Agent: Alpine 2.02 (DEB 1266 2009-07-14)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; format=flowed; charset="US-ASCII"
X-EOPAttributedMessage: 0
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-HT: Tenant
X-Forefront-Antispam-Report: CIP:66.129.239.15; IPV:NLI; CTRY:US; EFV:NLI; SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10019020)(6009001)(346002)(39860400002)(376002)(2980300002)(199003)(189002)(8676002)(50986999)(23726003)(68736007)(6266002)(2906002)(5005980100005)(54356999)(3480700004)(6916009)(3240700002)(69596002)(67846002)(356003)(8936002)(2810700001)(478600001)(45336002)(90966002)(47776003)(50466002)(58126008)(558084003)(189998001)(46386002)(57986006)(6306002)(77096006)(76506005)(83506002)(7126002)(316002)(966005)(106466001)(81166006)(53936002)(86362001)(16586007)(105596002)(81156014)(97736004)(305945005)(5660300001)(42262002); DIR:OUT; SFP:1102; SCL:1; SRVR:BN6PR05MB3604; H:P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net; FPR:;  SPF:SoftFail; PTR:InfoDomainNonexistent; A:1; MX:1; LANG:en; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BY2NAM05FT029; 1:rWYYUQ1lM6M4jNd3Ne2z0TZMIr/ZCgHvGtq9cfUrmqiQcAAxJL/HtycsvjdaSDr5mQoMxmKq6w+Ko7SdrDDGGMl6Z/rvkwJNDqItLnaPn4CJcQte4D7IcvIQN0/SuQOU
X-MS-PublicTrafficType: Email
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-Correlation-Id: faf5209c-d5e1-46ea-9e54-08d52e013a11
X-Microsoft-Antispam: UriScan:; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(22001)(4534020)(4602075)(4627115)(201703031133081)(201702281549075)(2017052603199); SRVR:BN6PR05MB3604; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BN6PR05MB3604; 3:ptNz0zRMqy+oHGT0mhqEEmzO/hnK2rXqCw6JKtUup/ikwj3mTIp9MDyU9R+kr8nu0OWpyeLwpl3Zpbg81lWWyLOvexSCikvKNHQTbbtsLMHK93ZehNIbMyYAa7rUpcDIdmTnz5IEIaKpHx8M7n8HcYhH6scOPAHyksrgK8xnC/fAL0veHLCUxUYKevudSCZl1QNeYn4xMkQw/ii8/JelcW3jFAFx2wPMOghbdWhg8gM6g2kCOyRazxxpulUgi/2GEtAst8G7HemhnRjK4z0vtN0lhB9V0zvQddoeh1892rr5Owj61oIw7Ya/oBtR5H21qYlB2d571Y/MmIESaUQGESRdrn+m3Zu2Nh65deQiKpg=; 25:PjIhIpRC3rFSeutKm51ItpY8EbjPVQqbD2xjtLTXtI+b9/BiKOu6/ZHsFIC+Q3/VgFaJwT2iOq71EdjiB2fy3WAWkLl0OYVdbzNtmIH9p9ElGYjBGtUc/cEn4OnwVFTx8/DCMReb1h5xg+TOtD10xIvtt+nEgOLOs/MU/j7LTXyCqc/OVnpkfuq7nPZE+esLDZOVpMgcBENtu3AS8wfh/PClvAYkXzOdRu4qvp66Uny4EbyAyPRfAPNZU//xkNjwK7hniRWZXY70zSfcobT4GR1JvJu9BSc6VTeViEcY5utnd9JOCrw1qa4YZx9lyX8TbehAsnXviHIC3cYRrLDf1g==
X-MS-TrafficTypeDiagnostic: BN6PR05MB3604:
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BN6PR05MB3604; 31:DTsC0hnnVMoK51s+xStEsSZFSybm7cRyDbuMGhzsqsyG/ORz4TiYjm8GFGY9ui2zG98T34B1WjzfOF4N+l8ncta851GBokS63PnGgx1NETarZ8FHe7f0S5k2kc7IJNnWilOr5nWpypoNqixRrhZPRkWkf9Bi9HtjlrDOv9s5QV/Dj/wDD/UOpNlzoeEzQAVsDp3LfId0Ne4rUzXGshlaaXgOiYTFX9OMXfkf8ZxxkA0=; 20: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
X-Microsoft-Antispam-PRVS: <BN6PR05MB3604A74380FB1FCFD0A46F5BA42F0@BN6PR05MB3604.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-Test: UriScan:(120809045254105);
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-CFA-Test: BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000700101)(100105000095)(100000701101)(100105300095)(100000702101)(100105100095)(6040450)(2401047)(8121501046)(5005006)(100000703101)(100105400095)(93006095)(93001095)(3002001)(10201501046)(3231022)(6055026)(6041248)(20161123560025)(20161123558100)(20161123555025)(201703131423075)(201702281528075)(201703061421075)(201703061406153)(20161123564025)(20161123562025)(6072148)(201708071742011)(100000704101)(100105200095)(100000705101)(100105500095); SRVR:BN6PR05MB3604; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000800101)(100110000095)(100000801101)(100110300095)(100000802101)(100110100095)(100000803101)(100110400095)(100000804101)(100110200095)(100000805101)(100110500095); SRVR:BN6PR05MB3604; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BN6PR05MB3604; 4:GbZreh6epRE5My64Ysj7IdrEwKSutzbVx9rwOjxv+0Yc7QBiaJBk4uJqASPOg7IqgBp8knWqUvD0O6fU5Au9mrF5RocLx0vJjoR+VcvfwfTWy92tTb+bQR/qHQPF8xd9fG24ujf5UHtDYFJ5XI09/FAe5Y0Fo7HFVeNoxpfEoVTMBcW+OFliIeCqJWubZ+PHm1Xn/U2u7ejejND4wWko+tZmCON1meRBlGr9KsTMQaBUEtJXm2pyOxwNHdj1DzGQsJu4WqvRtNoC0Jf1QMCPGHfwcs6oH3y5WMxSZfMU1gKklaxu4P46lTfwKjI/64aQ
X-Forefront-PRVS: 049486C505
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: =?us-ascii?Q?1; BN6PR05MB3604; 23:TA5J5Wkxdas42rCn0MDQMDhe196hVWir5IjeiEq5/?= =?us-ascii?Q?JymV55rA72Zn6wOC8oHUMsh1qfeKd+zKt0PsgNIJKFDpbGBMfUYOnJNgfQ/t?= =?us-ascii?Q?dkCpcW/9+3rVdVrpYJtXgBzvdS/Cbuo2uXVvmxyZZUCQJs+xAjgwzfs+bIXI?= =?us-ascii?Q?SkG+82TjcEaqSu/bLHjDIC5poBLns1ngC/5nqVZbSe47pdEq6ZJ35aM3UZyn?= =?us-ascii?Q?fuDm0PRjDFYBk3hSqWIyz10YGbTEtf+R+2hlskNkRvjvuB51C0YBigW1/dRl?= =?us-ascii?Q?lYU1dT7JogPN4kEKcEKe4s5N5MzmzVvVapaOOVGRlQLuoyF2/zi/n482T8gh?= =?us-ascii?Q?fhZrifxmdg3jOhYCace8haS08pCa/ItIvSNmKJsHxGX6e5EvK3k9dgB3S08w?= =?us-ascii?Q?iTU2uFN0jKQWYzALpylw48CMd/AKOSEbyOKLM0TJfY4kFqwUivu0jBmJ27Ev?= =?us-ascii?Q?yR+2A8m4TMxQ3VfqbGGxzoD7mlG7Ap03dwF4FR+IlDboqzssHO3NZbqF0Pa9?= =?us-ascii?Q?OZ+AoHwSchzGkIyLcLWCDqHzx0tjVz1o4yvNlEswrGq/bFUtOLwUOGBZkQsE?= =?us-ascii?Q?8NcyubP5a8HQ2vjtWjKRZf9gN0mP6RQMcrUZFpfpZnzrlgSHZLOxRYdxLAlP?= =?us-ascii?Q?ua0pm6vnb77ZFluZTqRHPzgbPLaBwWvr06O7tZ+mIlzGDXXo67IE104RNqMK?= =?us-ascii?Q?wuQB4auLisKS3rIIusFaRDCYc0wWQ7D+N/FoPzDECBn1BlTnCFd4e83W5AVi?= =?us-ascii?Q?FfEe3/ftLlGof5OCisniPXhiW0N+ztJl+P8Xq1ioD9fUcfSWKTasxB2umgum?= =?us-ascii?Q?l2KrH3CjxIz2mPjFB2BuqCKpll85z+pUPmOpE+zosoZGrm1EAyiAWgTB99fz?= =?us-ascii?Q?kuLNdSX+nXdLmvT0KoykDYE8Y8GGA5r48NUF+XENjxvM4ZUElzOpW1OOSCwf?= =?us-ascii?Q?R4RwbNidXlrIDcUk4qW13cPI1w6vtJI1AjkwmDrxBxsDF/+lhx2B2lS78Exs?= =?us-ascii?Q?byZ9gIBV55U40j4k4ByH4G69eIxL8yrmHKlsRpavB3Q79Na1rPDVoftktCVz?= =?us-ascii?Q?MlAzLWKj1Qy9SWc/g38HUtoQvhYtpcgzRJfAszwOvzaZdzMUJTeA2Hh59Bdf?= =?us-ascii?Q?yGCj82b6HBrk9aKx5YgdzgaS1Ym4B2QijznEtStV3/islYRH/NwRIh7MOWTt?= =?us-ascii?Q?znxzQQ/toXgSlBUDw0paw67rkRQcQ/x/XMI?=
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BN6PR05MB3604; 6:Q7NoZM57CmECk5LbsGFUErV9dXLGdfYaBKBpOV0bG1adQbwmMYx3dnRogBsYc7jmY0+Sjkhs5PA1EQjVwROPsv2cq+qumRi+UsYHTEJmHSv6dihvHB28ljYslQR0o5E2WSvHYTI2r/39YsAIsj5s9/OdKPmp+3LlYvNUGw8LU434SgIqLq66b76aEu3oGgPe/US28x8LVYW3OdMoiNLhXHbs78OMDw9BGqXzftNMD7t5+1FLrFUy8hTcnYpqvdf+n5S7RRRyf0vpvs1iz+STII/9DpHyETjBBfNo0jjpG7OocsyY5UWi2SV1Hd9i8K1+XsT84necgorgnaF5adVPFA0gtWIe6LaXWtUYeVQDaHU=; 5:+uq5QI/SL4+AQoxrQxyMyEziP5w75rOZsVZkDf0DlfCQ6FXzF4mYxdem2dyQgCIRplUYDKyI3n4lLv0/WruLDS1W6PtpyIG6fj9A6T+5J7yetqx/U6eIubd716rX5IDyvGbj3NQXWs34QfQb9xYkdaMGgwLCKWPHfVFywN4TTg4=; 24:iW3mB1+5SbY7LI/6yCZZ35Gz7D6YoHEjO5v9DAiXFRuFt1IjjBaUu/yZDTEKODdjC0zjkz6VYOtJVI+kmIzBayIBPzi8brAXEkCO/HwwV4A=; 7:13kV9vhekPV13sP9ijUxyU5fN9UvTPdR55aFFMan1w3RR4NnavhzafEfbVhQbcqqkXMUNPLOWX5Bom22DruL11x2W6kQuUuY97RR+n1ZViwg3IOyRM7AeNsO5T0rylxo363UYmcU0TMRkAkrb/I/f30asYn+ih5nqLUyyoJC7Oq4c++rY3iN0fSODBfO0buG0bIddheH8SZy1zPOesTJV2XIYcYq95b1q5vECT9nVsTv2hHpvYu+aCPAvVWSSWmT
SpamDiagnosticOutput: 1:99
SpamDiagnosticMetadata: NSPM
X-OriginatorOrg: juniper.net
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalArrivalTime: 17 Nov 2017 21:21:54.3902 (UTC)
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: faf5209c-d5e1-46ea-9e54-08d52e013a11
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Id: bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalAttributedTenantConnectingIp: TenantId=bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4; Ip=[66.129.239.15];  Helo=[P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net]
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-FromEntityHeader: HybridOnPrem
X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: BN6PR05MB3604
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-17_07:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=outbound_spam_notspam policy=outbound_spam score=0 priorityscore=1501 malwarescore=0 suspectscore=0 phishscore=0 bulkscore=0 spamscore=0 clxscore=1011 lowpriorityscore=0 impostorscore=0 adultscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1709140000 definitions=main-1711170287
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/C3CLTDTsJgDI4Tb-XuJbvdECdLo>
Subject: [MBONED] Singapore MBONED meeting mins
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 17 Nov 2017 21:22:11 -0000

Draft mins of the MBONED meeting in Singapore have been posted:

https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/100/materials/minutes-100-mboned/

Please take a look and let us know if you have any corrections or things 
to add.


From nobody Wed Nov 22 15:10:01 2017
Return-Path: <lenny@juniper.net>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 69B8E12EB74; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 15:10:00 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9,  DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, SPF_PASS=-0.001,  URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=juniper.net
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id PGzRbLc4qNp0; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 15:09:58 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mx0a-00273201.pphosted.com (mx0a-00273201.pphosted.com [208.84.65.16]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 8B061129AFC; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 15:09:58 -0800 (PST)
Received: from pps.filterd (m0108159.ppops.net [127.0.0.1]) by mx0a-00273201.pphosted.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vAMMXvQk020469; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 14:38:12 -0800
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=juniper.net; h=date : from : to : cc : subject : in-reply-to : message-id : references : mime-version : content-type; s=PPS1017; bh=MKKTM87UyTyY7s4UG9p3wmLai4swcotQplR5RLA/KcU=; b=zzkTzZSWYeO4jkN38a/OsfGVAbFWHky3dS8Ok8TNf8eOGz4oaskt9VE5CmZ8oYnjiK6p ftMCcvKFG02J4bn/VzvUa8RCzRy9+jdbjpTRdlL3xgvxhpTTYUpIPXON0/liYySb9jX+ BY1s3QtqfhXCDrp9w4TCpC+6/9ZhB0vduDVyUBe6FiYPK9iD1z4F8dreUh0xM+yaxPoW LQqYERdpA6xLqwV0Pm5uU4Cgjo5HFkV4cr08e7MX4N6b1YFNF3BMxFQKEGde3o6FFBy3 iibDJEbZIpPSS8J/igqjQWfo9fKhTJIgFDsJgX3KRdQCSo7HiL3fbNp0BcO1BgSRg4AZ 5w== 
Received: from nam03-by2-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-by2nam03lp0056.outbound.protection.outlook.com [216.32.180.56]) by mx0a-00273201.pphosted.com with ESMTP id 2edhkb02bx-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Wed, 22 Nov 2017 14:38:11 -0800
Received: from BN3PR05CA0040.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.174.64.50) by SN1PR0501MB2077.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.163.227.26) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384_P256) id 15.20.260.2; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 22:38:10 +0000
Received: from BY2NAM05FT051.eop-nam05.prod.protection.outlook.com (2a01:111:f400:7e52::201) by BN3PR05CA0040.outlook.office365.com (2603:10b6:400::50) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384) id 15.20.260.2 via Frontend Transport; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 22:38:10 +0000
Received-SPF: SoftFail (protection.outlook.com: domain of transitioning juniper.net discourages use of 66.129.239.15 as permitted sender)
Received: from P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (66.129.239.15) by BY2NAM05FT051.mail.protection.outlook.com (10.152.100.188) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_0, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA_P256) id 15.20.239.4 via Frontend Transport; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 22:38:09 +0000
Received: from svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (172.17.28.215) by P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net (172.24.192.21) with Microsoft SMTP Server id 14.3.123.3; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 14:38:09 -0800
Received: by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix, from userid 1709)	id 41E7F9F994; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 14:38:09 -0800 (PST)
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1])	by svl-jtac-lnx06.juniper.net (Postfix) with ESMTP id 3E2F89F979; Wed, 22 Nov 2017 14:38:09 -0800 (PST)
Date: Wed, 22 Nov 2017 14:38:09 -0800
From: Leonard Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte+ietf@cs.fau.de>
CC: <bess@ietf.org>, MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>
In-Reply-To: <DM5PR05MB31456805323BF32267D6BBEAD4200@DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
Message-ID: <alpine.DEB.2.02.1711221417300.10112@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net>
References: <20171114024232.GF19390@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <DM5PR05MB31456805323BF32267D6BBEAD4200@DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
User-Agent: Alpine 2.02 (DEB 1266 2009-07-14)
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="US-ASCII"
X-EOPAttributedMessage: 0
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-HT: Tenant
X-Forefront-Antispam-Report: CIP:66.129.239.15; IPV:NLI; CTRY:US; EFV:NLI; SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10019020)(6009001)(376002)(39860400002)(346002)(2980300002)(199003)(189002)(13464003)(51914003)(478600001)(5660300001)(46386002)(230783001)(7126002)(23726003)(53936002)(54356999)(2950100002)(45336002)(83506002)(76176999)(50986999)(106466001)(2810700001)(77096006)(6266002)(6246003)(90966002)(105596002)(229853002)(50466002)(3240700002)(356003)(305945005)(189998001)(8676002)(8936002)(81166006)(81156014)(69596002)(2906002)(68736007)(46406003)(5005980100005)(57986006)(76506005)(4326008)(47776003)(54906003)(53546010)(97736004)(16586007)(86362001)(316002)(58126008)(42262002); DIR:OUT; SFP:1102; SCL:1; SRVR:SN1PR0501MB2077; H:P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net; FPR:; SPF:SoftFail; PTR:InfoDomainNonexistent; A:1; MX:1; LANG:en; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; BY2NAM05FT051; 1:xC4wPdrTomAHP2psoo5QmbSj2K5uu9/Vos3++6EsDIz6/pK58Q4iwrKQefqpf+/hWj1hBrkKeU3ywwpVThHkEAiWyNP46T/YOPk/wbC9NsoCFSZasvvedYsKyc+tpIBC
X-MS-PublicTrafficType: Email
X-MS-Office365-Filtering-Correlation-Id: ffe28ec3-ad34-47fd-2043-08d531f9b53e
X-Microsoft-Antispam: UriScan:; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(22001)(4534020)(4602075)(4627115)(201703031133081)(201702281549075)(2017052603199); SRVR:SN1PR0501MB2077; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; SN1PR0501MB2077; 3:Vhnu/kAWWAIGJyiXbiZh2gffqwonb3iLvQStM247ySvUAoAOnlQJDR/XpDW4G4CjeyeSX4NVdT1CqrvRrWDah82Wd4y4ZeA1NzEJnOkFuZW9k1qc/hGM2hQob5AbRQd/7fU4hhCgnMUsOHDGGOAOya2ZHZFWT743HgwzzM2z9Jng/e7xlw7NCu65JlpVKYxEHZFgQbij+oE3yV/1O76Y/TD+PehKFiqnSKMf7QQrMbzMVjZkZA8JRN/u8WH3tPkhL7zze1Y8gGNnwTbkgVmss2noBZxFw6CoVMALbACfiT0YOfpI5PdTZCkxyDeGwVP03GEIMS/Ss4AEcBJB+Osd3aBVRtHnvf8vSkgAKWV5a0s=; 25:9LxanwcWNBUdM8WZELdjAeGvMTof7aY0eHYv8QnJaXrbw583QtFEXiqWFRJIsRBDcxYhlnjawiuYHjtPgkcXxqcMMblFOaRdShHBCMxgILhZ9CAyoPuRAPQooYJuOwybkFg1FaAKXxI/UiugfRbAPhWA90C4GozYTgnMteFIDA8wtW+uvAi4Skt76rpMi+iU0alAStdDtadoXqJ6ASiLjhkCmK3HZNNGkKuAiHjpqYnsyEVcfv1+pJQNy1uwrzNGqc3o9ymfUsRKAn0Reun3dIz5Feznyk5xXU+k7FTHCKwapkEdXsQ62pQPcyZIbTbVvNTZM01NraFUTcIk7GTgRA+YWICtWVhWGq/sikzg47A=
X-MS-TrafficTypeDiagnostic: SN1PR0501MB2077:
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; SN1PR0501MB2077; 31:OkG0GypyU47epIrdmEtFDRW9/3AWAjGaWdRlivsqgSAGN3ACzlqZ5P9IdyOmbJCQBiLSl5bv0ha69d3+eM3/SirLfpETFpn3aD1gF07bicAHTkThHkQsJpIRTqApFleN1/yJVujl1yidoi8z49Yx/4TCzbL4azuyQBZ0NmEZeOga7OFMFkelDQrWoPDT9pAsoabI8zJH1Ek8bwYaZvJ+ZkhlPAlnljWR3As0VQy+yAM=; 20: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
X-Microsoft-Antispam-PRVS: <SN1PR0501MB20775AA5E21675D364492F23A4200@SN1PR0501MB2077.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-Test: UriScan:;
X-Exchange-Antispam-Report-CFA-Test: BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000700101)(100105000095)(100000701101)(100105300095)(100000702101)(100105100095)(6040450)(2401047)(8121501046)(5005006)(3231022)(3002001)(93006095)(93001095)(10201501046)(100000703101)(100105400095)(6055026)(6041248)(20161123564025)(20161123560025)(20161123555025)(20161123562025)(201703131423075)(201702281528075)(201703061421075)(201703061406153)(20161123558100)(6072148)(201708071742011)(100000704101)(100105200095)(100000705101)(100105500095); SRVR:SN1PR0501MB2077; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000800101)(100110000095)(100000801101)(100110300095)(100000802101)(100110100095)(100000803101)(100110400095)(100000804101)(100110200095)(100000805101)(100110500095); SRVR:SN1PR0501MB2077; 
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; SN1PR0501MB2077; 4:gJk58KQEh5R5gRXx5IZuiFNOF15M8Cb3Y8oI4I0FaLogDIQapSkD/Iz94oCc2G0tOB12dl5kdBXTWN2CsWo6ISWpF/Y+E2zBgGRKcpyaLsEvuiJyxgte5ai0rRCgsxqjVe9vxu/9J2sr3JzFb9JDfSnXfStlCzYvdzkuzeNnah5YF3Pe1YvSYFWY2WwZLQ/Lu5Lawh278KrK5vjSfPEXr6zs4Y8va9buHD1YpEb5uZKhG4WOKEB3tOoS9934vwgiceP+hUhakdmbSVEC4UpJXQ==
X-Forefront-PRVS: 0499DAF22A
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: =?us-ascii?Q?1; SN1PR0501MB2077; 23:BKgiYaqG2h3SHYN/W5nAAWaMCGVB6UaIDAzb8rR?= =?us-ascii?Q?gWLi2nPbDmXoZIVOnRcgTpZDyvxV45AJxfwbK//EVYz/B8H7ZPsVyeGKM445?= =?us-ascii?Q?Lz0peL9gJM/o5/1GW9pLq9wpU2u97SvFPOqELfcppl/Wms+jTnWgu9u+Puwr?= =?us-ascii?Q?tPOQGyMc0BNQbSPbdsBd8JydYVXmHt//W0q2ftcSSbg7wYi8rDsuP4d5ANH3?= =?us-ascii?Q?vwegqJdhm9Uwqs2iioQ/zwAHsS5z6U78BqFb1rMVKivSULpiTxIJJxZb4dno?= =?us-ascii?Q?adaALoJu8Vqq2066jzTSoqJzM+IvH/Mp0E7uaEW1+cpyD0hHrRNbfbxGlGr7?= =?us-ascii?Q?I7tT0E5ZI9dIdJCaygbyQN89Z4azDhX5G4H4qeP1MvZ//NGGQnnKEELbMwKv?= =?us-ascii?Q?P1Jyd0n4PIbfocme6h3YxmnEBn9sZJDuCBWTzo5+V8WDAbslWnagGS9UkCe6?= =?us-ascii?Q?wqvL6XmOTTmX26ItLReh7FePMJYtXB8pmJMy1OBw54SlChOQBmYPCZjQWRr3?= =?us-ascii?Q?C7sQl9cKmfM7OzqxfVZGm5Aw+vt45ckZPmhGa3iCWNKfp5HBarIkpFuG83BG?= =?us-ascii?Q?skWnlKsYrPUMFDZwkfVTnGJzKTXI2/rz+ilWx7JKnLMhdU+6gUYNdC0EpbDo?= =?us-ascii?Q?xxR7ybqME/S47J9g78PhnQeOdJJxeBEuxLbjGNDHrjByE/HmjFKXM+VWg7Hb?= =?us-ascii?Q?KuKjZw+e4m9cx9atIgwrG3Z7tmjGF/of0aZskuKQ1p7+WeyTKFuCz2Nr8Gbn?= =?us-ascii?Q?P1yWhSqOi/eJY2jtkKvDgNkng/cl1CKCGRsjmb7wwC6EG4VFy2BF64gv83OY?= =?us-ascii?Q?tn1nmMhiOcXUojov8Srsy/4zPawS9GG9glbAa/UcwKcMdbsYIAnKugJRT/B7?= =?us-ascii?Q?Clp4k+PTqRNfqXsR7eLNIzSy4/g4MXvht+nRWkpElu0MplJkowEFJx/u/6g1?= =?us-ascii?Q?Amkkyk6mgMgMnYqYYnvY6/a0vxnzHXGXnHBiZXmFFuZjNnmHZIaehbIqpwFZ?= =?us-ascii?Q?IlGSVQyhBzZ0K7e8kmK+kB/yAmRuxD/fELVjA7yL84BeUvMWbd17kVp9amxv?= =?us-ascii?Q?Fo3oa/0J5Dl40yk3rLzVgzCCxq8YSrB+6I1/zwXGWK7vhLJ5+Ay+hIDtPdZ2?= =?us-ascii?Q?0jCOGQbN9rK9EwfMZ9/BCdnRAGsX+9jswcSelzeOKi7iD7EF065YhX5y3nly?= =?us-ascii?Q?edvRIb9zZkSzCCvcQsX8dgegvKMh8oV2xWQR6jhfl2TJTYsVVeTCpw9423RP?= =?us-ascii?Q?rRpQ8xoXcuHBfQMR7GuUQVR4mrZ5jx1x6J+5OcPoBONnjLEffym8rqxZgMt1?= =?us-ascii?Q?ygxi7fIqw9cn1YLfdJaS2UU4=3D?=
X-Microsoft-Exchange-Diagnostics: 1; SN1PR0501MB2077; 6:DqT3PbJELxEZiDmv6FLViNayl3JYC+4mSQhl0SH6enG4sSHNsKseJqnfNigdf2vW2OP1FwZVZw+K+E7jfuJCfpoCAp/sDDuEHMrJXIHu60mO/zFu855OEH3q3ScE2F6ff3pvmndl0dcg4H4WBqouhblqp72oRcpzq4A9hA3ZrMKaJyUfhEqLojoneyWPh4mttNzT5O3M89vwjr4g9ib5VXvhYf16YsIU3U9St5bU+vBoOBgDt9cnxVJvKqrMsw0p0IN50m8IKOTrB/3ZB0TlazhBYUwpBfufEtLjtpcV6WX2X7t/kx3HNbd1U7FYQUEIhg68tV4574l6hi5RGIYSxD/GhQfc+qSwv8bVkls9aC8=; 5:Ps7DkKbecFkw31AdO0pWtpOKmqSS3rAiDi2V1CHknO9RDkygK9/rUR5/MySBgFR88xdSffgmyCY9GYJIGxAP1+i0MH5rJswLU8aNPEqZF4BudMhDFLCFtZ1LaeYHO46JXwOWtlhE52rRwwgCetF5cNY2HHysxG1o3U2gf3hjTCw=; 24:G+sQoILVKVmD/CHQDlfIiVJu54MZtOPbo64JsilvGQ2EFuuYVAvq25gJSIgZ/Y1nP7enP1NVZAIiQ4L8LF9he3nnIeBByQkkxYsF+vB6mu4=; 7:oDKLyJ0qab5QeO3AiwEfPL8BaItoPVcT/hhpga4vinLf18nwGmqpNK9W+ct6ExsvyE0RgIRP2R0GbzwBKNbWOUGs+6Ak5s7oK2SisN3KYGyXhrxaAKieUkFU6T3oIg6yVys+FyogUVkXiJ0sSeEgryzzTs2EqdhUjZGaAE0VrcdfrhYJLCbmcF/PzHcEjAhcaQIonk2gUn6SjBw/1KdUzzNsS/MW+dGAK5VYxUgAGi1PwtHVCRcd0rYXtBdYcPWo
SpamDiagnosticOutput: 1:99
SpamDiagnosticMetadata: NSPM
X-OriginatorOrg: juniper.net
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalArrivalTime: 22 Nov 2017 22:38:09.7814 (UTC)
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: ffe28ec3-ad34-47fd-2043-08d531f9b53e
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Id: bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-OriginalAttributedTenantConnectingIp: TenantId=bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4; Ip=[66.129.239.15];  Helo=[P-EMFE01C-SAC.jnpr.net]
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-FromEntityHeader: HybridOnPrem
X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: SN1PR0501MB2077
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-22_06:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=outbound_spam_notspam policy=outbound_spam score=0 priorityscore=1501 malwarescore=0 suspectscore=0 phishscore=0 bulkscore=0 spamscore=0 clxscore=1011 lowpriorityscore=0 impostorscore=0 adultscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1709140000 definitions=main-1711220298
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/OkxOgHL6jfG0UhoISsOo--WP1BU>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Wed, 22 Nov 2017 23:10:00 -0000

Toerless,

Thanks for the comments.  After thinking about your feedback on RFC4610 a 
bit, I'm not sure that case is applicable here.  Consider the 2 directions 
of interworking:

1) MSDP SA/AnycastRP_PIM_Register -> MVPN SA

2) MVPN SA -> MSDP SA/AnycastRP_PIM_Register

As I understand, #1 is already covered by RFC6513/6514.  #2 is the missing 
piece that this draft attempts to address.  I don't believe #2 will be 
applicable for RFC4610, as these registers only go to members of the RP 
set.  And the RP set should be configured on all the C-RPs.  It wouldn't 
make much sense to have these registers transit the MVPN domain to go to 
an AnycastRP not in the configured RP set.

Hope this is clear, and let me know if I'm missing anything.

-Lenny

| -----Original Message-----
| From: BESS [mailto:bess-bounces@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Toerless Eckert
| Sent: Monday, November 13, 2017 9:43 PM
| To: bess@ietf.org
| Cc: mboned@ietf.org
| Subject: [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
| 
| Jeffrey presented subject draft in mboned. Given how i am
| not usually tracking BESS WG mailing list and may not be around:
| 
| I would like to see subject draft to be adopted as a WG document in BESS
| and become an update to RFC6514 (not to say bugfix ;-).
| 
| Feeedback detail: The draft should be amended to fix the same problem not only for
| MSDP SA but also RFC4610 and probably accordingly change the draft name.
| 
| Cross-posted to mboned (sorry) because there where a couple of MBoned
| participants expressing support for the draft in BESS and may like me not
| be BESS regulars.
| 
| Cheers
|     Toerless


From nobody Thu Nov 23 22:30:57 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 3F8C7129AE9; Thu, 23 Nov 2017 22:30:49 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.198
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.198 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 7Tlpe5gVVH-C; Thu, 23 Nov 2017 22:30:47 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id DED27129AEB; Thu, 23 Nov 2017 22:30:46 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [131.188.34.77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 3939E58C4B9; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 07:30:42 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 118EEB0D273; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 07:30:41 +0100 (CET)
Date: Fri, 24 Nov 2017 07:30:41 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: Leonard Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>
Cc: Toerless Eckert <tte+ietf@cs.fau.de>, bess@ietf.org, MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171124063041.GA21793@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <20171114024232.GF19390@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <DM5PR05MB31456805323BF32267D6BBEAD4200@DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1711221417300.10112@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <alpine.DEB.2.02.1711221417300.10112@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/r29yGA_s--fG5zBZZ-WZEo_s7OY>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 24 Nov 2017 06:30:49 -0000

Hi Lenny,

a) I was asking Jeffrey in the WG meeting if he saw any difference
   between MSDP and 4610 wrt. to the applicability of your draft, and
   he also said no (as i think too), thats where this originated.

b) Wrt to your contentions below:

   1) I agree, #1 is covered - for both MVPN SA and rfc4610 register
   messages according to rfc6514, 14.1.

   2) Let first make the argument where MSDP and rfc4610 operate equally:
   when you configure an MSDP mesh group. If all the non-PE RPs in an
   MVPN C domain are either an MSDP mesh group or an rfc4610 RP-set
   (same function, different names), then you could just add some PE
   as members of the MSDP mesh group or the RFC4610 RP-set and that
   would work "fine" without extending rfc6514 14.1, aka: those PEs
   would learn active C (S,G) and distribute it to all other PE, and
   they would not need to send any (S,G) SA/register messages back to the
   non-PE mesh group/rp-set because those RPs already have all state
   they need. And, as your draft says, as soon as you add more than
   one PE this way, you have multiple PEs that will send to all other
   PEs all active C (S,G) state info. And its kinda difficult to figure
   out how much redundancy one wants to set up that way.

   So, the model that i thought your draft meant to establish is one
   where you would avoid having to build a mesh-group/RP-set across all
   non-PE RPs in a large network:

   You would logically have a per-MVPN-site mesh-group/RP-set between
   the PEs of that site (one or more) and one or more non-PE RP. 
   Whenenver a PE receives an MVPN SA that comes from another site,
   it would forward it to the other non-PE members of this mesh-group/RP-set,
   and your new draft section 3 would permit this type of source check
   (i am not completeley through understanding that part of your draft).

   So, that would be a very scaleable setup as soon as you have
   non-PE RPs in the MVPN.

   3) MSDP of course has setup options not shared with rfc6410, aka:
   any setup that is more than a mesh-group. If you intended for the
   draft to also apply to such cases, it would be great to give
   examples of the so tht one can check if/how the proposed spec in your
   draft would work in the fce of those cases existing MSDP RPF rules
   (which can of course be quite complex).

3) Btw: It would be good if you would add some picture to your draft
   starting from section 2 to illustrate your text example PE1, PE2
   and so on.

   Also, your draft says:

     [RFC6514] only specifies that a PE receiving the MVPN SA routes, say
     PE2, will advertise (C-S,C-G) C-multicast routes if it has
     corresponding (C-*,C-G) state learnt from its CE

   can you point me to the text in 6514 that says that ?

Cheers
    Toerless

On Wed, Nov 22, 2017 at 02:38:09PM -0800, Leonard Giuliano wrote:
> Toerless,
> 
> Thanks for the comments.  After thinking about your feedback on RFC4610 a 
> bit, I'm not sure that case is applicable here.  Consider the 2 directions 
> of interworking:
> 
> 1) MSDP SA/AnycastRP_PIM_Register -> MVPN SA
> 
> 2) MVPN SA -> MSDP SA/AnycastRP_PIM_Register
> 
> As I understand, #1 is already covered by RFC6513/6514.  #2 is the missing 
> piece that this draft attempts to address.  I don't believe #2 will be 
> applicable for RFC4610, as these registers only go to members of the RP 
> set.  And the RP set should be configured on all the C-RPs.  It wouldn't 
> make much sense to have these registers transit the MVPN domain to go to 
> an AnycastRP not in the configured RP set.
> 
> Hope this is clear, and let me know if I'm missing anything.
> 
> -Lenny
> 
> | -----Original Message-----
> | From: BESS [mailto:bess-bounces@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Toerless Eckert
> | Sent: Monday, November 13, 2017 9:43 PM
> | To: bess@ietf.org
> | Cc: mboned@ietf.org
> | Subject: [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
> | 
> | Jeffrey presented subject draft in mboned. Given how i am
> | not usually tracking BESS WG mailing list and may not be around:
> | 
> | I would like to see subject draft to be adopted as a WG document in BESS
> | and become an update to RFC6514 (not to say bugfix ;-).
> | 
> | Feeedback detail: The draft should be amended to fix the same problem not only for
> | MSDP SA but also RFC4610 and probably accordingly change the draft name.
> | 
> | Cross-posted to mboned (sorry) because there where a couple of MBoned
> | participants expressing support for the draft in BESS and may like me not
> | be BESS regulars.
> | 
> | Cheers
> |     Toerless

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de


From nobody Fri Nov 24 06:27:03 2017
Return-Path: <zzhang@juniper.net>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id CD37B12894A; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 06:26:56 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9,  DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, SPF_PASS=-0.001,  URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: ietfa.amsl.com (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=juniper.net
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 5mcmNxz-FyY9; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 06:26:50 -0800 (PST)
Received: from mx0b-00273201.pphosted.com (mx0b-00273201.pphosted.com [67.231.152.164]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id EBB961288B8; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 06:26:49 -0800 (PST)
Received: from pps.filterd (m0108161.ppops.net [127.0.0.1]) by mx0b-00273201.pphosted.com (8.16.0.21/8.16.0.21) with SMTP id vAOEOFBv025680; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 06:26:42 -0800
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=juniper.net; h=from : to : cc : subject : date : message-id : references : in-reply-to : content-type : content-transfer-encoding : mime-version; s=PPS1017; bh=y06b2i7gN7PBKEiKeRAeQV8vNrqwCGizvtziKcgL//s=; b=CqiIO9XQWaBgPvyb1Q+dWdKGuKkjmYjXPR4QkvDsM4FSFmpzjtI0yxMOfvN/SoPQBa6t lu3V83gmaKO46gUjg+WKS/Zw3tjONDda6N90ryq7TymnL2DhT81jcFcGVm314eljVRq7 MvdRFfGQk7ImvJRaJWILqBA9wtwq1L9lV2z8zZYLETBA6tP/TEUnn5RNQPgnzVujXou5 OJsfbWsxL48WCBd8ZRBe1iT0LTe0tX1bBGIpP7mF5qNPn2zpb4lGCMb8guYzVrmoM1L6 nWckKRDX6u93eTG7JrJpIfNIu1eBosuKIhb+7XFUPNZlHBtivdbeo3bXW1Np9nSoS7uA BQ== 
Received: from nam01-by2-obe.outbound.protection.outlook.com (mail-by2nam01lp0177.outbound.protection.outlook.com [216.32.181.177]) by mx0b-00273201.pphosted.com with ESMTP id 2eegkvgjqf-1 (version=TLSv1.2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES256-SHA384 bits=256 verify=NOT); Fri, 24 Nov 2017 06:26:42 -0800
Received: from DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.173.219.15) by BY2PR0501MB2070.namprd05.prod.outlook.com (10.163.197.152) with Microsoft SMTP Server (version=TLS1_2, cipher=TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_CBC_SHA384_P256) id 15.20.260.2; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 14:26:39 +0000
Received: from DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com ([10.173.219.15]) by DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com ([10.173.219.15]) with mapi id 15.20.0282.002; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 14:26:40 +0000
From: "Jeffrey (Zhaohui) Zhang" <zzhang@juniper.net>
To: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>, Lenny Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>
CC: MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>, Toerless Eckert <tte+ietf@cs.fau.de>, "bess@ietf.org" <bess@ietf.org>
Thread-Topic: [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
Thread-Index: AQHTXPJFRb/XpCS5yk+cPU93+HFWMKMg0JcwgAA6qICAAhZbgIAAe5tQ
Date: Fri, 24 Nov 2017 14:26:39 +0000
Message-ID: <DM5PR05MB31452E571F227E67EEC50C95D4260@DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
References: <20171114024232.GF19390@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <DM5PR05MB31456805323BF32267D6BBEAD4200@DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1711221417300.10112@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <20171124063041.GA21793@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
In-Reply-To: <20171124063041.GA21793@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
Accept-Language: en-US
Content-Language: en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 
x-originating-ip: [66.129.241.13]
x-ms-publictraffictype: Email
x-microsoft-exchange-diagnostics: 1; BY2PR0501MB2070; 6:k+ElBlTbKSc71j6YftKyWlISEGkv2hIZCMWHFK+WcXr9w9807rmczzaxPKT87PZcFQpOojn/gdSa5V0LwxJuagM+rgxXGaeWHlunxGKVJw7S9+DTkNj17EqXbwpSTIA6RZL0ib1I/fvi4W0akoGoz8r1nYeghI1sA9mFpgZP4+rw5ByA8C+5ndOznYnJPYlH+2IGM2YGCeypEKTlhSvoyrZHFqsVPOIVHIK1ATfbpRdVzkPb/+dFurRH1FxvUI0PxRY402Pnd+LfQTnOUHjFfS2/JJ5B0pvXNNhhblhj7h2/8l0YQJ9MADRt43ti3ZHyzer7Mx+mU5Wukl5g5wtSdF5N8Rnyjr8kaBXk8X9l/0E=; 5:QzQCv/ZzcfeG13SMTwq+zvk3puGJVRPHiWxzogRLuowxyylZflPjuPbn4PMYAvN22/oM3KpBxI4PcuHZHtJi9hL8yIZDKLs2qfzLXAAKDiX44ut2lCS3+CcPddHli9jnxgoKnW0LfGlygweFn1yZ3d0HZinbkOQa+ATWkUx1JZo=; 24:ZgZEUzcBUyL3S94WH+zXROMD+Cnx3KEJ0vburbdouHanP0CTKqTVsK5FG7kngzhVqt4O6ZYeafk9r8Eg8GhVMzpEmSaJY4FYiycGN/Hsmgo=; 7:2CYph9oGLAOL37T1/A6zNDDGnRQum/vgYd8W+D22Kb6p0GeJodr2VjuVPF5w2VjpwOQlPO9RIQlxGWHdMJYyWPv8NEvArLrTodui6EZhxew4xC6Bt+79RYR92aYJ2gQkU6bHpKfiCvE93+zCSNoZKEOEgYvHym+SSpzlysqhHEQvWU4ubQN4d9aycwZfk2ljC9b47K9pPttMBej3c6oSqU7egqVG1ls5V5fxQx3z1ce7V5ns60NAn3kWdelM9g64
x-ms-exchange-antispam-srfa-diagnostics: SSOS;
x-ms-office365-filtering-ht: Tenant
x-microsoft-antispam: UriScan:; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(4534020)(4602075)(4627115)(201703031133081)(201702281549075)(48565401081)(2017052603258); SRVR:BY2PR0501MB2070; 
x-ms-traffictypediagnostic: BY2PR0501MB2070:
x-ms-office365-filtering-correlation-id: 1f688115-d6ef-4bf2-4212-08d5334760a9
x-microsoft-antispam-prvs: <BY2PR0501MB2070927C995EEF70BAF6DA86D4260@BY2PR0501MB2070.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
x-exchange-antispam-report-test: UriScan:(10436049006162)(138986009662008);
x-exchange-antispam-report-cfa-test: BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(6040450)(2401047)(5005006)(8121501046)(3002001)(93006095)(93001095)(10201501046)(3231022)(6055026)(6041248)(20161123558100)(20161123555025)(201703131423075)(201702281528075)(201703061421075)(201703061406153)(20161123562025)(20161123564025)(20161123560025)(6072148)(201708071742011); SRVR:BY2PR0501MB2070; BCL:0; PCL:0; RULEID:(100000803101)(100110400095); SRVR:BY2PR0501MB2070; 
x-forefront-prvs: 05015EB482
x-forefront-antispam-report: SFV:NSPM; SFS:(10019020)(6009001)(376002)(346002)(366004)(39860400002)(24454002)(199003)(13464003)(51914003)(189002)(54906003)(110136005)(6116002)(3846002)(102836003)(575784001)(86362001)(6306002)(8676002)(9686003)(81166006)(81156014)(14454004)(229853002)(55016002)(53936002)(93886005)(97736004)(189998001)(4326008)(7696005)(2900100001)(99286004)(106356001)(230783001)(7736002)(305945005)(5660300001)(6506006)(105586002)(6246003)(1941001)(74316002)(3280700002)(3660700001)(76176999)(54356999)(25786009)(66066001)(6436002)(50986999)(966005)(53546010)(68736007)(8936002)(2906002)(316002)(77096006)(101416001)(478600001)(33656002)(2950100002)(6636002); DIR:OUT; SFP:1102; SCL:1; SRVR:BY2PR0501MB2070; H:DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com; FPR:; SPF:None; PTR:InfoNoRecords;  A:1; MX:1; LANG:en; 
received-spf: None (protection.outlook.com: juniper.net does not designate permitted sender hosts)
spamdiagnosticoutput: 1:99
spamdiagnosticmetadata: NSPM
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-OriginatorOrg: juniper.net
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-Network-Message-Id: 1f688115-d6ef-4bf2-4212-08d5334760a9
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-originalarrivaltime: 24 Nov 2017 14:26:39.9411 (UTC)
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-fromentityheader: Hosted
X-MS-Exchange-CrossTenant-id: bea78b3c-4cdb-4130-854a-1d193232e5f4
X-MS-Exchange-Transport-CrossTenantHeadersStamped: BY2PR0501MB2070
X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:, , definitions=2017-11-24_05:, , signatures=0
X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=outbound_spam_notspam policy=outbound_spam score=0 priorityscore=1501 malwarescore=0 suspectscore=0 phishscore=0 bulkscore=0 spamscore=0 clxscore=1011 lowpriorityscore=0 impostorscore=0 adultscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx scancount=1 engine=8.0.1-1709140000 definitions=main-1711240196
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/2QM1VgM3pPvraE994zeRRc8ba30>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 24 Nov 2017 14:26:57 -0000

Hi Toerless,

> -----Original Message-----
> From: BESS [mailto:bess-bounces@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Toerless Eckert
> Sent: Friday, November 24, 2017 1:31 AM
> To: Lenny Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>
> Cc: MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>; Toerless Eckert <tte+ietf@cs.fau.de>;
> bess@ietf.org
> Subject: Re: [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
>=20
> Hi Lenny,
>=20
> a) I was asking Jeffrey in the WG meeting if he saw any difference
>    between MSDP and 4610 wrt. to the applicability of your draft, and
>    he also said no (as i think too), thats where this originated.

On the spot I did make a mistake that I thought with 4610 the RPs would pro=
pagate registers (received from a C-RP) to another :-) Lenny caught that.

>=20
> b) Wrt to your contentions below:
>=20
>    1) I agree, #1 is covered - for both MVPN SA and rfc4610 register
>    messages according to rfc6514, 14.1.
>=20
>    2) Let first make the argument where MSDP and rfc4610 operate equally:
>    when you configure an MSDP mesh group. If all the non-PE RPs in an
>    MVPN C domain are either an MSDP mesh group or an rfc4610 RP-set
>    (same function, different names), then you could just add some PE
>    as members of the MSDP mesh group or the RFC4610 RP-set and that
>    would work "fine" without extending rfc6514 14.1, aka: those PEs
>    would learn active C (S,G) and distribute it to all other PE, and
>    they would not need to send any (S,G) SA/register messages back to the
>    non-PE mesh group/rp-set because those RPs already have all state
>    they need. And, as your draft says, as soon as you add more than
>    one PE this way, you have multiple PEs that will send to all other
>    PEs all active C (S,G) state info. And its kinda difficult to figure
>    out how much redundancy one wants to set up that way.

Correct.

>=20
>    So, the model that i thought your draft meant to establish is one
>    where you would avoid having to build a mesh-group/RP-set across all
>    non-PE RPs in a large network:

Not to "avoid" -- just to make it work (better) -- when there is no such me=
sh-group/RP-set across all non-PE RPs, by making all RP-PEs into an MSDP me=
sh-group of their own (though replacing MSDP session with BGP-MVPN session)=
.

>=20
>    You would logically have a per-MVPN-site mesh-group/RP-set between
>    the PEs of that site (one or more) and one or more non-PE RP.

And the RP-PEs will be in their own "core" mesh.

>    Whenenver a PE receives an MVPN SA that comes from another site,
>    it would forward it to the other non-PE members of this mesh-group/RP-=
set,
>    and your new draft section 3 would permit this type of source check
>    (i am not completeley through understanding that part of your draft).
>=20
>    So, that would be a very scaleable setup as soon as you have
>    non-PE RPs in the MVPN.
>=20
>    3) MSDP of course has setup options not shared with rfc6410, aka:
>    any setup that is more than a mesh-group. If you intended for the
>    draft to also apply to such cases,

Yes.

>    it would be great to give
>    examples of the so tht one can check if/how the proposed spec in your
>    draft would work in the fce of those cases existing MSDP RPF rules
>    (which can of course be quite complex).

Yes more text would help. The idea is that MVPN SA messages would just be t=
reated as MSDP SAs from the PE that originated the SAs. Those MSDP SAs rece=
ived from true MSDP peers and those treated as MSDP SAs would follow the ex=
isting MSDP rules.

>=20
> 3) Btw: It would be good if you would add some picture to your draft
>    starting from section 2 to illustrate your text example PE1, PE2
>    and so on.

Sure.

>=20
>    Also, your draft says:
>=20
>      [RFC6514] only specifies that a PE receiving the MVPN SA routes, say
>      PE2, will advertise (C-S,C-G) C-multicast routes if it has
>      corresponding (C-*,C-G) state learnt from its CE
>=20
>    can you point me to the text in 6514 that says that ?

The full text is the following:

14.2.  Receiver(s) within a Site

   ...

   When (as a result of receiving PIM messages from one of its CEs) a PE
   creates, in one of its MVPN-TIBs, a (new) (C-*,C-G) entry with a non-
   empty outgoing interface list that contains one or more PE-CE
   interfaces, the PE MUST check if it has any matching Source Active
   A-D routes.  If there is one or more such matching routes, and the
   best path to C-S carried in the matching route(s) is reachable
   through some other PE, then for each such route the PE MUST originate
   a Source Tree Join C-multicast route.  If there is one or more such
   matching routes, and the best path to C-S carried in the matching
   route(s) is reachable through a CE connected to the PE, then for each
   such route the PE MUST originate a PIM Join (C-S,C-G) towards the CE.

   When, as a result of receiving a new Source Active A-D route, a PE
   updates its VRF with the route, the PE MUST check if the newly
   received route matches any (C-*,C-G) entries.  If there is a matching
   entry, and the best path to C-S carried in the (A-D) route is
   reachable through some other PE, the PE MUST originate a Source Tree
   Join C-multicast route for the (C-S,C-G) carried by the route.  If
   there is a matching entry, and the best path to C-S carried in the
   (A-D) route is reachable through a CE connected to the PE, the PE
   MUST originate a PIM Join (C-S,C-G) towards the CE.

Jeffrey

>=20
> Cheers
>     Toerless
>=20
> On Wed, Nov 22, 2017 at 02:38:09PM -0800, Leonard Giuliano wrote:
> > Toerless,
> >
> > Thanks for the comments.  After thinking about your feedback on RFC4610=
 a
> > bit, I'm not sure that case is applicable here.  Consider the 2 directi=
ons
> > of interworking:
> >
> > 1) MSDP SA/AnycastRP_PIM_Register -> MVPN SA
> >
> > 2) MVPN SA -> MSDP SA/AnycastRP_PIM_Register
> >
> > As I understand, #1 is already covered by RFC6513/6514.  #2 is the miss=
ing
> > piece that this draft attempts to address.  I don't believe #2 will be
> > applicable for RFC4610, as these registers only go to members of the RP
> > set.  And the RP set should be configured on all the C-RPs.  It wouldn'=
t
> > make much sense to have these registers transit the MVPN domain to go t=
o
> > an AnycastRP not in the configured RP set.
> >
> > Hope this is clear, and let me know if I'm missing anything.
> >
> > -Lenny
> >
> > | -----Original Message-----
> > | From: BESS [mailto:bess-bounces@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Toerless Ecker=
t
> > | Sent: Monday, November 13, 2017 9:43 PM
> > | To: bess@ietf.org
> > | Cc: mboned@ietf.org
> > | Subject: [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
> > |
> > | Jeffrey presented subject draft in mboned. Given how i am
> > | not usually tracking BESS WG mailing list and may not be around:
> > |
> > | I would like to see subject draft to be adopted as a WG document in B=
ESS
> > | and become an update to RFC6514 (not to say bugfix ;-).
> > |
> > | Feeedback detail: The draft should be amended to fix the same problem
> not only for
> > | MSDP SA but also RFC4610 and probably accordingly change the draft
> name.
> > |
> > | Cross-posted to mboned (sorry) because there where a couple of MBoned
> > | participants expressing support for the draft in BESS and may like me=
 not
> > | be BESS regulars.
> > |
> > | Cheers
> > |     Toerless
>=20
> --
> ---
> tte@cs.fau.de
>=20
> _______________________________________________
> BESS mailing list
> BESS@ietf.org
> https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=3Dhttps-
> 3A__www.ietf.org_mailman_listinfo_bess&d=3DDwICAg&c=3DHAkYuh63rsuhr6Scbf
> h0UjBXeMK-
> ndb3voDTXcWzoCI&r=3Df7wsLGcfzAWDNS6XNTBZwj_OLAOsZZqdrR2IDAzeZqE&
> m=3DhQz-NA6r7ahWKqMy6aI7ZXX5lvGX1ubRovr3Co5_VNE&s=3DrC5k8JOSHYD-
> XaNaPGxhtl-yyDQhzqd909XjwXnS5EI&e=3D


From nobody Fri Nov 24 07:22:04 2017
Return-Path: <eckert@i4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
X-Original-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Delivered-To: mboned@ietfa.amsl.com
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTP id 456A012895E; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 07:21:57 -0800 (PST)
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at amsl.com
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -4.198
X-Spam-Level: 
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-4.198 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_MED=-2.3, URIBL_BLOCKED=0.001] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Received: from mail.ietf.org ([4.31.198.44]) by localhost (ietfa.amsl.com [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id VArSVyC5arrs; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 07:21:54 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:40]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher AECDH-AES256-SHA (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by ietfa.amsl.com (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 15294128891; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 07:21:53 -0800 (PST)
Received: from faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de [IPv6:2001:638:a000:4134::ffff:77]) by faui40.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix) with ESMTP id 4D46158C4FF; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 16:21:49 +0100 (CET)
Received: by faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de (Postfix, from userid 10463) id 2D9A2B0D279; Fri, 24 Nov 2017 16:21:49 +0100 (CET)
Date: Fri, 24 Nov 2017 16:21:49 +0100
From: Toerless Eckert <tte@cs.fau.de>
To: "Jeffrey (Zhaohui) Zhang" <zzhang@juniper.net>
Cc: Lenny Giuliano <lenny@juniper.net>, MBONED WG <mboned@ietf.org>, Toerless Eckert <tte+ietf@cs.fau.de>, "bess@ietf.org" <bess@ietf.org>
Message-ID: <20171124152148.GB21793@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
References: <20171114024232.GF19390@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <DM5PR05MB31456805323BF32267D6BBEAD4200@DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com> <alpine.DEB.2.02.1711221417300.10112@svl-jtac-lnx02.juniper.net> <20171124063041.GA21793@faui40p.informatik.uni-erlangen.de> <DM5PR05MB31452E571F227E67EEC50C95D4260@DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <DM5PR05MB31452E571F227E67EEC50C95D4260@DM5PR05MB3145.namprd05.prod.outlook.com>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.21 (2010-09-15)
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/mboned/HBp73E1sAg7tXFmHFXSp_CqZoOI>
Subject: Re: [MBONED] [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
X-BeenThere: mboned@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.22
Precedence: list
List-Id: Mail List for the Mboned Working Group <mboned.ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/options/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/mboned/>
List-Post: <mailto:mboned@ietf.org>
List-Help: <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mboned>, <mailto:mboned-request@ietf.org?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Fri, 24 Nov 2017 15:21:57 -0000

On Fri, Nov 24, 2017 at 02:26:39PM +0000, Jeffrey (Zhaohui) Zhang wrote:
> > a) I was asking Jeffrey in the WG meeting if he saw any difference
> >    between MSDP and 4610 wrt. to the applicability of your draft, and
> >    he also said no (as i think too), thats where this originated.
> 
> On the spot I did make a mistake that I thought with 4610 the RPs would propagate registers (received from a C-RP) to another :-) Lenny caught that.

Ok. But the fact that it does not just means tht 4610 just acts like
an MSDP mesh group, and your draft is equally applicable to MSDP mesh
groups and therefore equally to 4610 (IMHO).

In fact, as soon as you have a setup that is not equivalent to
a mesh group, considerations for MSDP become more difficult.

[...]

> >    it would be great to give
> >    examples of the so tht one can check if/how the proposed spec in your
> >    draft would work in the fce of those cases existing MSDP RPF rules
> >    (which can of course be quite complex).
> 
> Yes more text would help. The idea is that MVPN SA messages would just be treated as MSDP SAs from the PE that originated the SAs. Those MSDP SAs received from true MSDP peers and those treated as MSDP SAs would follow the existing MSDP rules.

Right. But the problem is when you have non-PE RPs running MSDP
without mesh group, so the MSDP connectivity is set up with the assumption
that some of the RPF rules apply to avid looping MSDP SAs. Now you introduce
an MVPN core represented in that MSDP SA RPF loop prevention, and
you need to look how that will work.

I have not tried to imagine any such complex non-mesh-group seteup
because i have not see this in the real world. If you have, then it would
be great to explain that example in the draft. But if you have any
such example from the real world, i think we have a more fundamental
problem:

If there are really future important non-mesh group MSDP + MVPN examples,
that can not be converted better to mesh groups, then we have the
fundamental problem that we have no solution (yet) how to solve
such setup requirements with IPv6. Because we don't have MSDP there.
And we established it can't be converted to mesh-group. Aka: can't
be replaced with 6410.

So, i would suggest the draft distinguishes between mesh-group
and non-mesh-group MSDP setups. For the mesh-group setups, it should
be defined to work equally for MSDP and 6410. For the non-mesh group
setup we shuold vet whether that case is declared to be "non-relevant/
non-supported" because we have no evidence of need in real-world... OR
we have to solve another IPv6 issue.

Cheer
    Toerless

> > 
> > 3) Btw: It would be good if you would add some picture to your draft
> >    starting from section 2 to illustrate your text example PE1, PE2
> >    and so on.
> 
> Sure.
> 
> > 
> >    Also, your draft says:
> > 
> >      [RFC6514] only specifies that a PE receiving the MVPN SA routes, say
> >      PE2, will advertise (C-S,C-G) C-multicast routes if it has
> >      corresponding (C-*,C-G) state learnt from its CE
> > 
> >    can you point me to the text in 6514 that says that ?
> 
> The full text is the following:
> 
> 14.2.  Receiver(s) within a Site
> 
>    ...
> 
>    When (as a result of receiving PIM messages from one of its CEs) a PE
>    creates, in one of its MVPN-TIBs, a (new) (C-*,C-G) entry with a non-
>    empty outgoing interface list that contains one or more PE-CE
>    interfaces, the PE MUST check if it has any matching Source Active
>    A-D routes.  If there is one or more such matching routes, and the
>    best path to C-S carried in the matching route(s) is reachable
>    through some other PE, then for each such route the PE MUST originate
>    a Source Tree Join C-multicast route.  If there is one or more such
>    matching routes, and the best path to C-S carried in the matching
>    route(s) is reachable through a CE connected to the PE, then for each
>    such route the PE MUST originate a PIM Join (C-S,C-G) towards the CE.
> 
>    When, as a result of receiving a new Source Active A-D route, a PE
>    updates its VRF with the route, the PE MUST check if the newly
>    received route matches any (C-*,C-G) entries.  If there is a matching
>    entry, and the best path to C-S carried in the (A-D) route is
>    reachable through some other PE, the PE MUST originate a Source Tree
>    Join C-multicast route for the (C-S,C-G) carried by the route.  If
>    there is a matching entry, and the best path to C-S carried in the
>    (A-D) route is reachable through a CE connected to the PE, the PE
>    MUST originate a PIM Join (C-S,C-G) towards the CE.
> 
> Jeffrey
> 
> > 
> > Cheers
> >     Toerless
> > 
> > On Wed, Nov 22, 2017 at 02:38:09PM -0800, Leonard Giuliano wrote:
> > > Toerless,
> > >
> > > Thanks for the comments.  After thinking about your feedback on RFC4610 a
> > > bit, I'm not sure that case is applicable here.  Consider the 2 directions
> > > of interworking:
> > >
> > > 1) MSDP SA/AnycastRP_PIM_Register -> MVPN SA
> > >
> > > 2) MVPN SA -> MSDP SA/AnycastRP_PIM_Register
> > >
> > > As I understand, #1 is already covered by RFC6513/6514.  #2 is the missing
> > > piece that this draft attempts to address.  I don't believe #2 will be
> > > applicable for RFC4610, as these registers only go to members of the RP
> > > set.  And the RP set should be configured on all the C-RPs.  It wouldn't
> > > make much sense to have these registers transit the MVPN domain to go to
> > > an AnycastRP not in the configured RP set.
> > >
> > > Hope this is clear, and let me know if I'm missing anything.
> > >
> > > -Lenny
> > >
> > > | -----Original Message-----
> > > | From: BESS [mailto:bess-bounces@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Toerless Eckert
> > > | Sent: Monday, November 13, 2017 9:43 PM
> > > | To: bess@ietf.org
> > > | Cc: mboned@ietf.org
> > > | Subject: [bess] bess: draft-zzhang-bess-mvpn-msdp-sa-interoperation
> > > |
> > > | Jeffrey presented subject draft in mboned. Given how i am
> > > | not usually tracking BESS WG mailing list and may not be around:
> > > |
> > > | I would like to see subject draft to be adopted as a WG document in BESS
> > > | and become an update to RFC6514 (not to say bugfix ;-).
> > > |
> > > | Feeedback detail: The draft should be amended to fix the same problem
> > not only for
> > > | MSDP SA but also RFC4610 and probably accordingly change the draft
> > name.
> > > |
> > > | Cross-posted to mboned (sorry) because there where a couple of MBoned
> > > | participants expressing support for the draft in BESS and may like me not
> > > | be BESS regulars.
> > > |
> > > | Cheers
> > > |     Toerless
> > 
> > --
> > ---
> > tte@cs.fau.de
> > 
> > _______________________________________________
> > BESS mailing list
> > BESS@ietf.org
> > https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-
> > 3A__www.ietf.org_mailman_listinfo_bess&d=DwICAg&c=HAkYuh63rsuhr6Scbf
> > h0UjBXeMK-
> > ndb3voDTXcWzoCI&r=f7wsLGcfzAWDNS6XNTBZwj_OLAOsZZqdrR2IDAzeZqE&
> > m=hQz-NA6r7ahWKqMy6aI7ZXX5lvGX1ubRovr3Co5_VNE&s=rC5k8JOSHYD-
> > XaNaPGxhtl-yyDQhzqd909XjwXnS5EI&e=

-- 
---
tte@cs.fau.de

