Subject: [Mobike] issue summary from wglc, take 2

From: Jari Arkko <[email-masked]>
Date: Sun, 23 Oct 2005 18:52:21 +0300

Updated list:

Technical issues with proposed text but some discussion may
still be needed:

   68 - minimal conformance requirements
   60 - addresses in ike sa_init/auth

Technical issues without proposed text but discussion
has converged (or is uncontroversial)

   57 - question about initiator decides
          (we're not reversing an earlier decision. but is
          there a specific text change needed? I did not
          see it, but...)
   52 - security of address updates
   51 - spi collisions

Technical issues that have proposed text and discussion
has converged

   69 - rr requirements
          (aligning text to prior agreement on issues)
   67 - certain vs. possible changed address info
   66 - imprecise explanation of what nat cases are not supported
   63 - extensibility and payload
        (no changes needed)
   61 - version number, again
   56 - ingress filtering
          (we've already decided that unidirectional is not
          supported -- even with impacts to some ingress filtering
          cases)
   55 - mobike scope and limitations
   47 - more comments from mohan
          (or is some part still being discussed?)
   45 - clarifications on security considerations
   44 - nat changes and ike rekey

Editorial comments without proposed text

   64 - stephane's editorial issues
   59 - tero's editorial comments
          (some text exists, not all)
   58 - deleting an address
          (note: we are not reopening the discussion
          on diff/overwrite semantics. but there may be
          a clarification needed.)
   54 - marcelo's editorial comments

Editorial comments with proposed text

   65 - jari's editorial issues
        (but make sure 59 is solved too)
   62 - editorial comments from francis
   53 - editorial comments from pete
   50 - more editorial comments from maureen
   49 - editorial comments from maureen
   48 - editorial comments from james
          (mostly has text, but is some part missing?)
   46 - question about additional addresses
          (has proposed text. note that there's a link to
          one of parts of issue 68)

_______________________________________________
Mobike mailing list
[email-masked]
https://www.machshav.com/mailman/listinfo.cgi/mobike