Subject: [Mobike] issue summary from wglc

From: Jari Arkko <[email-masked]>
Date: Sat, 22 Oct 2005 20:33:31 +0300

The following is my understanding of what the issue
situation is. We need to work hard until I-D submission
deadline on monday to get all these resolved with
detailed text changes. Please comment on the issues
and continue the discussion where necessary. Most
importantly, post text.

Also, let me know if the classification below is incorrect
for some issue(s).

---

Technical issues without solution and discussion hasn't ended:

  68 - minimal conformance requirements
  63 - extensibility and payload
  60 - addresses in ike sa_init/auth

Technical issues without proposed text but discussion
has converged (or is uncontroversial)

  67 - certain vs. possible changed address info
  66 - imprecise explanation of what nat cases are not supported
  61 - version number, again
  57 - question about initiator decides
         (we're not reversing an earlier decision. but is
         there a specific text change needed? I did not
         see it, but...)
  55 - mobike scope and limitations
  52 - security of address updates
  51 - spi collisions
  45 - clarifications on security considerations
         (I will propose the remaining text)
  44 - nat changes and ike rekey
         (we just need to note the limitation, nothing else we
         can do)

Technical issues that have proposed text and discussion
has converged
 
  69 - rr requirements
         (aligning text to prior agreement on issues)
  56 - ingress filtering
         (we've already decided that unidirectional is not
         supported -- even with impacts to some ingress filtering
         cases)
  47 - more comments from mohan
         (or is some part still being discussed?)

Editorial comments without proposed text

  65 - jari's editorial issues
         (I will propose text)
  64 - stephane's editorial issues
  59 - tero's editorial comments
         (some text exists, not all)
  58 - deleting an address
         (note: we are not reopening the discussion
         on diff/overwrite semantics. but there may be
         a clarification needed.)
  54 - marcelo's editorial comments

Editorial comments with proposed text

  62 - editorial comments from francis
  53 - editorial comments from pete
  50 - more editorial comments from maureen
  49 - editorial comments from maureen
  48 - editorial comments from james
         (mostly has text, but is some part missing?)
  46 - question about additional addresses
         (has proposed text. note that there's a link to
         one of parts of issue 68)

_______________________________________________
Mobike mailing list
[email-masked]
https://www.machshav.com/mailman/listinfo.cgi/mobike